Wild West Mafia, Game#1

[Ch3tan]

Now as for the Deputy,
The deputy is awarded one role block by the sheriff

Right let us get this out of the way. This changes things.

There is a 33.3% chance that Toht is the merc, a 66.6% chance that he is not. Or if you introduce the bandit possibility, there is a 25% chance he is a merc, 25% chance he is a bandit and 50% chance he is innnocent.

On to me, as I was only roleblocked, and not protected on night one. There is a 33.3% chance I am a merc, 33.3% that I am a bandit and 33.3% that I am innocent.

 

[Will]

You do realise that makes you the best odds for lynching, Ch3t?

 

[old.Tohtori]

Ch3tan, have to say, there's no chance we're either the bandit as the first nights killing was clearly a revenge hit.

Unless the mercenary did a "cover up", which i doubt. The note that Will brought up does suggest that there's only the possibility that one of us is a merc, if we are guilty ofcourse.

Also, i'm curious on the Iceforges comment about the mercenary doing something else. Is there any record in the town halls about this? I know Mrs Olga used to study these kind of guys.(I'm going on the twist in original role list here(can't say that ic))

Levin as i've stated, yes, i know it makes me look guilty as heck. If you were jailed and there was no kill, i'd be suspicious too. It's just a shame i don't have anything to prove it to you, even if i war a tracker i wouldn't probably have but one nights info.

 

[Uara]

Statistically it would make him best bet for a lynch. But you have to ask the question would a bandit or merc purposefully make it clear that they are the best target for a lynching. Wouldnt be the smartest thing to do!

 

[old.Tohtori]

Unvote: Will

Basically yes, there's not enough to go by...

Vote: Ch3tan

Basically YES, i know if Ch3tan is innocent i'm toast.

 

[old.Tohtori]

And i know it looks like i'm trying to vote off the other "guilty guy", but honestly what else can i do? Vote for myself, or vote for someone who looks "mighty suspicious".

Only other thing i could do is vote for a nolynch, but i doubt that would look any better.

 

[Will]

I'm guessing this game has now ground to a halt. We have six active people, and we need six to lynch someone. Until everyone gets involved, this isn't going to get resolved.

 

[old.Tohtori]

I was gonna say that it would take for all of us to agree on one person, but that would mean hanging yourself...i'm too old for this sh*t....

 

[Levin]

Unless we hang one of the inactive people.. which probably wouldn't help us much either.

 

[Will]

Jimmy has the fewest posts at 13. Lets hang him.

Unvote

Vote : Jimmy

 

[Jimmy]

Jimmy has the fewest posts at 13. Lets hang him.

Unvote

Vote : Jimmy

great idea

tbh i dont think ch3t is a bandit but also he does fit to be the better person to hang/shoot

im torn really on who do go with.

 

[Uara]

Well as Ch3tan actually said himself, statistically from what we kno he is the best target to lynch, so i'm going to go with him as we don't really have much on anyone else at present.
Vote Ch3tan

 

[Jimmy]

Well as Ch3tan actually said himself, statistically from what we kno he is the best target to lynch, so i'm going to go with him as we don't really have much on anyone else at present.
Vote Ch3tan

im not sure thats a good idea why would he tell people that he is the best person to lynch if he was a bandit its silly

 

[Uara]

yeah i kno, i actually mentioned that earlier myself

Statistically it would make him best bet for a lynch. But you have to ask the question would a bandit or merc purposefully make it clear that they are the best target for a lynching. Wouldnt be the smartest thing to do!

But it could all be a double bluff, make us think he's innocent by showing the maths of it. Unfortunately there really isnt any option apart from Toht (due to what has been discussed and no other obvious target) but then that would leave me in the same position as it would be done on the stats agan.

 

[Olgaline]

You lot have a funny concept of inactive,
7 out of 10 players have posted today
9 out of 10 have posted within 24hours


Vote count:

Voting Jimmy: Will,
Voting Tohtori: Random,
Voting Levin: Ch3tan,
Voting Ch3tan: Downaneal, Uara, Tohtori

Not voting: Jimmy, Calo, Iceforge, Levin

 

[Jimmy]

yeah i kno, i actually mentioned that earlier myself


But it could all be a double bluff, make us think he's innocent by showing the maths of it. Unfortunately there really isnt any option apart from Toht (due to what has been discussed and no other obvious target) but then that would leave me in the same position as it would be done on the stats agan.

thats true but i still dont belive ch3t is a baddy

 

[Iceforge]

In this entire Toth vs. Ch3t debate, not that they are against each other, but some seem to have put up a lot of effort to make the assumption that 1 or the other of those 2 are bandits!

Now, I would like people to calm down! If BOTH of them are innocent, which is a possibility, this "1 of them has to be" mindset is going to waste 2 of our precious days, and if the scum is going lucky during those 2 nights that is 6 down for the town, 1 each day and 2 each night, leaving us with 4 alive, which means the bandit will soon be able to overpower us innocent townies!

Aren't you people forgetting that I put Old.Tohtori in that jailcell because I expected him to be a very likely target? If the bandits or mercenaries was out to get Old.Tohtori on the first night, they would have failed as he was safe and sound in the jailcell!

And if you are all wrong with this mindset of one of them got to be, the scum is laughing on the inside about how easy you are all making this for them!

 

[Ch3tan]

You lot have a funny concept of inactive,
7 out of 10 players have posted today
9 out of 10 have posted within 24hours

It's the lack of content that makes them inactive, their ability to post once and contribute nothing, not discuss any points that others are.

 

[Ch3tan]

Righto, lets get to it.

You (because I did not vote for him) got incredibly lucky on day one to find golena. It was nothing but chance and a bloodthirsty mob that got him hung/shot.

Rubric on day two, what a stupid bloodthristy bandwagon. One that I started but could not stop even though there was sod all evidence against him.

We have let the bandits run circles around us so far, and on this day no one seems to be able to focus past me and toht.

I am innocent, if you do not believe me then tuff luck, Toht you have played a stupid card by offering yourself up if I get hung, because I have no role at all. I am a plain townie.

This is ridiculous, and what is worse is those inactive people will come along and do their "one post in 24 hours" and make is a wasted vote on me.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Toht you have played a stupid card by offering yourself up if I get hung, because I have no role at all. I am a plain townie.

I didn't offer myself, i said what would most likely happen with this mentality. It seems things are calming down, but it looked very much like two guys getting hung because of only one nightkill.

 

[Jimmy]

you kind did with if ch3t turns out to be innocent then ud be next

 

[old.Tohtori]

Exactly. That's the most common expectation from the scenario, and with me thinking he could be guilty, i'm kinda up the creek without a paddle.

But, ofcourse the bad people would support that thesis so...

Unvote: Ch3tan

Need to look back a bit at you Jimmy. Ch3tan has a reason to say it as a defence, you don't.

 

[old.Tohtori]

And actually yes, checked back a few pages of the scribes writings and you support Ch3tans innocence, then support that i'm putting myself up for a vote, while otherwise flying well under the radar the whole time.

This would suggest you stay quiet for a reason, want to have the right to say "I told Ch3tan was innocent" and then have something to put against me when next day comes.

Vote: Jimmy

Hopefully i'm making sense, correct me if i'm wrong.

 

[Jimmy]

iv not stayed quite to hide anything but you go ahead and lynch me and when ur done shooting an innocent il leave my 6 shooter on the table for your self.

 

[Calo]

hej this is great!

everyone is innocent and everyone has the attitude of, kill me if you don't believe it! you'll see that 1 townie is dead then.

@ Iceforge, sure toht might be lucky that he was in jail, or he or ch3tan is the real merc, not like they gonna say it right?

I think you will have to make a smart decision for this night to see who you will block and who you will make deputy. maybe take random again and work together to make a plan to catch people?

Sure the bandits can read this, but they don't know if you really follow the plan or not.

About jimmy dunno, don't have really something on him. I'm more looking in the way of levin and will atm

 

[Jimmy]

About jimmy dunno, don't have really something on him. I'm more looking in the way of levin and will atm

reason you dont have owt on me is iv got nowt to hide

 

[Levin]

It's interesting how you're accusing Will and me, Calo, without really saying anything of why. Are we being too logical in your eyes for wanting to look where there was actually a lead? You're flying even below Jimmy on the radar at the moment and only chip in now and then with a pointy finger but no real reasoning.

And yes, of course everyone will say they are innocent. Iceforge, we've already been over what happened that night and chances and non-chances that Tohtori and/or Ch3tan may be bad guys. You're saying what has already been said. We've voted and unvoted and moved on. People want to look for the bandit instead of the merc, and it stands to reason that those two are not likely bandits unless there are two left.

Oh and whoever suggested Random again as deputy; didn't someone say you can't be deputized twice?

 

[Olgaline]

*Obs*

If a majority is not reached by Sunday night 24:00
It will be treated as a no lynch and the game will go
into night without a lynch taking place.

I also urge all players to keep in mind this is a themed game,
so try to stay in character? and for gods sake at least try to think
about if what you want to say, can be said in a way that promotes
the spirit of the game and the game univers. you all did so well on
day one. otherwise use (ooc) but also dont abuse it.

example: say you feel [playerX] is inactive, it's just as easy to say:
I havent seen the likes of [playerX] for days, or it would seem [playerX] has been out of town for a while, I dont like the feel of that. whats he up too ?

- No more Mod this mod that!
I wont confirm or unconfirm anything futher during this game, so dont ask!
if i deem something of crucial importance, I'll let you know.

- I will only react to mod, prod: [player X] and only if that player has been
inactive for more than 48hrs in wich case he'll be given 48hrs to respond.
If you as players otherwise deem someone inactive or dislike an inactive tactic,
thats your problem! Deal with it within the game mechamics, just like you would someone
too agressive, too talkative. too wiered ect. Case closed!
Any further inquiries, comments to or about this will be met with the wrath of the mod.

The Mod

 

[Ch3tan]

hej this is great!

everyone is innocent and everyone has the attitude of, kill me if you don't believe it! you'll see that 1 townie is dead then.

@ Iceforge, sure toht might be lucky that he was in jail, or he or ch3tan is the real merc, not like they gonna say it right?

I think you will have to make a smart decision for this night to see who you will block and who you will make deputy. maybe take random again and work together to make a plan to catch people?

Sure the bandits can read this, but they don't know if you really follow the plan or not.

About jimmy dunno, don't have really something on him. I'm more looking in the way of levin and will atm

If you had been around you might have noticed that you are regurgitating old points.

Iceforge chose his deputy if you had paid any attention what so ever, we have already been told the same person can not be a deputy again.

Myself and Toht have already accused Will and Levin, the difference was we at least tried to justify our actions.

Sod this, it is a waste of time arguing this any further. I would vote Down, but he has been so inactive he gives nothing to go on. On the basis you don;t even know what has been said so far, even though I still think it is a Will + Levin combo:

unvote Levin

vote Calo

 

[Ch3tan]

OOC. Ogla, it is all very well telling us to deal with inactivity, but it has ground the game to a halt and a lynch against an inactive player only helps the bandits that day. You need harder rules on activity next game.