Werewolf #15

[Ch3tan]

Flimsy evidence? Hah, it's not just the timing Dam, it's the fact he is defending Olgy with what he said. Apart from catching someone in a lie, or them coming out that is as close as we will get to good evidence.

You will know I am the vig, because I have stated my target. I already said why I wrote that there may be more than one vig. Quite simply it is because there might be.

I am really torn between shooting gohan and damini now. Jup also gives me pause.

random is the only one I am not doubting for once, and ECA and tab seem less likely. Although that may simply be because they are being relativly quiet.

vote recount please Will.

The reason I wanted to shoot olgy was because I wanted this discussion to happen. A quick day with us all simply voting olgaline would have given us no info for day three at all. By trying to get us to vote for someone else, nearly everyone has got involved.

 

[Ch3tan]

. why is Auntie Damini taking such a strong stance versus Ch3tan, who frankly I am inclined to believe as he is going to lengths to apply solid logic to aid our cause....

Fair play.... I have to lug this barrel of mead (or what's left of it by the time I arrive) to Farmer Bob's place today for an open fire hogroast, so for now I feel compelled to stick to what we know is fact.

Vote Olgaleanmeat

If Ch3t IS the vig then let Gohan's fate be in his hands... I'll not be part of lynching someone based on the weak evidence he has put forward.

So because Dam says my evidence is flimsy it just is? Why is it flimsy, give me some proof (either Jup or Dam) to support your belief in gohans innocence.

 

[Damini]

I've said why I believe it is unlikely gohan is the wolf repeatedly. If you prove you are a vigilante tonight, then I will rethink my position, but as it stands it looks to me like you are a wolf trying to protect his pack.

 

[Ch3tan]

Gohan voted for Olgaline, but switched to Sydrik. Gohan was also the person Olgaline named as innocent - as it was the last desperate roll of the dice to stay alive, I doubt he'd use his "seer" cover to protect a real wolf, because he knew there was a high chance he'd get rumbled. Of course, this could be layers of double bluffing, but I don't think so.

So you think olgy would not have played a double bluff, and that is your basis for gohan being innocent.

I really don't think Gohan is a wolf.

RE-stating what you have already said with no actual evidence.

Twist it all you like. I'm not a wolf, and from what I've seen and read, neither is gohan. So, that leaves me to think that you're a wolf Ch3tan. However, I will give you the benefit of the doubt tonight, and vote to lynch TaB, who I believe is the third wolf.

I have a hunch that you are lying, Ch3tan. I believe that the real vigilante, knowing Olgaline is a wolf, is very likely to take him out tonight - something you'd be banking on. You'd then claim that you shot Olgaline, and shift the finger of suspicion onto the vigilante, getting a stay of execution in the process.

However, I might have got it wrong. *Shrug* It's been a long day.

Fine. IF you are the vigilante, you can shoot me tonight. I think you're far more likely to eat me, personally. I've stated very clearly my reasons for why I think gohan is innocent, and it's very unusual for you to avoid looking at voting patterns and behaviour and fixate on timings instead - perhaps that was the only way you could twist it to look worse for Gohan? Of course, it's possible he's a wolf, if both he and Olgaline are very good at the double bluff, but I'm not convinced. I've also been clearly in favour of burning Olgaline since day one, so the fact you're trying to say I look suspicious just makes you look more dubious really.

Am I really the only person that isn't convinced Ch3tan is the vigilante? Seriously? Because if I'm just being a paranoid idiot, someone should pipe up and tell me.

I've said why I believe it is unlikely gohan is the wolf repeatedly. If you prove you are a vigilante tonight, then I will rethink my position, but as it stands it looks to me like you are a wolf trying to protect his pack.

You haven't actually shown any evidence to say gohan is not a wolf, and yet you call my evidence flimsy?

 

[Jimmy]

tbh gohan not voting for olg till i picked him up on it makes him more of a wolf

 

[gohan]

tbh gohan not voting for olg till i picked him up on it makes him more of a wolf

what ever shoot me then burn me then you can re-read what ive said realise im right kill random and tab and villagers still win so doesnt matter much

 

[gohan]

personally i think voting olgaline is pointless

we already know for a fact he is a wolf and we're wasting a chance to find another, even if you chose to burn me so you can see im right then shoot olgaline

 

[Damini]

So you think olgy would not have played a double bluff, and that is your basis for gohan being innocent.

You haven't actually shown any evidence to say gohan is not a wolf, and yet you call my evidence flimsy?

Part of my reasoning also includes the fact that you want him dead.

Hey ho, lets see what the morning brings. If you shoot me, then fine, if the vig shoots you, fine, I'll rethink it all if I'm still here tomorrow.

 

[ECA]

Firstly, Olgaline is used to playing OT Mafia, once you achieve a majority at any point the game is cut off there and the turn ends regardless of any vote switching.

Gohan - if we kill olgaline and let ch3t shoot whoever, its the same as if we kill whoever and let ch3t kill olgaline - unless we're getting fucked by ch3t.

I'd rather take the "anti fucked" route.

 

[gohan]

not quite

if we burn some1 as a joint decision then ch3t has to shoot olg or be uncovered as a fraud

where as if we kill olg ch3t has already said he'll shoot :
Me/ Damini / possibly Jup

all of whom i think are innocent

 

[ECA]

Yes and if ch3t is lying, more innocents die and we lose the good position we have now.

Its just dumb.

 

[gohan]

Yes and if ch3t is lying, more innocents die and we lose the good position we have now.

Its just dumb.

ye only cos he's not threatening to shoot you :<

 

[ECA]

ye only cos he's not threatening to shoot you :<

On the plus side, if ch3t doesnt shoot you tonight he's autolynched tomorrow. ( If he doesnt get vigged first ).

 

[Ch3tan]

Firstly, Olgaline is used to playing OT Mafia, once you achieve a majority at any point the game is cut off there and the turn ends regardless of any vote switching.

Will has introduced this as well, have you not noticed that as soon as the vote reaches his preset target he ends the day.

 

[Ch3tan]

Gohan - if we kill olgaline and let ch3t shoot whoever, its the same as if we kill whoever and let ch3t kill olgaline - unless we're getting fucked by ch3t.

I'd rather take the "anti fucked" route.

It is not the same. Because I convinced a few of you to unvote olgy for a while we have more time to expose another wolf. The more we talk the more likely a wolf is to slip up. Had we just voted olgy this day would be over by now. We would likely be in day 3 with an innocent slayed at night, and further away from establishing the other wolves.

taB you are being very quiet and it looks very dodgy.

 

[RandomBastard]

Talk is good and its also cheap!
It costs us nothing to debate for longer and gains us valuable Intel on the wolves!

 

[Olgaline]

vote olgaline

 

[Ch3tan]

I'm sure will banned voting for yourself in previous games. Nice try though.

 

[Olgaline]

uhm ok,
In this case I just want my dead guy forum pass really,
altho as I'm officially still alive, a ban of that seems really odd,
I'd love to hear the argument for why it's illigal to vote for one self tho?

 

[Olgaline]

Also reading back on the rules posted on day one there is No mention of this rule.

 

[Ch3tan]

I don't see why you should be able to speed up the end of this day. It can only help the wolves.

 

[Olgaline]

how is that different from a wolf putting the last vote on an innocent ?
that also only serves to help the wolvs, that argument is flawed.

I'm not dead, so by all accounts my vote is just as valid, onto who ever I wish to place it. And if we entertain your perspevtive, then one could easilly defend such an action within the confinds of role play as self sacrifice.

 

[ECA]

I don't see why you should be able to speed up the end of this day. It can only help the wolves.

I know you dont normally last this long, but wolves are not gonna magically type in their new forum post box "lolimmawolf OOPS"

 

[gohan]

lolimmawolf OOPS

GET HIM!!!!!!

have we not got 6 votes for olgaline yet? can we not burn and poke him

 

[Damini]

Where's TaB? Have we got another absentee?

 

[Will]

I think we can finally draw a line under this and lynch Olgaline.

I don't think words can describe how bad that burning hair smells.

It is now night. Please PM me your night actions.

 

[Will]

In the morning, there is only one body. After some CSI-style investigation, you eventually establish that it is your town author, Damini.

Time to vote again.

 

[Jupitus]

Scum bag.

Vote: Ch3tan

 

[ECA]

Odd there is no vigshot used, and the wolves didnt choose to eliminate ch3t to say the least, but lets not be too hasty.

( ie lets wait for jimmy ).

 

[RandomBastard]

So does this disprove ch3t as a vig? Could he be a wolf in vig's clothing?