Werewolf #15

[RandomBastard]

Wow too much whiskey and all this talk makes my head hurt.
Following ch3t is a good idea for now, if he's lieing we have two wolves to lynch.

unvote: olgaline
vote: gohan

 

[Damini]

Twist it all you like. I'm not a wolf, and from what I've seen and read, neither is gohan. So, that leaves me to think that you're a wolf Ch3tan. However, I will give you the benefit of the doubt tonight, and vote to lynch TaB, who I believe is the third wolf.

I have a hunch that you are lying, Ch3tan. I believe that the real vigilante, knowing Olgaline is a wolf, is very likely to take him out tonight - something you'd be banking on. You'd then claim that you shot Olgaline, and shift the finger of suspicion onto the vigilante, getting a stay of execution in the process.

However, I might have got it wrong. *Shrug* It's been a long day.

 

[Jupitus]

I'm as thick as a whale omelette, but even I can't believe a condemned Olga would finger another wolf.... that's why I don't think it can be Gohan next.

 

[ECA]

I dont see why we should risk killing an extra random innocent instead of a known wolf.

I agree we could "two for one" but its unlikely we'd hit the second wolf.

 

[Jupitus]

Out of character just a for a comment.... I was just re-reading this and noticed Ch3t said he thought PMs might be being exchanged. I, for one, would not condone any illicit PMs behind the scenes and if others are doing so I think it is not in the spirit of the game. As an admin, I could if I chose, read the werewolf forum, but I do not and would not do so until out of the game. Play within the rules folks, please!

 

[Damini]

unvote: TaB
vote: Olgaline

If Ch3tan is so sure Gohan is a furry, and if Ch3tan really is a vigilante, he can kill him tonight anyway. My vote for TaB can wait for further clarity in the morning.

Jimmy, good luck picking someone to cry tonight

 

[Damini]

Obviously, I meant to type scry.

 

[Rubric]

Hmmm,

Well i can confirm Jimmy is correct i am indeed innocent. Personally i think we should go with the wolf we know for sure. I think Ch3tan is wolf no.2 though and i would like Jimmy to check him out tonight. If Jimmy confirms his story then we can concentrate on the other suspects.

Votelgaline

 

[Jimmy]

(out of char)bah trying to read this on phone its hard work
my com is being broken give me till morning when I get to work to catch up and post.

 

[Ch3tan]

Twist it all you like. I'm not a wolf, and from what I've seen and read, neither is gohan. So, that leaves me to think that you're a wolf Ch3tan. However, I will give you the benefit of the doubt tonight, and vote to lynch TaB, who I believe is the third wolf.

I have a hunch that you are lying, Ch3tan. I believe that the real vigilante, knowing Olgaline is a wolf, is very likely to take him out tonight - something you'd be banking on. You'd then claim that you shot Olgaline, and shift the finger of suspicion onto the vigilante, getting a stay of execution in the process.

However, I might have got it wrong. *Shrug* It's been a long day.

I'm not twisting it, I honestly thought it was gohan and ECA. But your defence of gohan leaves me thinking it is you and gohan.

I'm as thick as a whale omelette, but even I can't believe a condemned Olga would finger another wolf.... that's why I don't think it can be Gohan next.

I realise this is unlikely, but the posts on day 1 by gohan tell their own story. Maybe olgy took the risk of naming gohan as a double bluff?

I dont see why we should risk killing an extra random innocent instead of a known wolf.

I agree we could "two for one" but its unlikely we'd hit the second wolf.

It cuts out a day, it gives the wolves less time to manouver. It is not unlikely we would hit the second wolf, the odds are in our favour. its a 1 in 5 shot right now.

Out of character just a for a comment.... I was just re-reading this and noticed Ch3t said he thought PMs might be being exchanged. I, for one, would not condone any illicit PMs behind the scenes and if others are doing so I think it is not in the spirit of the game. As an admin, I could if I chose, read the werewolf forum, but I do not and would not do so until out of the game. Play within the rules folks, please!

No jup, wolves are allowed to PM each other. I am suggesting that gohan is olgys wolf buddy so they were exchanging pm's.

unvote: TaB
vote: Olgaline

If Ch3tan is so sure Gohan is a furry, and if Ch3tan really is a vigilante, he can kill him tonight anyway. My vote for TaB can wait for further clarity in the morning.

Jimmy, good luck picking someone to cry tonight

Well you have done a good job of putting doubt in my mind, so right now I am more likely to shoot you tonight dams. Sorry.

Hmmm,

Well i can confirm Jimmy is correct i am indeed innocent. Personally i think we should go with the wolf we know for sure. I think Ch3tan is wolf no.2 though and i would like Jimmy to check him out tonight. If Jimmy confirms his story then we can concentrate on the other suspects.

Votelgaline

Rubric You have been deluded by the wolves. Jimmy would waste a scrying checking me out. The proof will be in the pudding, I will declare who I am going to shoot, and bar the doc being a wanker and blocking it. You will see that person dead in the morning. This is why I wanted us to try and find the 2nd wolf today, and let me use my bullet on the confirmed wolf. I do not want to shoot an innocent.

Oh well, I am off to bed, and then I shall be toiling the fields and drinking ale until the day of rest.

 

[ECA]

It cuts out a day, it gives the wolves less time to manouver. It is not unlikely we would hit the second wolf, the odds are in our favour. its a 1 in 5 shot right now.

Um I dont knnow how to tell you, but 1 in 5 doesnt make us a favourite, although I may want to be your bookmaker should you ever wish to gamble

By killing olgaline and not a random person, we let jimmy scry someone and be invulnerable tonight baring a werewolf blocker, so we'll get an extra innocent/guilty as well as your vig shot.


I'm also wondering if the wolves will kill you tonight or try and find the doctor so jimmy doesnt get two nights of scrying - thats a toughie for the wolves.

If they kill you, jimmy gets an extra night and you dead + 2 others scryed really makes it much more likely we'll find someone.

 

[Ch3tan]

1 in 5 is a very good chance on the 2nd day of werewolf. Will wait to see what the others have to say for themselves. But I believe my logic is sound and I only see one reason to question it.

 

[Damini]

Fine. IF you are the vigilante, you can shoot me tonight. I think you're far more likely to eat me, personally. I've stated very clearly my reasons for why I think gohan is innocent, and it's very unusual for you to avoid looking at voting patterns and behaviour and fixate on timings instead - perhaps that was the only way you could twist it to look worse for Gohan? Of course, it's possible he's a wolf, if both he and Olgaline are very good at the double bluff, but I'm not convinced. I've also been clearly in favour of burning Olgaline since day one, so the fact you're trying to say I look suspicious just makes you look more dubious really.

Am I really the only person that isn't convinced Ch3tan is the vigilante? Seriously? Because if I'm just being a paranoid idiot, someone should pipe up and tell me.

 

[Jimmy]

my head hurts after reading this.

Am I really the only person that isn't convinced Ch3tan is the vigilante? Seriously? Because if I'm just being a paranoid idiot, someone should pipe up and tell me.

no your not i had that same thought but we can test it if ch3t kills olg tonight then we know he's ch3t is the vig.
As long as the over vig dosnt shoot tonight ie dont shoot olg and dont kill ch3t if olg isnt dead then we know ch3t is a evil scum wolf.

i havnt picked who to scry tonight and im still not sure.

 

[Damini]

As ECA says, don't say who you will check, as if they are an innocent villager the wolves will just eat them and you'll have wasted a turn.

 

[ECA]

1 in 5 is a very good chance on the 2nd day of werewolf. Will wait to see what the others have to say for themselves. But I believe my logic is sound and I only see one reason to question it.

So you're argument is that we should vote for gohan and you'll kill olgaline, as opposed to us voting for olgaline and you kill gohan.

I fail to see your point, besides the fact that it lets a known wolf evade death if you're lying.

 

[Jimmy]

So you're argument is that we should vote for gohan and you'll kill olgaline, as opposed to us voting for olgaline and you kill gohan.

I fail to see your point, besides the fact that it lets a known wolf evade death if you're lying.

i think we kill olg and ch3t kill gohan works for me

 

[Jupitus]

I still think getting Ch3t to prove himself the vig by shooting Olg is a fair enough idea, if Olg isn't shot in the morning then we lynch Ch3t, BUT I am getting torn over who we should vote for if we do that. I've said my bit about Gohan already, but some of the other discussion is making me edgy... why is Auntie Damini taking such a strong stance versus Ch3tan, who frankly I am inclined to believe as he is going to lengths to apply solid logic to aid our cause....

 

[ECA]

Ch3t can prove himself vig by shooting anyone.

 

[Jupitus]

Ch3t can prove himself vig by shooting anyone.

Yes - but having ID'd a wolf that's a good target to use for proof... it's rare to have a conclusive id on a wolf and the time to then make informed choices before a lynching.

 

[Jimmy]

Yes - but having ID'd a wolf that's a good target to use for proof... it's rare to have a conclusive id on a wolf and the time to then make informed choices before a lynching.

aye its rare to have one this early this is why we should kill him now.

 

[Damini]

I still think getting Ch3t to prove himself the vig by shooting Olg is a fair enough idea, if Olg isn't shot in the morning then we lynch Ch3t, BUT I am getting torn over who we should vote for if we do that. I've said my bit about Gohan already, but some of the other discussion is making me edgy... why is Auntie Damini taking such a strong stance versus Ch3tan, who frankly I am inclined to believe as he is going to lengths to apply solid logic to aid our cause....

I'm taking such a strong stance because, quite frankly, I don't believe him.

He claims to be a vigilante, and in the same breath warns us that there could be more than one, to stop the real vigilante coming forward and revealing the lie, or maybe just the stop the real vigilante shooting him tonight by planting a seed of doubt.

By claiming to be a vigilante, he can prevent a real wolf being lynched today, and guide us towards killing an innocent villager, whilst killing another innocent villager tonight, helping level the playing field for them. If he's so sure Gohan is guilty, and if he is the vigilante, then he can shoot him anyway.

If the real vigilante shoots someone else tonight, Ch3tan could simply claim that he did it, and cast doubt upon whoever steps forward and claimed they fired the shot. If nobody is shot, Ch3tan will claim that regardless of whether there are three wolves, two wolves, or one wolf left they only kill one person at night, so since they already have one wolf identified he may as well stay his hand until he can work out who the companions are.

Maybe Ch3tan is the real vigilante. Maybe I'm just reading far too much into it. However, his "solid logic" is flawed, his evidence flimsy, and his reasoning behind staying the execution of Olgaline is weak, and anyone that fails to see that gives me pause for thought too, Jup

 

[Damini]

Also: the doctor is going to be protecting Jimmy, so the real vigilante would have a good reason not to come forward.

Tonight: Burn Olgaline...

Tomorrow: Burn Ch3tan...

Day after? I'm looking at you Jup.

 

[Jupitus]

Fair play.... I have to lug this barrel of mead (or what's left of it by the time I arrive) to Farmer Bob's place today for an open fire hogroast, so for now I feel compelled to stick to what we know is fact.

Vote Olgaleanmeat

If Ch3t IS the vig then let Gohan's fate be in his hands... I'll not be part of lynching someone based on the weak evidence he has put forward.

 

[RandomBastard]

I'm taking such a strong stance because, quite frankly, I don't believe him.

He claims to be a vigilante, and in the same breath warns us that there could be more than one, to stop the real vigilante coming forward and revealing the lie, or maybe just the stop the real vigilante shooting him tonight by planting a seed of doubt.

By claiming to be a vigilante, he can prevent a real wolf being lynched today, and guide us towards killing an innocent villager, whilst killing another innocent villager tonight, helping level the playing field for them. If he's so sure Gohan is guilty, and if he is the vigilante, then he can shoot him anyway.

If the real vigilante shoots someone else tonight, Ch3tan could simply claim that he did it, and cast doubt upon whoever steps forward and claimed they fired the shot. If nobody is shot, Ch3tan will claim that regardless of whether there are three wolves, two wolves, or one wolf left they only kill one person at night, so since they already have one wolf identified he may as well stay his hand until he can work out who the companions are.

Maybe Ch3tan is the real vigilante. Maybe I'm just reading far too much into it. However, his "solid logic" is flawed, his evidence flimsy, and his reasoning behind staying the execution of Olgaline is weak, and anyone that fails to see that gives me pause for thought too, Jup

Wow damini you've actually made sense.... ok I'm convinced.

vote: olgaline

 

[Rubric]

Can we get a vote count i can't be arsed to go back through it? It must be time to burn the dog.

 

[gohan]

wow internet is broke for a day and all hell breaks loose


my name got thrown around ALOT by ch3ten, but i can see why to be fair

i don't think ch3t's a wolf as all out war and finger pointing with og would be dangerous, he clearly thinks im a wolf but he's alone in that so i don't much care. i dont think damini is a wolf as if she was she wouldnt defend me, im looking at tab ogline (obiously) and possible random?

not sure on 3rd

 

[gohan]

ogaline for sure
random i fairly sure

then either jup ECA or random i think

most likely tab as jup and ECA were doubtful of ch3t's over enthusiasum, but could be a bluff


i know im innocent

we know jimmy and rubric are innocent

i belive ch3t and damini are innocent

so leaves 3 of those 5 or really 2 of those 4


vote random

 

[Jimmy]

ogaline for sure
random i fairly sure

then either jup ECA or random i think

most likely tab as jup and ECA were doubtful of ch3t's over enthusiasum, but could be a bluff


i know im innocent

we know jimmy and rubric are innocent

i belive ch3t and damini are innocent

so leaves 3 of those 5 or really 2 of those 4


vote random

you say olg for sure then dont vote for him :S

 

[gohan]

you say olg for sure then dont vote for him :S

i thought ch3t was gonna shoot him?

doesnt make much diff even if i vote olg ch3t will be like it made no difference he was already dead safe vote ect but fine
thing is we know for a fact ogaline is a wolf as he admitted it. and i honestly belive ch3t is the vig so it does make sense to try and uncover another wolf while we have a chance, as other wise ch3t is just shooting and hopeing

unvote random
vote ogaline

vote random tommoro ><