Werewolf #15

[Ch3tan]

Jimmy, I would ask that you resist answering Ogly's allegation for a while. Let everyone respond first.

 

[RandomBastard]

I don't believe olgaline for a second.

Faking being a seer when we are all assuming there is only one seer is foolish.

Jimmy would not fake it so early as we could easily lynch him if he's wrong.

Faking being a seer is an end game move and for olgaline this is game over.

My vote for olgaline stands

 

[Damini]

Riiiight... So Jimmy says that Olgaline is guilty. Ch3tan calls him up on it, questionning how he can be so sure, and he claims to be the seer. He scried Olgaline at the start of day one (guilty), and scried Rubric last night, who is innocent.

Then Olgaline counterclaims, and states that HE is the seer, and that he scried Gohan at the start of day one (innocent) and Levin last night. He tries to disprove Jimmy's claim by supplying this quote:

Then knowing that he's innocent isnt this Very very odd ? reply to Rubric post#102 whoops!??
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimmy View Post
reads to me like your trying to distence your self from olgaline rather than him trying to frame you

However, according to Jimmy, he discovered Olgaline's guilt at the beginning of day one. He did not know Rubric's status until AFTER this post was made. It only strengthens Jimmy's position, instead of undermining it.

unvote: Random

vote: Olgaline

 

[Olgaline]

you cant blame a wolf for trying ....
and amazed I survived day 1

grooowl!

I'll see you all later on the postgame forum all chewed up!
you, you Puwnie mortals

Wuff!

 

[Ch3tan]

Riiiight... So Jimmy says that Olgaline is guilty. Ch3tan calls him up on it, questionning how he can be so sure, and he claims to be the seer. He scried Olgaline at the start of day one (guilty), and scried Rubric last night, who is innocent.

Then Olgaline counterclaims, and states that HE is the seer, and that he scried Gohan at the start of day one (innocent) and Levin last night. He tries to disprove Jimmy's claim by supplying this quote:



However, according to Jimmy, he discovered Olgaline's guilt at the beginning of day one. He did not know Rubric's status until AFTER this post was made. It only strengthens Jimmy's position, instead of undermining it.

unvote: Random

vote: Olgaline

bah damini! I had to edit my reply to olgy to try and catch out anyone who may defend him. oh well, it's a bit quiet on here over the weekend, doubt we will get many more posts.

 

[Damini]

Hah. You threw in the towel a bit quickly then? There's 13 people left in the village, 2 of which will be allied to you anyway (assuming the 3 in the pack?) and I've seen first hand the fact that over whelming logic does not necessarily sway people into voting the right way.

But hey ho... One down

Edit:// Sorry Ch3tan!

 

[Ch3tan]

you cant blame a wolf for trying ....
and amazed I survived day 1

Luckily for you there was quite a bit of dissatisfaction with the non-posters, and those same non-posters not voting probably saved you.

 

[Jupitus]

Luckily for you there was quite a bit of dissatisfaction with the non-posters, and those same non-posters not voting probably saved you.

TBH Olgaline's gobbiness did have me thinking he had to be an innocent... shows how much I know eh? Reckon we should just follow Ch3tan's lead in future folks

Vote Olga Corbett

 

[Ch3tan]

OKay, lets focus on wolf number 2 and 3 then.

We can assume Jimmy and Rubric are now innocent. I know I am not a wolf. So that leaves:

Jup
taB
Damini
ECA
random
gohan


guys, this day phase will end with 6 votes. Hold off voting Olgy until we can get a better picture of who the other two might be.

unvote olg - purely to try and give us a bit of time to investigate.

 

[Jupitus]

Unvote Olga

 

[Jupitus]

Do we agree that Jimmy is the seer then? If he's innocent then fine, but what about his claim?

 

[Jupitus]

Sorry - read up and I found his post again. Only flaw in Ch3t's logic is removing himself from the list, as he could be playing a very sneaky wolluf....

 

[Ch3tan]

Guys, I am the vig, looking at Wills first post there could be more than one of each role, but only one pack of wolves. I intend to shoot Olgaline tonight, a confirmed wolf. So let us try and really hurt the wolves and lynch someone else tonight. We could go into day 3 with only 1 wolf left (assuming a 3 wolf pack).

Righto let us start with gohan. I am trying to read the thread and post at the same time so I do not have to take notes, so excuse the lack of quotes. I will give post numbers instead.

FreddysHouse - View Single Post - Werewolf #15 < post 89 by gohan.
Dams has just voted olgaline, I jump on the bandwagon and so does random. With Jimmy and gohan already having voted olgy, that makes it 5 votes for Olgy. But with his buddy in danger gohan quickly unvotes him.

FreddysHouse - View Single Post - Werewolf #15 < post 116 by gohan.
After a page or so of back and forth between myself and Olgy, I direct yet another question to him as to why he is after me. Gohan for some odd reason answers the question for Olgy. Could it be the fact that they are both in the same pack?

Also gohans posts above came very shortly before or after Olgy's posts. And always helped Olgys cause out. I thinks that PM's were exchanged.

FreddysHouse - View Single Post - Werewolf #15
FreddysHouse - View Single Post - Werewolf #15 < posts 121 and 124 by gohan. Threatening to switch the vote to me becuase I have questioned his actions. Now gohan is quick to jump on the vote the inactive bandwagon, mainly as he knows that two of those are not wolves. He also points out that he has been voting the inactive all along.

So I am off to the pub. In my mind this leaves ECA and Jup as most likely accomplices based on their posting, but I will present compelling evidence of this later.

For now though.

vote gohan You wolfy furry fucker.

 

[Damini]

OKay, lets focus on wolf number 2 and 3 then.

We can assume Jimmy and Rubric are now innocent. I know I am not a wolf. So that leaves:

Jup
taB
Damini
ECA
random
gohan


guys, this day phase will end with 6 votes. Hold off voting Olgy until we can get a better picture of who the other two might be.

unvote olg - purely to try and give us a bit of time to investigate.

Well, I voted for Olga day one (admittedly amongst others, but he was my final choice). I only switched because everyone wanted to kill an inactive member.

Gohan voted for Olgaline, but switched to Sydrik. Gohan was also the person Olgaline named as innocent - as it was the last desperate roll of the dice to stay alive, I doubt he'd use his "seer" cover to protect a real wolf, because he knew there was a high chance he'd get rumbled. Of course, this could be layers of double bluffing, but I don't think so.

Random voted for Olgaline, but switched to Bobby like I did, to speed up the game.

So, in my opinion, and assuming nobody is doing the old switcheroo vote, that leaves ECA, Jup, Tab - on the presumption that you're innocent, Ch3ts.

I must confess, Jup has me thinking. He's been very passive this game, reactive rather than active. That would be where my next vote lay.

If I had to guess, my third wolf would be Tab. ECA has cast doubt on Olgaline, admittedly without casting a vote, so out of the three those are the two I would chose.

 

[Damini]

Oh Ch3t, you look SO suspect right now. This is making my brain hurt.

 

[Damini]

Guys, I am the vig, looking at Wills first post there could be more than one of each role, but only one pack of wolves.

The way you phrase this concerns me greatly. You confess to being the vig, but immediately create a cover in case someone else comes forward to claim the same role.

 

[Ch3tan]

I tried to look at tab, but there are too few posts. I agree with what you say about Jup. A lack of mead and confusion in his posts makes me very suspicious.

Dams, I always look suspect. I can only ask that you put some faith in me here. It would be a very risky tactic for me and olgy to go full force at one other on day one if we were both wolves. It would be stupid for me to claim to be a vig and not kill Olgy tonight. You would know right off that I was lying. And then I would be next. Voting for olgaline when we know he is guilty is a wasted vote, I can kill him tonight with the one bullet I have. Read my post above, go and check the info for yourself. Gohan is either a wolf or just very unlucky to have made the posts he did.

 

[ECA]

ECA has cast doubt on Olgaline, admittedly without casting a vote, so out of the three those are the two I would chose.

FreddysHouse - View Single Post - Werewolf #15


Pardon?

 

[Damini]

I thought I edited that out. Sorry ECA.

 

[Ch3tan]

The way you phrase this concerns me greatly. You confess to being the vig, but immediately create a cover in case someone else comes forward to claim the same role.

Good, I am glad you are paying full attention. What I said would concern me, but I studied Will's first post very carefully and he does not state that there is only one of each of the roles. Only that there is only one pack of wolves.

I needed to state that, because some people will not check the info and if there is a 2nd legitimate vig then they or myself will look very guilty.

Doctor - protect Jimmy tonight, he could potentially scrye the 3rd and final wolf assuming gohan gets lynched today.

 

[Damini]

I want to know what ECA and Jup make of all this before I change my vote.

 

[ECA]

Btw nobody tell jimmy who to scry, if they are innocent they will just get eaten and we wont be any better off.

 

[ECA]

I want to know what ECA and Jup make of all this before I change my vote.

We have olgaline on the hook, I'm going to wait until next turn to see what new info we have.

 

[Ch3tan]

FreddysHouse - View Single Post - Werewolf #15 < ECA (above)

Actually throughout day 1 you avoided casting any doubt on olgy. you did against myself, damini and jimmy. I know two of those are innocent. You avoided tipping the balance against olgy, and jumped straight on the bobby wagon to save olgy.

You only vote for olgy today after it was clear jimmy had outed him. QED

Wolves are Olgy, gohan and ECA IMO.

All vote gohan today, olgy i will shoot tonight.

 

[Damini]

I really don't think Gohan is a wolf.

 

[Jupitus]

I want to know what ECA and Jup make of all this before I change my vote.

I'll tell you straight away that my ickle bwain hurts now....

Farmer Bob, my boss, has been unhappy with my work in the brewery, claiming I drink more than he sells, so he has put me on a performance improvement plan meaning I cannot sit all day and read tales of wolf-folk and the like and I have to actually work now instead!

I don't think Olga would finger a fellow wolf, or risk it in a double bluff, so I think Gohan might be a wrong choice.

Ch3tan is easy... if Olga doesn't turn up dead in the morning we still have the numbers left to lynch Olga and Ch3t while some of us live, especially if our doctor remains unknown.

I don't know who to vote for, to be honest

 

[Ch3tan]

The evidence against him on day one is pretty compelling. Read it for yourself, are you really saying that he was just really unlucky, or that olgy was that clever to make him look bad? Especially considering there is only 2 minutes between their statements on some of the posts I linked to.

Do you not see how pointless it is to lynch a confirmed wolf when there is another way to kill him?

 

[Jupitus]

I really don't think Gohan is a wolf.

Crossed conversations there, sorry for mumbling in the village meeting. I agree, Auntie Damini....

 

[Damini]

unvote: Olga

vote: TaB

 

[Ch3tan]

Well I do not think (and you have no idea how much it hurts to say this) that it is random. That leaves taB, ECA, Dams or Jup.

Now ECA looks dodge, but your defence of gohan looks even dodgier.

edit:// my horse and cart has arrived, time for ale!