Off-topic Mafia #3 Game Thread

[Vasconcelos]

This is turning quite interesting

With potential of levin/vascon being innocent and if cerb is telling the truth, we're down to some very narrow margins.

All I can do is plea that you investigate my home tonight so you'll know I'm innocent...then we can start properly eliminating people

Not sure how to vote as of yet, not gonna vote for no lynch but I'm not gonna jump on a lynch bandwagon yet either...

Hmmm hmmmmm

I dont trust Cerb at all... but dont want to make the same mistake on invisibletank as i did with poor Tohtori (sowy dude ). And Calo was very fast jumping on the mob bandwagon ("yes yes, burn him burn him hes the infidel!!")....

Even if u accuse me of erratic...

UNVOTE: INVISIBLETANK

VOTE: CALO

 

[Calo]

Hmmm hmmmmm

I dont trust Cerb at all... but dont want to make the same mistake on invisibletank as i did with poor Tohtori (sowy dude ). And Calo was very fast jumping on the mob bandwagon ("yes yes, burn him burn him hes the infidel!!")....

Even if u accuse me of erratic...

UNVOTE: INVISIBLETANK

VOTE: CALO

You really have a twisted mind, first its invisibletank, now suddenly me?
Looking for an easy target?

Bit of a stupid vote, or you are Scum and hoping everyone will jump on.

 

[Levin]

You really have a twisted mind, first its invisibletank, now suddenly me?
Looking for an easy target?

Bit of a stupid vote, or you are Scum and hoping everyone will jump on.

He is not scum, I can testify to that. I still find it strange that you'd want the town cop to go unprotected though, so his vote seems at least somewhat logical to me. Still, there are some very quiet people around here... I'd very much like to hear what they have to say about things.

 

[Calo]

He is not scum, I can testify to that. I still find it strange that you'd want the town cop to go unprotected though, so his vote seems at least somewhat logical to me. Still, there are some very quiet people around here... I'd very much like to hear what they have to say about things.

I didn't say unprotected, i just explained the possibilities.

I've played a few of these games and when a cops claims his role, most of the time mafia will lynch someone else because they don't want to take the risk to vote on the cop who will protected anyway.
They can't afford to waste a night lynch on a target thats almost certain protected. Thats what i mean, sure doc, protect the cop but my guess is that the mafia will night lynch someone else.

 

[Levin]

I didn't say unprotected, i just explained the possibilities.

I've played a few of these games and when a cops claims his role, most of the time mafia will lynch someone else because they don't want to take the risk to vote on the cop who will protected anyway.
They can't afford to waste a night lynch on a target thats almost certain protected. Thats what i mean, sure doc, protect the cop but my guess is that the mafia will night lynch someone else.

Right, but now that you've put forward your theory and possibly make the doc protect someone else, the mobs may go back to the plan of killing me. Argh.. I guess it becomes some kind of strange circle argument.

 

[Amanita]

I'm still trying to decide if the lovely Levin is fibbing or not

 

[Levin]

I'm still trying to decide if the lovely Levin is fibbing or not

I'm actually surprised more people haven't doubted me so far. But really, if I'm fake and there's a 'real' cop out there, they could just name and shame me and it would be their word against mine, and ... hmm well I guess things wouldn't get any easier from there. It would be quite interesting to see someone else claim the cop title though! One of us would know the other would be mob!

 

[Vasconcelos]

I'm actually surprised more people haven't doubted me so far. But really, if I'm fake and there's a 'real' cop out there, they could just name and shame me and it would be their word against mine, and ... hmm well I guess things wouldn't get any easier from there. It would be quite interesting to see someone else claim the cop title though! One of us would know the other would be mob!

I'd know it too

Now you mention it, i should have kept my hole shut with the hope sum1 jumped claiming to be the real cop

 

[- English -]

Going out for the night, my vote stands, but dont accuse me of being quiet lol

 

[Levin]

Hmm, well we have take some chances here. In my eyes there are five people left competing for three mobster spots... talking back and forth doesn't do much anymore so it's time for some action.

VOTE: ENGLISH

Sorry English, but your vote for no lynching makes me feel you just want another night and another murder to come by. Rubric voted no lynching too on the first day, and he turned out to be a psychopath so.. I guess I'm grasping at patterns here, but hey grasping is all we can do at the moment.

 

[Lethul]

Hmmm hmmmmm

I dont trust Cerb at all... but dont want to make the same mistake on invisibletank as i did with poor Tohtori (sowy dude ). And Calo was very fast jumping on the mob bandwagon ("yes yes, burn him burn him hes the infidel!!")....

Even if u accuse me of erratic...

UNVOTE: INVISIBLETANK

VOTE: CALO

really, the 2 top suspects tries to free their suspions by saying they are masons (both of them!) and you insta jump the
wagon and UNVOTES him just like that? Imo someone who jumps the bandwagon fast is prolly not mafia. The mafia is most likely the 3 last votes on the first guy that dies. Unless the have leet tictacs. Imo, the mafia is CERB, AMANTIA, INVISIBLETANK.

Ofc i can be wrong, but i really believe that Levin is a cop. So i'm gonna go as far and say this, i am the town doctor. I will protect Levin next night cycle. If someone else than these get lynched i want you Levin to check one of their houses for proof!

DOUBLEVOTE: Cerb !!!!!!!!!!!

picture of Cerb ->

Edit: And if we burn one of Cerb and Invisibletank and we are proven wrong we will have freed one guy more of suspicion. Altho the game is almost lost by then

 

[Howley]

first off : sorry been offline for so long, been sick irl.. now back to real mafia business!

basically i cant decide between Lethul and Vasconcelos... Lethul went straight for Cerb and as my 'tactical partner' already mentioned were supposed to be masons, i cant allow this. Maybe Lethul noticed Cerb in a previous game and said we have to have him out of the pic asap! coz he went from vote cerb -> teh seal gets hung -> doublevote cerb! and i havent noticed too much more input from him

And Vasconcelos seemed real eager to switch his vote to Calo after Calo passed on a pretty good strategy concerning the doc / cop... IF THERE ARE EVEN COPS/DOCS IN THIS GAME... again is this a tactical move by the mafia?.. or are the real mafia keeping quiet for now.

As said already either me or Cerb have a good chance of getting knocked the fk out 2nite even if we grab the right mafia person.

/shrug will try decide in the morning.. bit late to think clearly atm /ponder
ps. guess i do know Cerb "The world traveler" a bit toho

 

[- English -]

VOTE: ENGLISH

Sorry English, but your vote for no lynching makes me feel you just want another night and another murder to come by. Rubric voted no lynching too on the first day, and he turned out to be a psychopath so.. I guess I'm grasping at patterns here, but hey grasping is all we can do at the moment.

I guess everyone is entitled to an opinion, i dont want to join the bang wagon without real knowledge and without convincing myself on who's who. I have got some of my own suspects, although annoucing them here wouldnt be wise. Admitting im a townie probably doesnt help the matter as it is narrowing down the doctor, if Lethul isnt the real doc..... which i can understand why anyone would do

 

[Lethul]

Hmmm i was thinking long and hard when i went to bed yday.
This is how i see it at the momemnt...

Vote results when Tohtori got lynched:
Vote Count:
Day: Day 1

(Invisibletank) - 1 - (Old.Tohtori)
Old-Tohtori - 6 - (Levin, (Invisibletank), Amanita, Vasconcelos, Cerb, Rubric)
No Lynch - 1 - (-English-)

Not Voting: 3 (Lethul, Calo, Kirennia)

This makes me think the Mafia dude is among the 6 persons who voted on Tohtori. But two of them i dont belive to be mafia. One has already been burned. BUT! Amanita's strange unvoting as soon as Tothori got burned makes me think she wanted to get evil eyes off her.

Cop: Levin
Doctor: Me
Townie: Vasconcelos
Dead: Rubric/Tohtori

Possible mafia: Cerb, Invisibletank, Amanita, Calo, Kirennia

Therefor my prime mafia suspects are Amanita, Invisibletank, Cerb. But if what Cerb says that he and Invisibletank are Masons. Then then mafia must be my setup nr2, playing a quite game letting the town kill itself.

Possible mafia setup nr1: Cerb, Invisibletank, Amanita
Possible mafia setup nr2: Calo, Kirennia, Amanita

But -English- constantly voting No Lynch is fishy as well but thats a later problem, can single out atleast one more mafia first and maybe let the cop investigate - English - first. Does he just wants the nights to pass so he can burn someone? I don't know. But those two setups are my prime suspects. And i know what i see in those, Amanita in both! Therefor

VOTE: Amanita

ps. Vasconcelos should be glad Levin says he ain't mafia. Cause his sporadic voting makes me wanna burn him. He ain't mafia but he sure as hell ain't making townie life easier (prolly on mafia payroll trying to get townies voting on eachother.)

 

[Levin]

Some interesting reasoning there Lethul. So where do you put English in your two possible setups?

EDIT: Ah nevermind.. I got it now.

 

[Cerb]

ya some very logical thinking there so im going to go alon withi it cuz obviuosly i dont want to get lynched myself

VOTE: Amanita

 

[kirennia]

Have just been writting down on a piece of paper what roles everyone has claimed. I'm gonna be going for amanita also but for a different reason.

If everyone thus far has been telling the truth about their roles, that leaves Calo, English and Amanita in my eyes, thus we should be able to eliminate a mafia person today. The only reason at the moment that I'm trusting peoples word on matters is that there have been no conflicts of roles whatsoever so unless they've made up a role which isn't in the game at all, they surely must be telling the truth.

The reason I chose Amanita out of the three is her sheer silence about matters, especially avoiding the questions about whos the cop and generally any conversation that can benefit us.

If I'm wrong and she does turn out to be a townie, one of the two segregated groups must be lying(Levin and vasc or cerb and invisible).

VOTE : AMANITA

I wasn't sure about whether to vote yet at all but the problem with both the cop and doc saying who they are is that they'll be targetted so we can't afford to waste a day and lose someone overnight without having sorted anything during the day.

 

[Levin]

Lethul, Cerb and Kirennia.

A quick smatter of votes cast on Amanita, with some very logical reasoning behind it. You make compelling arguments viewing all sides, but you emit the obvious one: what if the three of you (or maybe just Kirennia and Cerb) are mafia and talked this through before posting? If it's so, you're being incredibly clever I have to say. That's the third option.

No matter what, I'm sure we will know after the next night depending on who got murdered. I need to think a bit more and then possibly change my vote.

 

[kirennia]

Lethul, Cerb and Kirennia.

A quick smatter of votes cast on Amanita, with some very logical reasoning behind it. You make compelling arguments viewing all sides, but you emit the obvious one: what if the three of you (or maybe just Kirennia and Cerb) are mafia and talked this through before posting? If it's so, you're being incredibly clever I have to say. That's the third option.

No matter what, I'm sure we will know after the next night depending on who got murdered. I need to think a bit more and then possibly change my vote.

While I can't defend myself, I can however prove (wow, we can actually prove something this time) that that combination is flawed. For Cerb to be one of the mafia, surely invisibletank wouldn't back him up as a mason if he too was a townie? If you include one of them, you have to include both. The only defence I currently have is the hope you'll find out tonight, if you're a cop, if you investigate me.

 

[Levin]

While I can't defend myself, I can however prove (wow, we can actually prove something this time) that that combination is flawed. For Cerb to be one of the mafia, surely invisibletank wouldn't back him up as a mason if he too was a townie? If you include one of them, you have to include both. The only defence I currently have is the hope you'll find out tonight, if you're a cop, if you investigate me.

True, and I did mostly mean Cerb and you since you were quick to follow up on Lethul's Amanita vote. I could easily imagine Lethul indeed being the doc and (invisible), Cerb and you being the mobsters seeing a chance to lynch another townie. I'm not saying that's what I believe, but the rest of us shouldn't leave it out as a possibility.

Amanita, dear girl, I think you need to start defending yourself against these accusations!

 

[Amanita]

Bah, I unvoted because Tohorti was being awesomely entertaining so like I said the game woulda been more fun with him in.

Don't you think that the mafia will have a gameplan? All they need to do is pick someone to bandwagon and everyone else'll follow! That got my fellow townie Tohorti lynched, admittedly partly because I fell victim to a moment of hysteria but soon realised the error of my ways!

Lethul seems a bit too desperate to start a bandagonning of his own choice! J'accuse!

Vote: Lethul

 

[Vasconcelos]

Yes, Mummin looks like Kaiser Soze. My vote remains for Calo tho.

 

[Calo]

Yes, Mummin looks like Kaiser Soze. My vote remains for Calo tho.

Which is stupid, you will find out!

Anyway, who says there are 3 mafia's out there?

And who says lethul is the doc? who says Levin is the cop?

I'm not saying they are lying but so far nobody has counterclaimed at all, so atm i think its true but really, if any of you is the real doc/cop, its VERY important that you counter-claim.

Tbh i'm helping the townies and putting myself on danger every time.

Still think amanita and (invincibletank) are teh scum. English.. dunno about him.

 

[Vasconcelos]

Which is stupid, you will find out!

Anyway, who says there are 3 mafia's out there?

And who says lethul is the doc? who says Levin is the cop?

I'm not saying they are lying but so far nobody has counterclaimed at all, so atm i think its true but really, if any of you is the real doc/cop, its VERY important that you counter-claim.

Tbh i'm helping the townies and putting myself on danger every time.

Still think amanita and (invincibletank) are teh scum. English.. dunno about him.

i know levin is the cop, thats for sure

 

[- English -]

Bah, I unvoted because Tohorti was being awesomely entertaining so like I said the game woulda been more fun with him in.

Don't you think that the mafia will have a gameplan? All they need to do is pick someone to bandwagon and everyone else'll follow! That got my fellow townie Tohorti lynched, admittedly partly because I fell victim to a moment of hysteria but soon realised the error of my ways!

Lethul seems a bit too desperate to start a bandagonning of his own choice! J'accuse!

Vote: Lethul

Part of me believes Amanita is telling the truth, but part of me doesnt. Basically I cant get my head around it lol. There has been alot of speculation to her name. Im still debating weather to vote or not, although i simply dont agree voting the person who voted against me.

!votecount

 

[Howley]

i know the cop (if 1) wants to investigate -English- to see if he really is a townie, but dont u think its more wise to investigate either me or cerb that way u will know both of us are townies!

as for deciding on who to vote to hang for 2nite.. i havent decided yet

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 2

English - 1 - (Levin)
Calo - 1 - (Vasconcelos)
Amanita - 3 - (Lethul, Cerb, Kirennia)
Lethul - 1 - (Amanita)

No Lynch - 1 - (English)

Not voting: 2 (Invisibletank, Calo)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

 

[Amanita]

Can't you see? The mafia are ganging up on me!

 

[Howley]

VOTE:Amanita ...

 

[- English -]

Can't you see? The mafia are ganging up on me!

that sounds too mafia like for me, sorry hope we're right

UNVOTE NOLYNCH

VOTE AMANITA