Off-topic Mafia #3 Game Thread

[Cerb]

thats 5 right?...ice where are you i want to see what comes out before i go to work!!!!

 

[Amanita]

no saving people from themselves. Hmph.

 

[Cerb]

so your not mafia then.....christ not again....why are we so bad at this!

 

[Amanita]

No, I'm not mafia. If I were mafia I would be more like "oh noes the townspeople will lose!"

In fact, last game when I was mafia I started the Kirennia lynching randomly and loved it when the townies blamed someone else for that random lynch You'll probably find the mafia are the ones that are hamming up the "oh noes" act!

 

[Howley]

well if were wrong i really hope the cop investigates me or cerb

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 2

English - 1 - (Levin)
Calo - 1 - (Vasconcelos)
Amanita - 5 - (Lethul, Cerb, Kirennia, Invisibletank English)
Lethul - 1 - (Amanita)

Not voting: 1 (Calo)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

The mob gathered around Amanita! An angry voice shouting "He is the one! GET HIM!". Quickly Amanita was overpowered and a noose put around his neck. He hanged dangling lifeless from the tree as the town people went and ransacked his house to find out who he was. He was Brian, vanilla townie, once again an innocent had fallen in the hands on the mob before the dusk gathered.

People returned to their homes, and night feel upon the town.

Night 2: No posting in the thread as before and all with nightchoises, send them to me ASAP! Deadline for night is monday the 4th at 18.00 CET

 

[Iceforge]

It once again became morning in the little town. In the middle of the city, right on the town square where they gathered each day, they found (Invisibletank) dead with a gunshot wound in his back.
A quick search through his house nearby revealed he truely was John, townie. One more of the towns good people was dead and whoever the scum was, they was getting a good advantage by now.

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch

Day 3 started: You can once again post in the thread

 

[- English -]

COP what happened!!!!!

 

[kirennia]

/sigh ...here we go again. At least by now we can start narrowing it down I guess but this is getting pretty late in the game to be taking out maybes; we might have lost already . Actually been taking notes this time to try and get a better chance of finding people.

Levin - Claims of being a cop, has determined that vasc is a townie in his eyes...who did you investigate last night and what were the outcomes?

Cerb - Tbh, I'm pretty sure you're a townie now as invisible has been killed and found to be a townie. There would have been no reason for him to lie to cover up for you unless it's some weird rule set for your characters but I highly doubt it.

Lethul - Doctor...no-ones been saved but to be honest, I thought the cop(Levin) was gonna go last night. Not sure whether to beleive you as sadly the only way for you to be cleared is if someone is saved one night.

Vascon - Levin says you're a townie...we can't prove or disprove this without more being said, not sure what to think here.

English - Quiet, killing blow on Amanita but then, with who was remaining I guess that could have been anyone. I'm as guilty along with lethul, cerb and invisible there I guess. With people claiming their roles as they had, I was certain :/

Calo - Only one not voting yesterday, I guess this makes you as suspicious as it does clears you, no claims made on you yet other then as a standard townie.

Me - Similar to Vascon, English and Calo I guess in your eyes. I just hope if you really are the cop and that you investigated me last night, otherwise I'm as liable to be in trouble as the others.


With Amanita being shown as a townie, I'm not completely sure what to think. Still if people have been telling the truth, I can only narrow it down to English and Calo. With that said, if there are more mafia people then just the two, it means that someone has been lying along the way.

If Vascon is the mafia, I'm pretty sure that means Levin isn't but not the other way round. Pretending to be a cop and saying a townie really is a townie is a good way to get someone on side, or then again, could both be mafia.

Cerb is in the clear in my eyes...there is no way he could be mafia now.

Lethul is the other maybe.

Basically, what were your investigations last night Levin and who did you try and protect last night Lethul? It's the only way we can start narrowing it down again or hopefully you've come up with something solid.

 

[Vasconcelos]

For me:

Levin: cop

Me: townie

Calo: mafia

English: mafia

Kir: townie ¿no vigilante?

Now i have my doubts about Lethul n Cerb...

VOTE: CALO

 

[Lethul]

Now i have my doubts about Lethul n Cerb...

If I'm not the Doctor, don't you think the real doctor would have stepped up and said he was the doctor by now?
I don't understand how you can be doubtful of Cerb either as both he and Invisibletank said they were Mason and its proven that Invisibletank is townie he was mason.

Cop: Levin (proven by no other person claiming to be cop imo)
Townie: You (proven by Levin), Cerb (proven by invisbletanks death)
Doctor: Me (proven by no other person claiming to be doc imo)

That makes
Mafia: Kirennia, -English-, Calo

Unless someone really outsmarted us i think we can actually win this one now!
And ye Levin, i wanna know who you investigated before i cast my vote!

 

[- English -]

Cop: Levin (proven by no other person claiming to be cop imo)
Townie: You (proven by Levin), Cerb (proven by invisbletanks death)
Doctor: Me (proven by no other person claiming to be doc imo)

That makes
Mafia: Kirennia, -English-, Calo

Unless someone really outsmarted us i think we can actually win this one now!
And ye Levin, i wanna know who you investigated before i cast my vote!

Isn't each game different? Different classes get different roles and abilities to communicate with each other like invis said about masons. For all we know any of the dead could have been undercover. For all we know some of the mafia have died which we do not know. I think i need known who was investigated last night before i cast my vote as its all about ruling people out. And who says theres even a doc in this game?

edit: iceforge is there a time limit for this round?

 

[Lethul]

Isn't each game different? Different classes get different roles and abilities to communicate with each other like invis said about masons. For all we know any of the dead could have been undercover. For all we know some of the mafia have died which we do not know. I think i need known who was investigated last night before i cast my vote as its all about ruling people out. And who says theres even a doc in this game?

edit: iceforge is there a time limit for this round?

Oh, i thought certain roles were always there. Might need to reconsider then. Hmmm, but i will still stick with my logical thinking for now! Would be quite a gamble by me and levin to go and claim roles and hope nobody else had them. So who did you investigate Levin!?

 

[- English -]

Oh, i thought certain roles were always there. Might need to reconsider then. Hmmm, but i will still stick with my logical thinking for now! Would be quite a gamble by me and levin to go and claim roles and hope nobody else had them. So who did you investigate Levin!?

its just what ive thought, probably are ;x

 

[Levin]

I investigated Cerb last night, and found no evidence of him belonging to the mafia. I found that Cerb is a "townie" but i don't know if that means he lied about being a mason, or if I'm a lousy cop and simply wasn't able to find the mason connection.

In short - I can confirm that Cerb is a townie. I can't confirm any ties to the masons though.

 

[Cerb]

ok heres my take on things at the moment and i hope my opinions have a little sway now that invisible is dead....i think levin and vasc are mafia for sure....vasc because i was looking back over the thread and i seen that as soon as a band wagon was started on toth he jumped hapily on...levin i dont trust because theres no proof that hes a cop and secondly because he investigated me last night?!?!? wheres the logic in that...surely after invisible died it was obvious i was a townie?....and when he did "investigate" all he gave back was information we all already knew because me and invisible alrdy posted it...another reason i suspect vasc is because levin seems to have "investigated" him for no reason from the start in what i believe is only a ploy to protect another mafia!

in short....get levin!!!!

Vote: Levin

 

[Calo]

I think english, vasc or kir are mafia

There's just something fishy about it, vasc voting for me for no reason, and the 2 others for staying a bit of the field.

We really need to vote the right guy now.

 

[Vasconcelos]

No!

Cerb dude, if wot Levin is telling is true, the good guys stand for:

Levin + Vasc + Cerb so far.

Levin investigated on you, if you trully are a townie you should now Levin is the cop as he unmaked you...

Kirennia and Lethul might have a shadow of doubt as they havent been investigated, thus i propose to leave them alone for now. If you too are reading this, i encourage you to follow me and vote Calo.

It is time for some good ole mafia ganking lads. Bring the pitchs and the forks!!

 

[- English -]

Ive had my suspicions of Calo all along being Mafia (check recent posts) and with the recent findings of innocent people (or so we seem to be believing). Its just a matter of trusting levin(cop) which i am very confident in doing so. Its either that or your playing a very cleaver game indeed.

VOTE CALO

 

[kirennia]

ok heres my take on things at the moment and i hope my opinions have a little sway now that invisible is dead....i think levin and vasc are mafia for sure....vasc because i was looking back over the thread and i seen that as soon as a band wagon was started on toth he jumped hapily on...levin i dont trust because theres no proof that hes a cop and secondly because he investigated me last night?!?!? wheres the logic in that...surely after invisible died it was obvious i was a townie?....and when he did "investigate" all he gave back was information we all already knew because me and invisible alrdy posted it...another reason i suspect vasc is because levin seems to have "investigated" him for no reason from the start in what i believe is only a ploy to protect another mafia!

in short....get levin!!!!

Vote: Levin

I think he investigated you last night because invisibletank asked him to. The thing is, although I would rather him to have investigated me, investigating one of you would confirm that BOTH of you are telling the truth, thus it's a double whammy.

I can only draw the conclusion that he investigated vasc completely randomly on the first night as no-one confirmed they were a cop, mafia, mason or whatever in the first day so it would have been pot luck.

The other reason I'm starting to have a reason to beleive him is that only vasc/lethul and myself confirmed that we weren't cops before he stood up and said he was one. At the time there were another 5 people who hadn't commented so to claim it that early is a pretty wild guess that there wouldn't be another cop in the game. Of course the other alternative is a random rule whereby he knew exactly what roles were out there when he started the game; for now though, I'm going to believe him.

There are three options concerning those two:

Levin is part of the mafia, randomly saying people he knows to be innocent to avert attention.
Levin AND vasc are part of the mafia, covering for each other.
Neither of them are part of the mafia.

Surely it couldn't just be vasc as part of the mafia, otherwise, there would have been no reason for Levin to lie about being a cop.

Kirennia and Lethul might have a shadow of doubt as they havent been investigated, thus i propose to leave them alone for now. If you too are reading this, i encourage you to follow me and vote Calo.

Sorry mate but I'm not gonna jump on the bandwagon because my name is in doubt; this is gonna take a bit more time for me to think through. I am however starting to waver in that direction due to the claimed roles and who is left in the town. It just isn't making sense for certain people to have made up roles when they did...

 

[Levin]

Cerb.

On the very first day I really had no idea who to investigate, but I had to start somewhere. I thought you and Vasconcelos seemed a little suspicious so I decided to investigate one of you two. I picked Vasc, and he turned out innocent. Then everything happened as it did on day two, and for my second investigation I decided to stay on the plan to investigate you next, simply because you and invisibletank were linked. If you were innocent, then Invisible would be as well. Now the mafia has been all clever and removed that advantage by killing one of you.

You should also know that during the night when i investigated you, I had no idea who was going to get murdered. If anything, I was worried I'd get ganked myself, and not be able to relay my findings.

Finally, I think CALO and ENGLISH are mafia for sure. And out of those two I think English is the top candidate. I still haven't figured out who the third one is.

 

[Calo]

Vasc, yet again you are trying to bandwagon on me, why? because you are almost certain scum tbh.

If people watched the 2 previous games they know i play like a townie because i am totally a townie..
Why didn't I vote on the last 2 people? 2 people who got bandwagoned.
And why didn't the scum nightkill the doc? its pretty obvious that would have been the best option. We know that lethul is the doc, so why kill some random townie?

English and vasc are way to eager to just start a vote on someone for no apparent reason but they always come together on the same guy to vote.

Vote: English

 

[Levin]

And why didn't the scum nightkill the doc? its pretty obvious that would have been the best option. We know that lethul is the doc, so why kill some random townie?

Vote: English

I fully agree with that question. I would have expected them to off Lethul too. I don't want to believe Lethul is mafia but it does confuse things the hell up that they didn't try to kill him or me!

In either case, since i know for a fact that Vasc and and Cerb are innocent, and myself being a cop - that leaves English, Calo, Kirennia and Lethul.

Four people, of which three are mafia. 75% chance to lynch the right one.

Lethul says he's doc, and I WANT to believe that, but can't know for sure. Still, there are at least two other mafias among English, Calo, Kirennia, so I'm going to focus on them.

Calo voted for English though. Would a mafia vote for another mafia just to throw us off? Possible. It's also possible that Calo is actually innocent although that would mean Lethul isn't a doc but mafia.

Kirennia really has nothing to convince people of his innocence other than very elaborate "townie" thinking and reasoning. The markings of an innocent or just a skilled mafia player? Need more info on this one.

English has been fairly passive, and I can almost imagine a lot of talk going on through PMs between him and the other mafioso. He has voted for Calo. Same reasoning here as with Calo voting for English.

VOTE: ENGLISH

What worries me a lot right now is that, even if we pick the right one to lynch this day, the remaining two will kill another one of us tonight, and it will probably be me, so that I can't give the rest of the townies all the info they need. That means there will still be a risk that they will win, but oh well. If that happens, just remember who I told you are innocent.

 

[- English -]

I fully agree with that question. I would have expected them to off Lethul too. I don't want to believe Lethul is mafia but it does confuse things the hell up that they didn't try to kill him or me!

In either case, since i know for a fact that Vasc and and Cerb are innocent, and myself being a cop - that leaves English, Calo, Kirennia and Lethul.

Four people, of which three are mafia. 75% chance to lynch the right one.

Lethul says he's doc, and I WANT to believe that, but can't know for sure. Still, there are at least two other mafias among English, Calo, Kirennia, so I'm going to focus on them.

Calo voted for English though. Would a mafia vote for another mafia just to throw us off? Possible. It's also possible that Calo is actually innocent although that would mean Lethul isn't a doc but mafia.

Kirennia really has nothing to convince people of his innocence other than very elaborate "townie" thinking and reasoning. The markings of an innocent or just a skilled mafia player? Need more info on this one.

English has been fairly passive, and I can almost imagine a lot of talk going on through PMs between him and the other mafioso. He has voted for Calo. Same reasoning here as with Calo voting for English.

VOTE: ENGLISH

What worries me a lot right now is that, even if we pick the right one to lynch this day, the remaining two will kill another one of us tonight, and it will probably be me, so that I can't give the rest of the townies all the info they need. That means there will still be a risk that they will win, but oh well. If that happens, just remember who I told you are innocent.

lol well this is going to be a funny finish. I think you need a wakeup call and check Calo's previous posts. Now that i will be out, it leaves what? Cop Doc (Calo who i strongly believe is mafia), Kir (?) and Cerb.

Ive claimed to be a townie all along,just time will tell i guess

 

[Levin]

Now that i will be out, it leaves what? Cop Doc (Calo who i strongly believe is mafia), Kir (?) and Cerb.

Ive claimed to be a townie all along,just time will tell i guess

No, if you are innocent it leaves Calo, Kir and Lethul as 100% mafia.

 

[- English -]

No, if you are innocent it leaves Calo, Kir and Lethul as 100% mafia.

who says theres 3????

 

[Cerb]

gota say levin if your mafia your a damn good one cuz youve got me convinced....
unvote
Vote: English

 

[- English -]

gota say levin if your mafia your a damn good one cuz youve got me convinced....
unvote
Vote: English

and hes mr bandwagon

gj guys another innocent townie down ;/

 

[kirennia]

Well it was between Calo and English for me but at least if we're right we have a decent lead for once.

VOTE : ENGLISH

Make or break time, give it to us straight iceforge

 

[- English -]

fools, fooolllsss i tell yaa!!!

<waves walking stick>