Off-topic Mafia #3 Game Thread

[kirennia]

fools, fooolllsss i tell yaa!!!

<waves walking stick>

Walking stick gets no sympathy vote here, pfft!

And for the love of God, investigate me tonight Levin if you're really a cop, then we can put an end to this mess without anymore needless bloodshed...

 

[Levin]

who says theres 3????

Isn't there always 3 mafia? If I'm wrong I'd very much like to know.

 

[Calo]

Isn't there always 3 mafia? If I'm wrong I'd very much like to know.

Normally only 2

Last game there were 3 because it was a special game, It was said in the start that there was 1 thing special about this game but nobody knew what, it was that there were 3 mafia's

 

[Lethul]

ok heres my take on things at the moment and i hope my opinions have a little sway now that invisible is dead....i think levin and vasc are mafia for sure....vasc because i was looking back over the thread and i seen that as soon as a band wagon was started on toth he jumped hapily on...levin i dont trust because theres no proof that hes a cop and secondly because he investigated me last night?!?!? wheres the logic in that...surely after invisible died it was obvious i was a townie?....and when he did "investigate" all he gave back was information we all already knew because me and invisible alrdy posted it...another reason i suspect vasc is because levin seems to have "investigated" him for no reason from the start in what i believe is only a ploy to protect another mafia!

in short....get levin!!!!

Vote: Levin

He turns in who to investigate at the same time they chose who to murder tho?

 

[Levin]

So the thing is then, we have no idea how many mafias we have in the game??

That puts things in a whole different perspective. Well, things make more sense in one way (two of my remaining four suspects would be innocent instead of just one) and it makes it harder to find the guilty ones. Tum ti tum. Ah well, I'm going to stick with my vote still.

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 3

Calo - 2 - (English, Vasconcelos)
English - 3 - (Levin, Calo, Cerb)

Not voting: 2 (Lethul, Kirennia)

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

Questions:

Isn't there always 3 mafia? If I'm wrong I'd very much like to know.

No, there is not always 3. The number of mafia depends on the number of players. In this game it is a secret number, so will not confirm or disconfirm any number.

 

[Lethul]

Both my two top candidates of mafia is left so

VOTE:English

 

[Levin]

No, there is not always 3. The number of mafia depends on the number of players. In this game it is a secret number, so will not confirm or disconfirm any number.

Ah thank you for that.. I wish I'd realized this earlier! I've been trying to put together how there could be only one innocent out of the four "unclear" ones, and it was hard to make sense out of things.

 

[kirennia]

Votecount
Day: Day 3

Calo - 2 - (English, Vasconcelos)
English - 3 - (Levin, Calo, Cerb)

Not voting: 2 (Lethul, Kirennia)

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

Questions:

You missed my vote for English. I put it in bold, caps etc...

 

[Levin]

So all in all we have five people voting English... uh oh... maybe he was innocent after all.

*anguish*

 

[- English -]

at least give me a soldiers death,
or hung drawn and quatered, william wallace style!

 

[kirennia]

Well Lethuls was voted after the fourth vote had already gone in...not sure if that's of any significance but I don't know whether iceforge/lethul just didn't see my vote on the last page or what.

I thought I'd mistyped it but I voted the exact same way as you did (Post 149)

 

[Iceforge]

I am so sorry, yes, Kirennia, you voted him and that made it 4.
And Lethul jumped the gun as well, making it 5, 1 more than whats needed:

With a ravenous force, a big majority of the remaining living towns people surrounded - English - and pull him with great force to the big tree. The corpse from yesterday was removed and English found the noose placed around his head and he was hanged!
The towns people ransacked his house and then burned it to the ground as they found out he was Made-man Johnny, Mafia

Glad that the day went well, the townsfolk returned to their homes. For once, a guilty man had been hanged by the mob!

Night 3, no posting in the thread!! All with nightchoises, send them to me!

 

[Iceforge]

Just to clearify the final votecount looked like:

Votecount
Day: Day 3

Calo - 2 - (English, Vasconcelos)
English - 5 - (Levin, Calo, Cerb, Lethul, Kirennia)

Making -English - The lynched one, and he was, for the record, mafia!

 

[Cerb]

oh my god we actully got a mafia!!!! wooooo!

 

[Lethul]

Well Lethuls was voted after the fourth vote had already gone in...not sure if that's of any significance but I don't know whether iceforge/lethul just didn't see my vote on the last page or what.

I thought I'd mistyped it but I voted the exact same way as you did (Post 149)

I just saw the votecount just before i posted Didn't really notice your vote

 

[Levin]

<bump> Come on people, hand in your night-stuff so we can get on with things!

 

[Cerb]

levin...your sooo getting it 2nite!

 

[Iceforge]

The sun went up, it was dawn in the town.

The towns people gathered in the, they were in a lighter mood than the other days, now that they had finally gotten a scum hanged!
They looked around and noticed no dead corpses on the street. Perhaps nobody had died tonight... how amazing would that be?
Heads was counted. 5 heads. Damn, someone was missing. Cerb was there, Kirennia was there, Levin was there, Vasconcelos was there and Calo was there.
Lethul! Quickly they ran to his house and in his backyard they found him strangled and naked.
Searching through his house they found out he was Dr. Brown, the towns Doctor!.

A great loss for the town!

And it meant there was still scum about.

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch

Day 4: You can now post again

 

[Cerb]

ok to me it seems the mafia have to be kir and calo...in a game of what was it 11 there must ahve been 3 mafia...as to which to vote for im not sure

 

[kirennia]

ok to me it seems the mafia have to be kir and calo...in a game of what was it 11 there must ahve been 3 mafia...as to which to vote for im not sure

I'm not part of the mafia which I hope Levin can prove if he has investigated me last night.

Levin investigated Vascon and uncovered cerb as a townie so as of yet, I still beleive the three of you to be on the right side of the law.

Calo is for me the only person who has had nothing said about him and as the only remaining person, it's a no brainer.

VOTE : CALO

While I realise the rest of you can still be drawn between myself and calo, I would advise awaiting Levins response as to who he investigated then you will see my innocence.

 

[Vasconcelos]

Im gonna waite for Levin's report, tho im pretty sure Calo is another scum

 

[Cerb]

levin hurry up and tell us what you found out!!!

 

[Levin]

First of all, Cerb, I thought there were 3 mafia too, but apparently there's only supposed to be two. I suppose we have to assume it could be either.

Well.. I thought since Kir had been begging to be investigated, he's probably innocent anyway, and so I was going to be clever and investigated Lethul. I wanted to be sure he really was the doctor. I wish now i'd investigated Kir or Calo and then we'd have known for sure who the bad guy is. Sadly, this means I have no idea which of Kirennia and Calo is the bad guy.

Kirennia has been begging to be investigated, indicating he may well be innocent.

Calo voted for English who turned out to be mafia, indicating he may well be innocent too.

Still, at least one of these guys is a bad guy. Kirennia would of course vote for Calo. Calo will probably vote for Kirennia leaving it up to us other three to pick one. *sigh* This won't be easy. I for one am going to go back and re-read some posts and try to figure things out from there.

 

[Vasconcelos]

First of all, Cerb, I thought there were 3 mafia too, but apparently there's only supposed to be two. I suppose we have to assume it could be either.

Well.. I thought since Kir had been begging to be investigated, he's probably innocent anyway, and so I was going to be clever and investigated Lethul. I wanted to be sure he really was the doctor. I wish now i'd investigated Kir or Calo and then we'd have known for sure who the bad guy is. Sadly, this means I have no idea which of Kirennia and Calo is the bad guy.

Kirennia has been begging to be investigated, indicating he may well be innocent.

Calo voted for English who turned out to be mafia, indicating he may well be innocent too.

Still, at least one of these guys is a bad guy. Kirennia would of course vote for Calo. Calo will probably vote for Kirennia leaving it up to us other three to pick one. *sigh* This won't be easy. I for one am going to go back and re-read some posts and try to figure things out from there.

Calo voted for english and English for Calo, that made me suspice even more of them...

Sadly, now theres no way to know who btwn Cerb, Kir and Calo is innocent by w8ing for another nite to investigate, since Levin will prolly be the next target, thus i came to this conclussion:
- Cerb and Invisibletank both announced they were masons. Since Invisible died being a townie im gonna assume Cerb is also a townie.
- Kirennia been begging for an investigation over him since last nite, so I'm gonna assume that wasnt a bluff and he was sincere.

So, that leaves my suspect nº 1 since 2 nites ago:

VOTE: CALO

 

[Levin]

I just re-read this whole thread. This whole line of reasoning assumes there is only one mafia left. (If there are TWO left, I guess we know who they are and we win eventually even if it would cost another murder-victim before we get them both.) Anyway.

I must say when I started re-reading I was slightly leaning towards Calo being mafia and Kir a townie. Calo has been very quick to point fingers and put attention on others, without actually voting himself. He did have a theory that the doc shouldn't protect the cop, but I don't know what to make of that. Was he mafia, trying to make it easier to kill the cop, or was he a townie showing genuine concern? Whenever Vasc voted for him he'd only defend himself with the "im an easy target huh?" instead of with some kind of logic.

But then... English voted for Calo and propagated against him with the 'skald' ploy and whatnot, and never touched Kirennia at all. Also, Kirennia's pleading for me to investigate him feels more and more like a ploy to draw attention away from him, and so far it's been successful! And I guess if I did end up investigating him and saying he's mafia, he could claim that i'm a false cop. If Kirennia is mafia, his tactics has been to overwhelm us with logical townie thinking, and counting on that the cop with the rare and few investiation chances, would not investigate someone who's been asking for it.

I'm pretty much 50/50 between the two of them now... Vasc, I know you've had a bad feeling about Calo the whole time. I'm basicly split in half between them at the moment. Cerb, what's your reasoning?

EDIT: You posted while I was typing Vas. Cerb is 100% innocent. I investigated him, remember? I just wouldn't confirm he is a mason, but i've had it explained to me that in Iceforge's games the cop can only see town or mafia alignments, so that's nothing strange.

 

[Cerb]

just read back over all the thread and have to say am strongly leaning towards calo being the mafia but the fact he voted for english is throwing me

 

[Calo]

I think there's only 1 mafia player left and its kir, Dunno bout vasc, he's been trying to bandwagon me from the start and he won't stop, so I'm actually pretty sure that I'll get lynched and then its pretty much over for townies, because I really am a good one.


Vote Kirennia

 

[Calo]

And the question i asked about the doc protecting the cop is quite important.
Townies should think how the scum would act and then act against it. Just by random voting and hoping you find a scum will most of the time lose you the game.

And why is kir innocent because he wanted to be investigated? Like levin said, ppl will go like " well he is a townie because he wanted to be investigated" and if he was and turned out mafia, then we got 1 word against another. And people might go "hey he's not the real cop , lets lynch him!" which again is in favor of kir.

 

[Levin]

I think there's only 1 mafia player left and its kir, Dunno bout vasc, he's been trying to bandwagon me from the start and he won't stop, so I'm actually pretty sure that I'll get lynched and then its pretty much over for townies, because I really am a good one.


Vote Kirennia

Damn you Calo, I was going to vote Kirennia as well to even the score but... if you suspect Vasc, you clearly suspect me as well since I cleared him. And that makes you fishy in my eyes. Still, I have to go to bed now, so i'll leave it in Cerb's hands.

Vote: Kirennia