Off-topic Mafia #3 Game Thread

[Cerb]

Damn you Calo, I was going to vote Kirennia as well to even the score but... if you suspect Vasc, you clearly suspect me as well since I cleared him. And that makes you fishy in my eyes. Still, I have to go to bed now, so i'll leave it in Cerb's hands.

Vote: Kirennia

so no presure then

Votecount

 

[kirennia]

And the question i asked about the doc protecting the cop is quite important.
Townies should think how the scum would act and then act against it. Just by random voting and hoping you find a scum will most of the time lose you the game.

And why is kir innocent because he wanted to be investigated? Like levin said, ppl will go like " well he is a townie because he wanted to be investigated" and if he was and turned out mafia, then we got 1 word against another. And people might go "hey he's not the real cop , lets lynch him!" which again is in favor of kir.

I've still maintained my position and as of yet have no idea why Levin hasn't investigated me whereas you, haven't.

Levin, only you will know if you're really a cop or not but having investigated Vascon, cerb and lethul, you'll know who is innocent out of them. I put it to you that if there are two Mafia members left, voting off either myself or Calo will produce the same result as you'll hit on either one of us if you've been telling the truth about being a cop and the game will continue into the next day, knowing the exact same as you do now. If there is only one Mafia left, you still have nothing to lose by voting one off and investigating the other one by night.

I STILL put myself forward as a guarantee, investigate me and you'll know I'm a townie.

As for the you vascon and cerb, only you can make the decision; you don't need me to produce the facts. All I can assure you is that if you really do trust Levins investigations as I still do, the game can be ended today with Calo being undone.

No matter what way you look at it, if you keep me going for this final day, it's a win-win situation unless one of you three have been somehow lying which as far as I have seen, I doubt.

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 4

Calo - 2 - (Vasconcelos, Kirennia)
Kirennia - 2 - (Calo, Levin)

Not voted: 1 (Cerb)

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch!

 

[Levin]

Vasconcelos and Cerb.

The way I see it we have pretty much already won. The only way the mafia can survive now is if we lynch an innocent today, another gets murdered tonight, and you two somehow turn on me tomorrow. We know the mafia is either Calo or Kirennia (or god forbid, both, but I doubt that) and it doesn't really matter which is which. If we lynch the wrong guy today that will suck, but it really just means one more of us will get murdered before we lynch the right one tomorrow with a 2 vs 1 majority.

Think about these things in case we're forced to go into another night. Now it's just a matter of winning with as large a margin as possible, and as few innocents as possible having to die.

 

[Levin]

And in line with my thinking above.. might as well get things done with. My apologies, Calo. If you really are innocent, I hope you can take comfort in that the town will win and you helped!

Unvote: Kirennia

Vote: Calo

 

[Vasconcelos]

And in line with my thinking above.. might as well get things done with. My apologies, Calo. If you really are innocent, I hope you can take comfort in that the town will win and you helped!

Unvote: Kirennia

Vote: Calo

I think we won

In my eyes, the only way posible to be a 3 mafia game is if Kirennia n Calo are playing the same game i suspect both Calo n English did: accusing each other as a way of diversion, ensuring at least one of 'em surivive....
In that case if after lynching Calo theres a mafia alive, we will know whos left, for I have 110% confidence in Levin and from him in Cerb.

!votecount

 

[kirennia]

Woot, first townie victory here we come, end it for us Ice

 

[Cerb]

YES!!! Come on!!

oh and to leave no doubt Vote: Calo

 

[Calo]

Oh well, hope townies win because I am indeed a townie.

 

[kirennia]

Oh well, hope townies win because I am indeed a townie.

That wouldn't make sense...

If he is...erm...well so am I as an investigation will show. If Levin has already investigated Vascon and Cerb, that leaves...nobody?

 

[Levin]

That wouldn't make sense...

If he is...erm...well so am I as an investigation will show. If Levin has already investigated Vascon and Cerb, that leaves...nobody?

I will investigate you next, Kir, but it's academical really. If Calo is innocent it can only be you. Your only chance would be to do a dirt campaign against me and try to win the others over. I'm sure you've kept some compelling arguments in the backburner just for such an occation.

 

[kirennia]

I will investigate you next, Kir, but it's academical really. If Calo is innocent it can only be you. Your only chance would be to do a dirt campaign against me and try to win the others over. I'm sure you've kept some compelling arguments in the backburner just for such an occation.

No arguments needed; it'd make sense that I'd be the mafia member if Calo proves innocent but I'm really not. All I can say is that if this does carry on and he's been telling the truth, don't lynch before Levin comes back with the results. Can't see that happening though, think Calo is just out to cause some last minute mischief

 

[Levin]

No arguments needed; it'd make sense that I'd be the mafia member if Calo proves innocent but I'm really not. All I can say is that if this does carry on and he's been telling the truth, don't lynch before Levin comes back with the results. Can't see that happening though, think Calo is just out to cause some last minute mischief

Haha, indeed. Let's hope for that!

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 4

Calo - 4 - (Vasconcelos, Kirennia, Cerb, Levin)
Kirennia - 1 - (Calo)

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch!

The mob gathered around Calo and quickly got him strung up! "The partner of English!" they all shouted, as life left Calo's body. Ransacking his house, however, revealed a sad truth. He was Dr. Nick, the town Physchiatrist!
A sad loss for the town, yet again, despite the so good lynch the other day, they had to return to their homes, head bowed down and sad.

End day 4,
Start night 4: Those with nightchoises, send them in ASAP! with this few left, night deadline is tomorrow, thursday, at 18.00 CET

 

[Vasconcelos]

Votecount
Day: Day 4

Calo - 4 - (Vasconcelos, Kirennia, Cerb, Levin)
Kirennia - 1 - (Calo)

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch!

The mob gathered around Calo and quickly got him strung up! "The partner of English!" they all shouted, as life left Calo's body. Ransacking his house, however, revealed a sad truth. He was Dr. Nick, the town Physchiatrist!
A sad loss for the town, yet again, despite the so good lynch the other day, they had to return to their homes, head bowed down and sad.

End day 4,
Start night 4: Those with nightchoises, send them in ASAP! with this few left, night deadline is tomorrow, thursday, at 18.00 CET

OOOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCCCCCCCCCCHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!

I'm :eek2: :eek2: :eek2: :eek2:

 

[kirennia]

I'm :eek2: :eek2: :eek2: :eek2:

Not as much as me :/ Get your night votes in and lets finish this.

 

[Levin]

Not as much as me :/ Get your night votes in and lets finish this.

I'm not too surprised really. But let's hush, it's nighttime!

 

[Iceforge]

Dawn came to the town for the 5th time
Day 5 started and they gathered in the centre of the town. They was only 3 now. Cerb was not there. Walking there, keeping an eye on one another the entire way, they made it to Cerb's house and found him killed. Looking through his stuff, they found he was Charles, Townie

With 3 alive, it takes 2 to lynch

 

[Levin]

Okay guys, things have seriously gone down the shitter. Because you know what? I investigated Kirennia tonight and he came out as "not mafia connected".

This means there must be a Godfather among us. That is, someone who registers as town aligned when being investigated by the cop.

Now, I reckon if Vasconcelos was the Godfather, he would have murdered me tonight, and easily be able to convice Cerb that Kirennia was mafia (since Kir was the only one not investigated).

If Kirennia on the other hand is the Godfather, he couldn't murder me, because I would have come out as a cop, and more imporantly my information about Kirennia being "innocent" would have gone with me to my grave.

Thus... with Cerb being murdered tonight (incidentily the only guy we all knew was clean because of his ties with poor Invisibletank), it's pretty clear to me that Kirennia is the Godfather. He couldn't murder me tonight because he would then get 100% lynched today. If Vasconcelos had been the Godfather, murdering me would have been the perfect framing job on Kirennia.

So Vas.. what do you say? Shall we hang the Godfather himself today?

VOTE: KIRENNIA

Btw, this explains Kirennia's pleas for me to investigate him early on.. sneaky Godfather!

 

[Levin]

By the way when I found Kirennia innocent in the investigation I was really scared that Vasconcelos would be the Godfather. Because then he would have won in a very, very neat way.

Oh and one more thing, Vasconcelos.

If I was the Godfather myself, I would have just said that my investigation proved Kirennia to be mafia. Remember that when Kirennia tries to turn you against me.

 

[Cerb]

god dam it it thought id make it to the end!

 

[Vasconcelos]

FFS!!!!!
I was about to make a long post with a detailed reasoning, but cba...

Fuck all! I prefer the bandwagon-jumping mob attitude!!11

BURN KIRENNIA!


VOTE: KIRENNIA

For good or for bad, GAME OVER

 

[Calo]

I told you so!!!!

Why do people find me suspicous? i was contantly helping townies and putting myself on danger!

Never ever trust people no matter what they say/ask/claim.

Btw my job was to cure the psychopat (rubric it seemed) but he got killed first night so my job was done/over. lucky because he would kill randomly people

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 5

Kirennia - 2 - (Levin, Vasconcelos)

Not voted: 1 (Kirennia)

With 3 alive, it takes 2 to lynch.

Levin and Vasconcelos grabbed one of Kirennia's shoulders each, slamming him to the ground and stabbed him with the knife they pulled out of Cerbs cold body.
The pair went to Kirennia's house and searched through all his belongings.
It showed out Kirennia was Don Carlo, the Mafia Godfather!

Game 3 over, TOWN WINS!

Total rolelist:

1. Godfather (Shows up town on investigations, performs nightkills) - Kirennia
2. Mafia Roleblocker (Can't block 1 persons role each night) - English
3. Psychopath (Serial Killer, can be cured by the Psychiatrist) - Rubric
4. Psychiatrist (Can cure Serial Killer and make him into mason, townie) -Calo
5. Cop (Sane cop, Townie) - Levin
6. Doctor (Sane Doctor, Townie) - Lethul
7. Mason with 11 - (invisibletank)
8. Townie - Amanita
9. Townie - Old.Tohtori
10. Townie - Vasconcelos
11. Mason with 7 - Cerb

 

[Iceforge]

Okay, a few questions to the players here before I start game number 4

1) Did you like or dislike roles not being 100% revealed all the time? I mean, masons specificly, I only revealed them as town alligned. Did that hurt or benifit gameplay?

2) In this game I went back and used very basic roles, unlike game 2 that got a bit out of hand! Did people like that?

3) Would people like to be PMed when phase change from night to day or are people fine with having to check it themselves? (seems nobody became inactive, so seems to work for now)

4) Would people like to see the transcript // anyone got any problem if total list of all nightchoises are revealed?

 

[- English -]

I think me and Kir did very well considering the odds were stacked against us. We were kinda hoping that the COp investigated Kir early which would have probably won us the game. I think i was UL to go out before Calo, or did he get lucky?

Been a very fun game though, hope the next can compare anywere near to it

 

[kirennia]

Aye, Levin, you won that game effectively; myself and English had some pretty detailed plans for each night describing what would happen in each instance, it was just a shame you never took the bait and investigated me

Had to keep you alive really, hoping you'd investigate me earlier so we could take you out of the game and play it fine from there.

I'd also point out that had there of not been any masons, it would have been a much easier game as that effectively guaranteed the two people to be innocent and took one of our night choices away. 2 mafia against 9 townies was a hard but very fun game

Also a shame I never got to say anything in the last round, had things to deal with but no worries.

Cheers Iceforge for a very fun game

edit:Am in a way glad we didn't win, to win with those odds would've made my suspicious of my own psych, hehe.

Okay, a few questions to the players here before I start game number 4

1) Did you like or dislike roles not being 100% revealed all the time? I mean, masons specificly, I only revealed them as town alligned. Did that hurt or benifit gameplay?

2) In this game I went back and used very basic roles, unlike game 2 that got a bit out of hand! Did people like that?

3) Would people like to be PMed when phase change from night to day or are people fine with having to check it themselves? (seems nobody became inactive, so seems to work for now)

4) Would people like to see the transcript // anyone got any problem if total list of all nightchoises are revealed?

1)No reason they should be revealed really, it'd make it 100 times worse for the mafia who already have a tough job.

2)I thought they were actually more detailed roles which I liked.

3)No need, it'd just slow the game down

4)Would love to see it but then again, I'm pretty sure I could guess what went on. Wonder if people would want to see mine and Englishes ideas for each night ^^

 

[old.Tohtori]

*raises from the grave*

Braaaaains...ahem...i mean.

Jolly good show, i win too! Even if... you bastards, you utter utter cow-utter bastards! *waves finger* I told you i was innocent.

Heck, it takes a psycho to know a psycho, atleast i knew Rubric was nasty.

Though, have to say i was way of on more then one point. Ah well. Roll in next game!

 

[kirennia]

Forgot to mention, I was surprised no-one noticed or brought up the fact me and English have the same avatars and picked on me once he was out

 

[Levin]

YES!!!!! *highfives Vas*

Dear lord that was fun! Kirennia, you're one devious SOB! It wasn't until we lynched Calo that I knew 100% you were the main man, even if i strongly suspected you before then. It was interesting how, at the end of the game, I got kind of immune as a cop since my death would pinpoint you. Then again, if Vas had been the Godfather he would have won so HARD.. that's what I was really afraid of until we got the message that Cerb had been slain.

I am curious though, what would you have said to convince Vas? I bet it would have been something about how I as a mafia could easily have "investigated" Vas on the first round and id'd him as a townie (with no risk of getting caught since the cop can't tell specific roles), and then done the same for Cerb and Lethul. Cerb was even easier being linked with Invisible.

Iceforge, about your questions. I felt, since I couldn't investigate specific roles, it would have been extremely easy for a mafia to counterclaim my cop role and for them to start pointing out innocents as well. Then again, maybe it's a balance issue.. i just saw it as terrible from my cop point of view.

About PMs when night phase is over.. nah, no need. At least it worked nicely in this game without them.

About roles.. it seemed pretty advanced to me! It was definately not too basic! I didn't even know there was a roleblocker. Did you mean to say English could block other people's roles? In your description it says "can't" block...

I would love to see a transcript, as long as it's okay with the people involved.

Lastly, thank you so much Iceforge for a great fun game! Oh and please don't make me a cop again in the next game - nobody would believe me!