Melachi
Fledgling Freddie
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2003
- Messages
- 1,001
Ok, for comparsions sake, taking your examples from above...
A Dwarf Berserker with +15con at creation, +75con from sc, and +200 hits from SC he will have:
1896 hps
A troll with +10con at creation, +75con from sc and +200hits from SC will have:
1825 hps
Even though the Troll only had +10 at creation, and the Dwarf had +15, theres just under a 75hps difirence. While at the same time:
Imagining the Troll had +10 str at creation, and the Dwarf also had +10 str at creation:
The troll with +10 str at creation, +11 from SC, +75 str from SC, and 50weapon spec will have:
1412~ Weaponskill
The Dwarf with +10 str at creation, +11 from SC, +75 str from SC and 50 weapon spec will have:
1263~ Weaponskill
So a difirence of about 150 Weaponskill.
Lets look at quickness too, imagining both Troll and Dwarf started without putting points into quickness at creation, and using 4.0 speed weapons.
The Dwarf with +0 qui at creation, and +75qui from SC, will swing his 4.0 speed weapon at:
3.48 seconds a swing
The Troll with +0 qui at creation, and +75qui from SC, will swing his 4.0 speed weapon at:
3.6 seconds a swing
So thats a difirence of 12 miliseconds.
Even though the Dwarf had the advantage of getting +15 con at creation while the Troll only had +10 con, you can see the HPs bonus a Dwarf gets are minimal, and the swingspeed is small, the weaponskill advantage of the Troll, while not massive I agree still offsets both of these.
Regarding Dex. I know it may have plenty of use in the BG's since alot of dueling goes on there I imagine, and Im sure it would help alot for XPing too, in RvR rarely imo will you have a chance of Parrying, and when you do it will usualy be at a stage where your dead regardless. You either being zerged, all your support is dead and now the group is finishing off the tanks, your being nuked, its a gimp group your fighting and they insist on meleeing the Berserker first (in this case the group your fighting is prolly gonna lose ) ect.. ect..
For thid, sure Dwarf has its advantages, also the height thing helps in thid also. But in RvR, I see no reason not to go Troll, unless for looks, allthough imo Male Trolls look cool
A Dwarf Berserker with +15con at creation, +75con from sc, and +200 hits from SC he will have:
1896 hps
A troll with +10con at creation, +75con from sc and +200hits from SC will have:
1825 hps
Even though the Troll only had +10 at creation, and the Dwarf had +15, theres just under a 75hps difirence. While at the same time:
Imagining the Troll had +10 str at creation, and the Dwarf also had +10 str at creation:
The troll with +10 str at creation, +11 from SC, +75 str from SC, and 50weapon spec will have:
1412~ Weaponskill
The Dwarf with +10 str at creation, +11 from SC, +75 str from SC and 50 weapon spec will have:
1263~ Weaponskill
So a difirence of about 150 Weaponskill.
Lets look at quickness too, imagining both Troll and Dwarf started without putting points into quickness at creation, and using 4.0 speed weapons.
The Dwarf with +0 qui at creation, and +75qui from SC, will swing his 4.0 speed weapon at:
3.48 seconds a swing
The Troll with +0 qui at creation, and +75qui from SC, will swing his 4.0 speed weapon at:
3.6 seconds a swing
So thats a difirence of 12 miliseconds.
Even though the Dwarf had the advantage of getting +15 con at creation while the Troll only had +10 con, you can see the HPs bonus a Dwarf gets are minimal, and the swingspeed is small, the weaponskill advantage of the Troll, while not massive I agree still offsets both of these.
Regarding Dex. I know it may have plenty of use in the BG's since alot of dueling goes on there I imagine, and Im sure it would help alot for XPing too, in RvR rarely imo will you have a chance of Parrying, and when you do it will usualy be at a stage where your dead regardless. You either being zerged, all your support is dead and now the group is finishing off the tanks, your being nuked, its a gimp group your fighting and they insist on meleeing the Berserker first (in this case the group your fighting is prolly gonna lose ) ect.. ect..
For thid, sure Dwarf has its advantages, also the height thing helps in thid also. But in RvR, I see no reason not to go Troll, unless for looks, allthough imo Male Trolls look cool