Shovel
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2003
- Messages
- 1,350
Is he right? He is for some people but I'm not sure that anyone has ever been able to decide something as definate as that for all cases.
The depression I'm familar with can have plenty of fueling issues at any one time (such is everyday-life on top of the illness), but no actual singular 'root cause' (after many years of looking and treatment).
I'm afriad that to the best of my knowledge, it's really not that simply. It's hard, because to comprehend depression we're faced with having to simplify it, but even the slightest simplification can detract from the fact that the condition is mostly individual and where a 'tough love' treatment might work for one sufferer, it would send another to a prompt and early grave. Medication works for some, not for others, to different degrees. The same for counselling.
I kinda sympathise with those who have 'made up their mind' about it, it's a very human thing to fix on a definate explaination (right/wrong or otherwise). However, this is the human mind we're talking about, not a broken leg.
The depression I'm familar with can have plenty of fueling issues at any one time (such is everyday-life on top of the illness), but no actual singular 'root cause' (after many years of looking and treatment).
I'm afriad that to the best of my knowledge, it's really not that simply. It's hard, because to comprehend depression we're faced with having to simplify it, but even the slightest simplification can detract from the fact that the condition is mostly individual and where a 'tough love' treatment might work for one sufferer, it would send another to a prompt and early grave. Medication works for some, not for others, to different degrees. The same for counselling.
I kinda sympathise with those who have 'made up their mind' about it, it's a very human thing to fix on a definate explaination (right/wrong or otherwise). However, this is the human mind we're talking about, not a broken leg.