Off-topic Mafia #4 game thread

[Levin]

Levin & Thot, are you both mafia or is one of you misguided?

If you are amazingly both misguided you will look as guilty as hell tomorrow.

Why are you so surprised? Obviously you must think I am mafia since you voted for me.

Amanita: Yes, I am. And I have my reasons.

 

[Levin]

If you are amazingly both misguided you will look as guilty as hell tomorrow.

I'll take that risk. I realize if you turn out innocent, those who vote for you will look suspicious. That's the nature of this whole thing. Still, we got to start taking action, and quite simply I suspect you more than I suspect others. At least I have stated my reasons why I suspect you, and you have so far done nothing to contest them; in fact you have done quite the contrary!

 

[old.Tohtori]

Rubric i've suspected you for a long time, now it seems, as good as any choice really at this point, that atleast i can remove Lethul from my list of suspects if you happen to be innocent.

Ofcourse people will look at the votes and go "ooh you voted to hang him!", but the chances are, we're gonna hang mafia or a townie, kinda 50 50.

So should i vote for Levin? And when Levin turns out innocent as a suprise, should we hang you next for advocating that?

 

[Lethul]

A votecount would indeed be good at this point.

I just happen to suspect Rubric a lot more for his words and actions than I suspect Amanita for her silence. I'm not going to swing around and change my vote just to try to prove something to finger pointers.

My vote stands for Rubric.

Levin has made all the best "arguments" so far reading back in the posts. Even if the start of the game is much shooting in the dark.

Unvote, Vote: Rubric

 

[Vasconcelos]

VOTE: RUBRIC

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 2

Rubric - 6 - (Vasconcelos, Levin, Amanita, Olgaline, Old.Tohtori, Lethul)
Amanita - 2 - (Kirennia, Cerb)
Levin - 1 - (Rubric)

Not voting: 3 (Calo, English, Wonk)

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

Sorry about late votecount, but just felt so lazy yesterday (thats not an excuse, just me saying!)

 

[- English -]

vote rubric

time to get on with it imo

 

[Olgaline]

here we go... :s

 

[Levin]

*buckles seatbelt*

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 2

Rubric - 7 - (Vasconcelos, Levin, Amanita, Olgaline, Old.Tohtori, Lethul, English)
Amanita - 2 - (Kirennia, Cerb)
Levin - 1 - (Rubric)

Not voting: 2 (Calo, Wonk)

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

The town's people starred at Rubric. They then moved to pick him up by his hands and feet and carried him above their heads to the nearest Tree they could find. They put a rope around and his neck and left him there throughout the night to die. Investigating his house they found out he was Vanilla Townie

There was a shear silence as everyone quietly went back home

Start Night 2, No posting in thread, people with nightchoises send them in to me! Deadline on Sunday 18 CET

 

[Iceforge]

The Sun's rays shone down from above the town. Once more, another town's man hadn't turned up. They quickly reailsed it was Wonk, Vanilla Townie. The crowd started bickering and pointing at each other with anger!

Start day 3, feel free to post again!

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

 

[Olgaline]

well,

dear fellow townies are you about ready to listen to me on the matter of amanita,levin, toht issue ?

 

[Olgaline]

I might be mistaken but i strongly dout it.

i see two options with the three of them 3x mafia or they are 3 masons with 1 mafia traitor in their mist

 

[old.Tohtori]

Well you didn't wait long to vote for Rubric either. Guess there were 7 people wrong about this.

I don't know if amanita or Levin are mafia, but i'm kinda leaning towards either. Amanita for being quiet, and Levin for seemingly pushing things around.Like i think i said earlier, if Levin is mafia, damn well played.

Now i don't know who the hell to vote as my own suspicions were blown right out the water.

 

[- English -]

i do actually think its Toht... I wanna get this round rolling!

vote Tohtori

what do u have to say to defend yourself

 

[Olgaline]

the one kill pr night is kinda confusing me tho' either we dont ahve a serial killer or a damn good doc, I'm leanign towards no serial killer this time tho'

wich prob means 3 mafia also

 

[Levin]

Well, I'm all clueless as well then. I was sure Rubric was mafia, the way he behaved. Why couldn't he have defended himself better? Either way, I gave some honest reasons why i voted for him, contrary to those who just jumped the "bandwagon". Which behaviour is more "suspicious"?

Anyway, I can now tell you why I ended up eager to have him lynched. These were the scenarios i feared if i would have ended up alone voting Rubric and him not getting lynched:

1) If he was mafia, my gunning for him would likely see me murdered the following night.

2) If he was innocent, the real mafia would likely murder me anyway just to place the blame on Rubric so that we'd lynch him on the day after.

So... my only "hope" was that if i spoke up this strongly against him, that others would help me completely remove him. With him removed, both 1) and 2) scenarios are removed. There's no longer any need for mafia to murder me just to blame someone i've been gunning for.

I guess all this reasoning has been kind of selfish and perhaps even unfounded. Who knows? But done is done, and i didn't force anyone to vote for Rubric. I just put forward how I was thinking, minus the selfish reason that I mentioned just now.

As for how to continue now.. I truly don't know. It feels like we have some very clever mafia players here, and that it could be just anyone. Need to think some more (read: sleep!) and start sorting out this mess tomorrow.

P.S. If we have a cop, now might be a good time to reveal some insights? Masons? Anyone? With 3 townies down and no bad guys, we really need a break here.

 

[old.Tohtori]

i do actually think its Toht... I wanna get this round rolling!

vote Tohtori

what do u have to say to defend yourself

As my defence goes, i can say these:

I think i've judged fairly, as in give reasons for voting and not just /point /hang people.

I think i've TRIED to help this town atleast in speculating, if nothing else. and to actually keep us from getting slaughtered one by one by trying to shed some light on things.

I don't think, correct me if i'm wrong, done anything that would cause me to be suspected, not more then other atleast.

Sure, if i look at the past, agreeing with Levin and Olgaline might be considered as suspected behaviour, but i think i've given fair enough reasons for those "alliance votes" so to speak.

I don't know if amanita or levin are mafia, as olgaline suspects, heck, i don't know if YOU are mafia, i'm just trying to go as i see things and then make the best choice i believe is right. I don't try to keep myself alive, i'm trying to get some good decicions...which hasn't worked, i know.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Have to say english, the way you said it though, does sound a bit eager, as in, not really trying to figure out, but just wanting more hangings.

Not particulary bad thing, but also as worrying as Vascs eagerness.

Also have to say, as earlier, that if Levin or Olgaline is mafia, they've played some really nice tactics. But i just don't see them being.

Maybe i need to sleep on it too, nearing 2am and my brain ain't all that great.

 

[Cerb]

im begining to agree with the whole levin amenita toth option as the mafia and im goin to go with Vote:Levin as hes been very vocal from the start and constantly trying to bring people around to his way of thinking...now i may be wrong and he may be trying to help us out here but i find it a bit suspect

 

[Olgaline]

I'm gonna go with my initial choice altho cerb & english you two are scaring me abit now!
you dont question me at all ?

anywhoo,

do or die This time I'm sticking with it, as I've steared wrong by joining in so far.

Vote: Amanita

 

[- English -]

I'm gonna go with my initial choice altho cerb & english you two are scaring me abit now!
you dont question me at all ?

anywhoo,

do or die This time I'm sticking with it, as I've steared wrong by joining in so far.

Vote: Amanita

id happily reveal my class though i can assure i would be certainly killed next round. Imo its toht/levin or if not amanita.

 

[Amanita]

I'm afraid I am going to accuse Levin this time around. (sorry sweetheart!) I think he's being too pushy towards getting certain folks lynched, and since Rubric wasn't mafia and Levin being so eager to get him killed...

Vote: Levin

 

[- English -]

I'm afraid I am going to accuse Levin this time around. (sorry sweetheart!) I think he's being too pushy towards getting certain folks lynched, and since Rubric wasn't mafia and Levin being so eager to get him killed...

i thought this aswell but i tink toht is acting suspicously. It was between them, but at the moment my vote sticks

 

[Vasconcelos]

Right now I doubt of every1!!!!

Funny enuff, its Lethul, who voted me 2 times straight, the one who gives me little more confidence...

Holding my vote untill I make up my mind.

 

[Levin]

I'm afraid I am going to accuse Levin this time around. (sorry sweetheart!) I think he's being too pushy towards getting certain folks lynched, and since Rubric wasn't mafia and Levin being so eager to get him killed...

Vote: Levin

I've explained why, and I don't actually believe I was all that "pushy". As I said, all I did was presenting my reasons and then let people decide for themselves. A lot of people happened to follow my vote for one reason or another. If you're just a townie sweetie, you may want to consider those who never give any reasons for their actions to be just as suspicious.

All that said, I can of course not blame you for suspecting me. I would too, just as I suspect pretty much everyone in town. It's just kind of sad that those who get the ball rolling always get the evil eye from the others even if they voted just as much. With that mentality of people being afraid of taking initiatives, we'll get a town where the mafia can just pick us off one after another because every day will be a "no lynch".

So.. this time i'm not going to take any initiatives at all, and just be a bandwagon person. I'll add my vote later, so i'm not accused of starting anything again.

I can say one thing though, that has nothing to do with voting or pointing fingers. Have you noticed that the mafia has so far only murdered the quiet people? Kind of the "least" suspicious ones so to speak? Why do you think that is?

 

[Wonk]

sorry folks, i've been hospitalized and therefore unable to post :| I'll read up on it.

 

[old.Tohtori]

i thought this aswell but i tink toht is acting suspicously. It was between them, but at the moment my vote sticks

Some form of justification for "suspiciously" would be nice. Atleast if you''re going to hang me, tell me why, not without some reason. I'd do the same to you if i voted for you.

Anyway, if you die next night, people will blame me. If you don't, you'll blame me, so good job, i can't do this way or the other about you.

I'm not voting yet, as i'm not sure who to believe anymore.

 

[Calo]

sorry folks, i've been hospitalized and therefore unable to post :| I'll read up on it.

You are dead!

 

[- English -]

Some form of justification for "suspiciously" would be nice. Atleast if you''re going to hang me, tell me why, not without some reason. I'd do the same to you if i voted for you.

Anyway, if you die next night, people will blame me. If you don't, you'll blame me, so good job, i can't do this way or the other about you.

I'm not voting yet, as i'm not sure who to believe anymore.

Hmm i dont have any really. But your one of those people who I wouldnt want in the game. And considering you were a Townie last game, i suspect your Mafia this game. Even though it may have been random, I dont trust that.