Off-topic Mafia #4 game thread

[- English -]

Alright, I think it's safe to assume we have a storyteller among us, and i bet it's Tohtori!

the question is do we believe the storyteller or not, he could be mafia afterall.

 

[Vasconcelos]

Whats the meaning of Lethul scurring into the crowd.........???

 

[Levin]

Does it really matters if someone is an author though? That's why I thought it was you Toh, because claiming (or being obvious about it) that role wouldn't mean much at all really.. i thought it was just a flavour thing?

As for poor Invisibletank.. yes i suppose they got him for being very quiet and not adding much to the plot, or something. He never voted for anyone either, did he? So as i feared, we're now left with nothing more at all to go on, and one townie less.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Does it really matters if someone is an author though? That's why I thought it was you Toh, because claiming (or being obvious about it) that role wouldn't mean much at all really.. i thought it was just a flavour thing?

I thought that the storyteller is like, well, role that has no other roles. Like, vigilante or something.

Whats the meaning of Lethul scurring into the crowd.........???

Well now that sounds like you wrote it and are now trying to hang him too!

Well, come to think of it, since we have nothing new, lethul is still a suspect like yesterday. But like i said, i'm gonna wait a bit more and see.

 

[Olgaline]

this is indeed as suprise, but it's definatly given me some clues

 

[Cerb]

Annoyed now as i thougt the no lynch would lead to help..seems to have given us no idea

 

[Levin]

The best way to get clues is probably to lynch every day, and try to figure out patterns after a bunch of lynches. I really don't believe in letting days pass like this.. it only lets the mafia pick us off one by one until we stand no chance.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Annoyed now as i thougt the no lynch would lead to help..seems to have given us no idea

Unless you count (invisibletank) being really really innocent *zoolander face*

The best way to get clues is probably to lynch every day, and try to figure out patterns after a bunch of lynches. I really don't believe in letting days pass like this.. it only lets the mafia pick us off one by one until we stand no chance.

This is probably in the minds of everyone, that we can't just sit around, like i said yesterday, and wait to be killed.

Thing is, do we go back to day 1 suspects, or do we start from scratch and just start hanging random people?

Also the real bummer about this is that the towns most valuable asset, if there is a cop around, can't speak up because it's a suicide run. I know i personally would keep rather quiet about being one and just try to maybe point at a direction.

 

[Rubric]

Unless you count (invisibletank) being really really innocent *zoolander face*



This is probably in the minds of everyone, that we can't just sit around, like i said yesterday, and wait to be killed.

Thing is, do we go back to day 1 suspects, or do we start from scratch and just start hanging random people?

Also the real bummer about this is that the towns most valuable asset, if there is a cop around, can't speak up because it's a suicide run. I know i personally would keep rather quiet about being one and just try to maybe point at a direction.

I think there must be some clues in yesterdays voting, i don't have time to read back through the posts at the moment though

 

[old.Tohtori]

I think there must be some clues in yesterdays voting, i don't have time to read back through the posts at the moment though

Aye. But if i keep my stance, and vote for Lethul, like i did after Vasc, it's exactly the same situation as yesterday. that's why i'd rather wait and see what people have to say before going with the gut feeling.

Also thinking still about you Rubric, and the few weird votes, in sync with Lethul. But can't be bothered to say them all again...

But, then again we have the REALLY quiet amanita who we almost decided to hang, unless it's just what they want us to do.

 

[Levin]

It really doesnt help with all these quiet people. It makes you wonder if they're just not following the game as closely as the rest, or if they're just trying to keep a low profile.

And about the cop.. I suppose we should give him another night to investigate, but if he wants to help the town he really should speak up soon. We don't want to accidentily lynch him, or risk him getting randomly murdered by the mafia. We need that info!

That is, if we even have a cop.

 

[Lethul]

old.Toth: The cop speaking up is not suicide IF we have a doctor aswell.

 

[Lethul]

this "no lynch" can't go on at least imo.

I'm thorn between Amanita or Wonk, they are just to quiet

 

[old.Tohtori]

old.Toth: The cop speaking up is not suicide IF we have a doctor aswell.

Well that's true.

Though it would take both doc and cop to speak up on the same day, 'cause otherwise, either one is prime candidate.

And isn't that protection for just one night? As surely the doc would die the very next one, to give an open road to the cop?

Ah but yes, if the doc is ASSUMED to be around, then he/she could stay in hiding and protect the cop.

 

[Lethul]

Well that's true.

Though it would take both doc and cop to speak up on the same day, 'cause otherwise, either one is prime candidate.

And isn't that protection for just one night? As surely the doc would die the very next one, to give an open road to the cop?

Ah but yes, if the doc is ASSUMED to be around, then he/she could stay in hiding and protect the cop.

The doc don't have to speak up. He can just keep the protection on cop.

 

[old.Tohtori]

The doc don't have to speak up. He can just keep the protection on cop.

Yeah, didn't think it through until the very end of my post.

The thing is though, can we be sure of any role?

Wouldn't want to announce myself as a cop and then get killed when no doc is around.

 

[kirennia]

Docs can protect themselves too overnight, the only way for the doc/cop combo to gain an advantage is if the cop first discovers a mason as they did the last game.

But then again as you say, it'd still require for them to reveal themselves in the same day. The best thing I'd say for a cop to do would be to get a couple of people firstly investigated then come out with it tomorrow. That way if they're killed it'll just prove the two people they investigated are really townies (or a godfather?). That way a doctors protection isn't completely needed.

I'm still not sure what to do; got to go tomorrow morning so hoping for some leads but if we have really quiet people again today, I know exactly where my vote is going...

 

[Olgaline]

I for one got alot of info from whats happened uptil now
so i dont really get tho's that say we've learned nothing.

one thing tho'
the talk/threat of a "no lynch" was far more usefull than the actual action there of.
I for one learned alot and have my prime suspects.

But for now I'll stick with my initial vote, as i have reason to belive I'm onto something
so..............

Vote: Amanita

 

[Olgaline]

oh and there is absolutly no reason what so ever for the doc to reveal himself for any other reason than if his welfare is somehow threatend by his fellow townies!

 

[Olgaline]

or later on in the game to deduct players out of the mafia equasion!

 

[Levin]

I'm currently torn between voting for someone who's been really quiet, or someone whom I suspect for other reasons. Hmmm.

 

[Cerb]

im starting to change my mind about the whole no lynch thing but id not like to vote for someone just because they're quiet....however there seem to be some who are too quiet....

 

[Vasconcelos]

Docs can protect themselves too overnight, the only way for the doc/cop combo to gain an advantage is if the cop first discovers a mason as they did the last game.

But then again as you say, it'd still require for them to reveal themselves in the same day. The best thing I'd say for a cop to do would be to get a couple of people firstly investigated then come out with it tomorrow. That way if they're killed it'll just prove the two people they investigated are really townies (or a godfather?). That way a doctors protection isn't completely needed.

I'm still not sure what to do; got to go tomorrow morning so hoping for some leads but if we have really quiet people again today, I know exactly where my vote is going...

Prob is that if the cop gets randomly killed, he wouldnt be able to announce the results of his investigation...

dunno if its just me but the last nite result didnt clarify nmothing for me. Im exactly at the same point than last week cept 1 less person to suspect, poor Invis may he be taken into the bossom of the lord

At the end, i find my behaviour pretty consistent: i just randomed a name to start with n drag some ppl into discussion (even if i attracted all the fire on me), and then i just voted the other person with enuff votes to cover my ass from a lynch.

If right now I had to choose another name to discard, I'd go for the more quiet ppl, like you said, either Amanita or Wonk. Not gonna vote yet, but be sure I wont contribute to let another No Lynch day pass.

Just my 2 cents

 

[old.Tohtori]

I for one got alot of info from whats happened uptil now
so i dont really get tho's that say we've learned nothing.

Aye, learned plenty along the way and from peoples reactions, but last night didn't give out much info. I mean, atleast to me, if you got something you're a wiser man then me *laugh*

Like i said, voting for Amanita is to get an inactive one out. But i'd vote for her because, well, inactive doesn't mean inactive, it means more towards "staying out of light". Or some such.

But i'd also like to think about my reasoning before, and as such, i should vote lethul or Rubric. So..urhm...well, i'm gonna trust that Olgaline has more of a theory then me so.

Vote: Amanita

 

[old.Tohtori]

then i just voted the other person with enuff votes to cover my ass from a lynch.

And now i'm SO tempted to go back to my original suspect...

 

[Amanita]

Or I am inactive because I wanted to be mafia and I am sulking at the random generator I was all nice and peaceful yesterday, wotcha wanna kill me for?

I confess all this over-tactising is making my head spin

 

[Vasconcelos]

And now i'm SO tempted to go back to my original suspect...

None wants to be lynched, even fair vanilla townies like me.....

 

[kirennia]

Two ways we can play this; we can lynch another sort-of-guessing random today or we could play it out another night with no lynch and hope the cop returns with something useful tomorrow. I guess the problem with the second option is that if there is no cop, we're pretty much screwed but if there is, that's potentially three people in the clear straight away on that day and we can start narrowing down choices.

I would as previously said though, not even think of the cop revealing themselves today as they'd most likely be killed, roleblocked or whatever straight away and we'd be kept in the dark.

There is no solid evidenve to prove anyone has any role currently so I'm not willing to double the mafias 'score' for today on a whim...

 

[Olgaline]

My guess, and yes it's only a guess since i dont have much to back it up is
that amanita is the intended role blocker,

How ever Toht agreeing with me really scares me, and i still have him and levin suspected of being the other two.

But kirennia, vasc and cerb also have my undevoted attention

 

[old.Tohtori]

My guess, and yes it's only a guess since i dont have much to back it up is
that amanita is the intended role blocker,

How ever Toht agreeing with me really scares me, and i still have him and levin suspected of being the other two.

But kirennia, vasc and cerb also have my undevoted attention

Basically suspecting everyone? *laugh* Well, understandable.

My reason for going with amanita, is that i don't suspect you of being mafia, atleast as much as others. Amanita was someone i was willing to put into vote yesterday, so why would today be different. Even if i did go with my initial Lethul vote, i doubt people would think like i do. And as i think you're part of this town, i also have to trust that you have some sort of thought pattern.

As such, our thought patterns collide somewhat at amanita, so it's a logical choice.