Off-topic Mafia #4 game thread

[Rubric]

hey all, apologies busy day,

yes seel, my vote for lethul is odd. that was the plan, then looking at peoples reactions to it. see if i can gauge anything from it.

 

[Cerb]

ok just home from work and after a good read ive decided to hop off the fence and vote....i figure a random lynch today isnt good for us as odds are we'll lynch one of ourselves and put us at more of a disadvantage so im goin to
Vote: No lynch
This way we can see who has been killed tomorrow and see who they had a suspicion for...we only lose one and have more of an idea!

 

[Levin]

This way we can see who has been killed tomorrow and see who they had a suspicion for...

That's not really going to help. If two townies suspect eachother, one getting lynched doesn't mean the other is guilty.

 

[Cerb]

That's not really going to help. If two townies suspect eachother, one getting lynched doesn't mean the other is guilty.

a good point...oh christ dont get me unsure again

 

[Vasconcelos]

A No Lynch day is a nono for townies

 

[old.Tohtori]

hey all, apologies busy day,

yes seel, my vote for lethul is odd. that was the plan, then looking at peoples reactions to it. see if i can gauge anything from it.

So you're doing the same thing that Vasc is doing. It's a nice enough way and well used plan, BUT it also gets you hanged very often, much like the "let's say stuff" way Vasc is displaying.

Also, are you now saying that to save Lethul, your suspected friend in crime to get a few votes and not get Lethul hanged, or just trying to throw more suspicion out of your way and save your own behind? Because have to say, it looks more like a "It worked for Vasc, i'll use this too" excuse.

That's not really going to help. If two townies suspect eachother, one getting lynched doesn't mean the other is guilty.

Have to say, even if it's a valid point, that it's most likely going to go that way. One says "this guy is bad!", and then when he's not, and an innocent is hanged, they all turn to the guy saying it and want to hang him, no matter how innocent of a guess, or a reasoning it was.

 

[Olgaline]

Well,

Personally I'm going to vote for Amanita, and here's why

The game having run for a couple of days now Amanita hasnt posted even once,
now this means that he's either quiet on purpose or inactive.

now if he's inactive I'd like to see him hung innocent or not, the reason is I'd rather know that the doc, cop, shrink ect was inactive and now dead and out of the game, than have him inactive and f.exp not able to counter claim a mafia, also this way i can then discard that role from the game and shift focus ect.

so by doing this I'm either forcing him to come forth and post or be lynched and we can then discard him inocent or not so to speak.

Vote Amanita

note that I'm not accusing Amanita of being guilty, but he is a liability as long as he's this inactive!

 

[Levin]

Well,

Personally I'm going to vote for Amanita, and here's why

The game having run for a couple of days now Amanita hasnt posted even once,
now this means that he's either quiet on purpose or inactive.

now if he's inactive I'd like to see him hung innocent or not, the reason is I'd rather know that the doc, cop, shrink ect was inactive and now dead and out of the game, than have him inactive and f.exp not able to counter claim a mafia, also this way i can then discard that role from the game and shift focus ect.

so by doing this I'm either forcing him to come forth and post or be lynched and we can then discard him inocent or not so to speak.

Vote Amanita

note that I'm not accusing Amanita of being guilty, but he is a liability as long as he's this inactive!

Not that I imagine it would change your vote in any way, but I thought I would just point it out anyway.. Amanita is actually a girl, yes a REAL girl! It just looks funny when you refer to her as a him all the time. *grins*

 

[Olgaline]

oh heh no i did not know that, sorry Amanita guess i just took it for granted,
I shall fall inline from now on and refer to you as Her
my sincere apologies

and your right wont make me change my vote

 

[Olgaline]

afterall gender dosent really change anything

 

[Olgaline]

if she comes forward and gives me a good reason for her absence and lack of parcitipation then I'm more than willing to reconcider ofc

 

[Amanita]

Sorry folks! Been away for the weekend. Gimmie a couple of hours to read up on all the fun and then consider who I want to blame!

And yeah, it is weird everyone's referring to me as a he

 

[Wonk]

The mafia really has found the thin line here. I was expecting someone to make a step in the wrong direction sooner or later. Something drastic has to happen soonish.

 

[Amanita]

Well, like JD I am a member of the watensee tribe...
Until someone can show me a really good reason to lynch someone (other than myself! Don't kill the innocent!):

Vote: No lynch

 

[Olgaline]

vote count

please

 

[Olgaline]

looks like we'r faced with a status que atm ?

 

[old.Tohtori]

Alls that can be said, is said at the moment.

Welcome back to the real world Amanita, even if i'm still owndering how anyone could think Trans-Ama could be a man...

Anyhoo. Sticking with my vote, for now.

What aobut your vote Olgaline, Amanita seems nice enough, but ofcourse, this could just be a fiendish tactic.

 

[Iceforge]

Votecount
Day: Day 1

Lethul - 4 - (Vasconcelos, Levin, Old.Tohtori, Rubric)
Amanita - 1 - (Olgaline)
Vasconcelos - 1 - (Lethul)

No Lynch: 5 - (Amanita, English, Kirennia, Cerb, Wonk)

Not voted yet: 2 (Calo, Invisibletank)

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

 

[Lethul]

What have i done to deserve this voting? Not retaliating on Rubric cause i think Vasc voting is dangerous regardless if he is townie or mafia? Will everyone unvote if i vote Rubric instead?

 

[Lethul]

to me it looks like me and Olgaline are most innocent so far, not bandwagooning anyone.

 

[old.Tohtori]

What have i done to deserve this voting? Not retaliating on Rubric cause i think Vasc voting is dangerous regardless if he is townie or mafia? Will everyone unvote if i vote Rubric instead?

Well, my reasoning was that you and Rubric seemed in kahootch(explained earlier), i'd rather take out Rubric though 'cause you might just be a pawn, but if people want to vote you more, then, well...

 

[Rubric]

to me it looks like me and Olgaline are most innocent so far, not bandwagooning anyone.

Unvote: Lethul
Vote: No Lynch

Makes me look guilty as hell i know. But as i said i was only using my vote to get an idea of people from how they reacted. I have no view on Lethul's guilt or innocence at this stage and therefore don't want to be responsible for a lynching. I also have no real idea on who is guilty. Will need to have another read of the thread when i have more time.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Unvote: Lethul
Vote: No Lynch

Makes me look guilty as hell i know.

It didn't look guilty, that much, until you said "makes me look guilty", as now it makes it look like you said it makes you look guilty to avoid being looking guilty...

I hate my head...

 

[Rubric]

One more no lynch for a sensible end to day 1. Managed to get a bit of debate and voting to give us some clues. Now it's time to let the night draw in peacefully and take stock tomorrow.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Actually your unvoting did confirm what i was thinking.

Because, well, if you were in it together, then you would unvote as Lethul already got 4 votes.

But this will most likely end peacefully, unless people start voting for people.

 

[Levin]

It's a shame that so many want to give the mafia a freebie nightkill, but since this seems to be the longest day ever (even longer than D-day!) I guess I'll go with the flow and vote like everyone else - just so we can finally move along.

Unvote: Lethul
Vote: No lynch

 

[old.Tohtori]

Fair enough. I would've liked to take a chance(sings take some ABBA), but this works too. Maybe the night gives some idea, even if the skeptic in me says we're in the same mess tomorrow with one extra body.

*locks doors and windows and sits in the lazy-boy-recliner-1960 version with a shotgun*

 

[Cerb]

Fair enough. I would've liked to take a chance(sings take some ABBA), but this works too. Maybe the night gives some idea, even if the skeptic in me says we're in the same mess tomorrow with one extra body.

*locks doors and windows and sits in the lazy-boy-recliner-1960 version with a shotgun*

i disagree! this way we have only have one of us dead and at least some clue as chances are we would have goten one of us...so hopefully only one of the innocent dead! *crosses fingers that theres no serial killer*

 

[old.Tohtori]

i disagree! this way we have only have one of us dead and at least some clue as chances are we would have goten one of us...so hopefully only one of the innocent dead! *crosses fingers that theres no serial killer*

Seems like it's a serious opinion divider.

If we vote for noone, there's still the same voting that has to go in tomorrow. As in, we have to hang someone sometime, or else it's good night dolly and off to the cemetary again.

I'm just skeptical about the night giving that much info, but, guess we have to see as the votes are in.

 

[Levin]

I'm with Tohtori on this one. But it feels like we're stuck in groundhog day here so i'd rather just get on with things and let a new day dawn. I really doubt we will be any wiser after one of us is dead though. The only thing that can possible come out of it is "so and so voted for so and so and now he's dead, everybody get him!" which is just as random as randomly voting for someone on day 1. Make sense?

And cops etc... can be insane or might not be, so not much to go on there either. Basicly, we're screwed backwards either way. I'd have preferred to at least shoot a few rounds in the blind before we go down. That would give us some info, regardless if we got an innocent or a mafia or a crazy turkey.

Aaaanyway.... bring on the night! *barricades his doors and places a standing bathtub in the closet*