I was with you until you said something bad about Baldur's Gate 2.
BURN HIM.
Was DA2 that bad? Loved first one but never got around to playing the second.
Just can't find the motivation to get through Witcher2. The combat annoys me. The "hit, roll, Quen, hit, roll" thing is just not capturing me.
I picked up Divinity II - Dragon Knight Saga in the Steam sale recently. Despite being being a "cheap" Dragon Age 2 / Witcher 2 clone it has one thing both those lack. It's fun.