Werezomwolfbie Game thread #10

[Ch3tan]

you are ignoring the possibility of a rhubarb infection baddie itcheh, and so doing nothing would play into their hands.

Knowing nothing, we cannot actually do nothing. We need to do something so we get an inkling of what is going on.

Toht, that was what I expected you to say, but your argument, whilst long, IS easily swept aside. That is why Olga did it so well.

I don't buy what you've written, people called you on it because it was obviously a silly statement (you blaming syd), those that have not called you on it probably haven't had time to. I still want to know why you assumed there were two baddies, and on that basis my vote is staying on you.

 

[old.Tohtori]

To get more info on the reactions really, i have no idea on the amount or type of baddies.

It can be swept aside, but so can anything, it STILL gives us info to look into.

Have you noticed, for example, how Calaen has ignored the whole thing? Itcheh ignored Sydrik also, and what i said. Per example.

 

[Sydrik]

I really dont like the way Itcheh is looking at this situation..

I'd almost rather give toht the benefit of the doubt and get rid of someone contributing nothing but pointless ramblings.

 

[Ch3tan]

I don't like doing this so soon after Toht's post.

Toht I will be willing to go along with you, but if you are wrong I want you to be the first to vote for yourself tomorrow.

But you need to pick, itcheh with his odd passive stance or cal with his ignorance?

 

[Sydrik]

unvote: toht

vote: itcheh

suspected from day one.

 

[Calaen]

Ignorance of what? Your random vegetable ramblings?

I've commented on itchehs stance, and I needn't comment on toh simply because someone is always going to try and push people for a reaction. It's pointless jumping down his throat and asking for an explanation.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Those were just examples Ch3t, i'm not that keen to jump on anyone. Still gathering info and musing on theories. If it serves a purpose, i'll gladly vote myself out as i can only contribute what i hear people talking. No special voodoo, no fangs under my lips, no furry likes and no need for brain soup. I do feel a bit gay since we're STILL in an all male village.

Calaen has a good point though and atleast acknowledges the situation.

 

[itcheh]

Look ... what comments am I meant to be reviewing and in what context? There's a perceived evil in the village but we have no crimes, no victims ... and I'm being criticised for inactivity? You're all strange ... and the fact that everyone seems to think Chet with his fruit + vegetable fetish is normal makes me more worried.

 

[Uara]

Knowing nothing, we cannot actually do nothing. We need to do something so we get an inkling of what is going on.

I agree with this tbh. If what has struck our beloved mayor down is infection based then we're going to be buggered, just doing nothing is just going to cause further upset for us down the line.

It is always useful to look at peoples responses to statements and although no-one is clearly jumping out at me (baring not allowing Chet near my fruit bowl in the future) I am willing to go with Tohts response theory at least to some extent (of course I would say that as I was in his rabble-rousing group). As long as we don't get too blinkered in this approach and consider everyone is potentially guilty at this stage.

 

[old.Tohtori]

I have this awful feeling that we should stock up on garlic, i can't explain why, but i just have this incling in my groin region that someone wants to suck me.

I'll go with my own theory as i only can and

vote: itcheh

I can't vote the quiet ones just for being quiet, but i can vote on actions or there lack of as said on my theory. Can't really explain it, but i just feel that's the way my vote should go.

 

[Nate]

So if itcheh turns up good we vote toht tomorrow?

 

[old.Tohtori]

You don't have to vote like i do, i'm most likely wrong.

 

[Calaen]

I'm not so sure about this theroy or stance, but I'll go with said majority.

My only concern with this stance, is that if Toh is an innocent and gets it wrong with Ithceh, if we do have a bad guy on board he isn't giong to target Toh tonight, simply because he's going to get another free go tomorrow.

 

[Calaen]

You don't have to vote like i do, i'm most likely wrong.

Well lets hope you guess right eh? for all of our sakes.

Vote itcheh

 

[old.Tohtori]

I'm not betting my life on that vote by any stretch and as said, the theory isn't that sound.

 

[itcheh]

I love how there's a few people to seem to systematically jump on the next available bandwagon at the first opportunity.

Toht is the latest with his vote... an yet strangely

I'm not betting my life on that vote by any stretch and as said, the theory isn't that sound.

So you're willing to kill me based on nothing ... but you're not willing to bet your own life on it?

FAIL

And as for Sydrik - you are the dodgiest bastard ever.

unvote: toht

vote: itcheh

suspected from day one.

On the basis of nothing!!!!!!

On day 1 (and indeed now) we don't know if anything bad is actually happening ... or to what extent there is badness... but you voted for me on day 1 regardless.

You then voted for Toht on Day 2 without casting so much as a sideways glance at me? A little bit trigger happy there perhaps?

I offered a view for discussion:

1. it was backed by logic because we still don't know wtf is going on
2. I'm willing to put myself out there by being forethright and trying to drive discussion

... and you still think that makes me more guilty (of what?) than the silent majority who are staying quiet???

I think you know more than you're saying ... I think you understand the evil threat to this village because YOU ARE the evil threat.

Vote: Sydrik

 

[old.Tohtori]

Quite itcheh, i'm not betting my life on it and even said i'm most likely wrong.

 

[Calaen]

Then why are you voting for Itcheh then?

I'm retracting my vote for now. I'm not following someone who isn't behind his own decision.

unvote Itcheh

 

[old.Tohtori]

Sounds like a reasonable decision to make to be honest.

 

[Nate]

In your village if the mayor went missing, would you start hanging people? Would you even know?

 

[Nate]

Because that is all we have to go on right now. Other then toht acting strangely.

 

[Calaen]

Sounds like a reasonable decision to make to be honest.

That didn't really answer my question did it

 

[old.Tohtori]

That didn't really answer my question did it

No it didn't, but it was meant to mean that your decision seems reasonable.

 

[Ch3tan]

Nate and itcheh seem to nkow something we dont. What do you sugest we do nate? Twiddle our thumbs until we lose?

 

[Nate]

I say we wait, we will know more tomorrow. I don't think firing blindly will help.

What are we losing? Nothing has happened yet.

 

[Calaen]

What if nothing happens by tomorrow?

If you have asensibl answer then I'll consider holding off on a vote, but I am more inclined to agree with ch3t at the moment. Somethings suerly amiss, but Itcheh and yourself seem relatively calm about whatever is going on. This suggests one or both of you know more than you are making out!

 

[Mabs]

*****
you notice the sky beginning to darken.. how much longer till bed time one wonders!
*****

 

[itcheh]

Somethings suerly amiss, but Itcheh and yourself seem relatively calm about whatever is going on. This suggests one or both of you know more than you are making out!

WRONG

It's means I don't know what is going on ... I have nothing to base any decisions on. I wasn't being inactive to be passive, I was trying not to make a wrong decision based on no information.

There are a few people on here, however, that seem happy to keep wanting a lynching. I would urge the villagers to look at THOSE people - they have the agenda. That's why I've voted for Syrik - he seems to have a bloodlust

 

[Olgaline]

***from my anoying phone, so keeping it short" ***

- Toht brought up the possible need for garlic = bad if we wait, no deaths, just recrutes.

- The killers got blocked = we might as well wait, blocker know who to block, the seer gains more info.

I'm inclined to go with option two. it's a 1 in 7/6 in the towns favor?

 

[old.Tohtori]

Yeah i do believe i'm sleeping in the garlic storage tonight. *points at itchec* So we hanging him or not? No wait, don't. You really shouldn't. Oh go on. No!