Lethul
FH is my second home
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2004
- Messages
- 8,433
Muylaetrix said:i have casted through mellee swing once in a while...
but never in a 1 vs 1.
Any time i was apparently able to cast through a mellee interupt was with massive amounts of mobs/attackers causing probably server lag.
yes, it happens
No, i can`t reliably recreate the occasion...
Matriarch|Sneakers said:no defence? m8 830 af 27% abs armor som proc, malice/battler charge, 70 point abltaive twistable, IP, wingedhelm, FZ,PS thats ur defence![]()
I know full well what makes it good it's why i say the class is balanced i in no way believe we're underpowered, we could do with more none-stealth group utility but in no way do i consider us overpowered either, as assassins are a huge threat to me and usually i have to use charges/RA's/ML's to beat them.i see in ur sig u do have a mincer still u have NO clue on what makes it good and bad
Not true.rvn said:but being meleed, then trying to cast after the first attack round it wont happen unless you moc or qc..
Pricelessacei said:as assassins are a huge threat to me and usually i have to use charges/RA's/ML's to beat them.
acei said:By defense i mean evade/parry/shield. We have no spec in shield and only have evade 2. Our AF/ABS/Ablative/IP is to make up for our lacking defense whereas assassins get extreme amounts of evade and scouts get shield spec and evade, i feel sorry for hunters and rangers though.
Also FZ/PS/Winged helm/Malice/battler can be used by other stealther classes they are NOT minstrel exclusive so in no way can be considered what makes a minstrel OPed.
I know full well what makes it good it's why i say the class is balanced i in no way believe we're underpowered, we could do with more none-stealth group utility but in no way do i consider us overpowered either, as assassins are a huge threat to me and usually i have to use charges/RA's/ML's to beat them.
illu said:1on1 if a mincer loses - it is the mincer's fault as if it goes wrong
And can't they charm pets too? ^^
Oli - Illu
rvn said:with lag its sometimes possible to hit between enemys attack swings, also if you allready started your spell before the enemy reached you you can sometimes get that spell and a second spell off even when the enemy is hitting you, due to server lag and half of the spell being casted before you got interrupted, but being meleed, then trying to cast after the first attack round it wont happen unless you moc or qc..
Eeben said:if they remove stealth from mincers what can we do then?
You ever tryet getting a good grp with a mincer after nf/toa????
Were you buffed? a sitting minstrel taking a direct PA should hurt ALOT! Or did he use malice/battler or get some other debuff off on you while you were zephyred? Yes we can SOS away, it can also be used to kite which is a good method to kill people, but skalds and bards can kite tooillu said:And of course Mincers are OP! I had one baiting me the other day and he sat down. He was that sure that he was going to win, and his health was maybe on 70%. I PA'd him, the sitting target, CD missed, he FZ/IP/bashed me to smithereens. 1on1 if a mincer loses - it is the mincer's fault as if it goes wrong, they use SoS to get the hell out of there :>
And can't they charm pets too? ^^
Damage adder, parry skill, 2 hander, no swapping instruments, insta-mezz, snare... yeah can see why you'd want a no-stealthing minstrelAnd no, but I would happily swap my skald for a mincer.
Nul said:U will have a OP skald....
And no, but I would happily swap my skald for a mincer.
acei said:I want to know which Minstrel "specific" ability people make thinks us overpowered...
noaim said:When they add styledamage to nukes, and makes them stun people if you nuke em from difference positions.
Twinky said:just not fun to play sb vs 3 other stealths and 1 fg..

Bard - heal, speed, end regen, power regen, buffs, demezz, rezz, mezz, AE-mezz (normal cast speed), amnesia, AE-amnesia, insta-mezz, 2xinsta DD's, confuse.tierk said:U have mentioned a host of tools that your class gets on one toon whereas to get all those abilities with any other class u have to playing like 5 classes as u have mentioned, rangers bards skalds amongest others. Do u not see what people are talking about or are you just uping your post count? If mincers are not OP then Warlocks are balanced as well then i guess. Get a grip and face facts you playing in easy mode and if u are getting owned a lot(1vs1 ofc) on yer mincer then u must be one shyte player.
acei said:but seriously it's your chars that are weak minstrel/infil/scout imo is well balanced atm and are where all stealthers should be at.
Every class is unique. Albion has 2 classes that can stun minstrel (instant) cleric (cast), Hibernia has several more and Hibernia's is on primary casters, Midgard has Healers and they have AE and insta versions.tierk said:u get abilities from across the classes of the others realms
Unbreakable? Purge is a RA y'know.u got a unbreakable stun like a chanters stun except yers is even more over powered as u dont have to cast jack shit just hit yer insta and hack hack hack
Healer, scout, ranger, hunter, bard, skald all get the ability as well.u get Fz another super ability
We definately do NOT!!! Our AE-mezz has 5sec cast speed, we don't have buffs, we don't have heals, we don't have rezz, we do not have amnesia, we don't have cure poison/disease.in addition u get all the abilities of a bard
Yes they only get one DD that was a mistake on my part, but a battle bard is quite effective in 1 vs 1.one shitty insta dd, doesnt have chain armour and hits like a fag
This was a minstrel unique ability it was a nerf to minstrels that bards and skalds got it and to add to that speedwarp counters the speed on it, so don't moan just because it can be used against stealthers, it's designed to be that way and isn't a "i-win" button as it doesn't do any damage, it doesn't even do anything to the enemy it just gives me and my group speed. Usually used to kite, mezz or run away.u also get sos, were is this balanced from a stealthers point of view
I wouldn't moan if hunters or rangers got shield, it would mean they lose duel wield and 2handFor your argument that these classes are balanced i think you need yer head examined cuz if they made the other stealther clsses as OP as these there would be a whole world of people screaming nerf the fuckers.
tierk said:How can u seriously come out with this crap geeza. Its not well balanced at all, u get abilities from across the classes of the others realms. U get stealth so u can fight in stealth wars in addition u got a unbreakable stun like a chanters stun except yers is even more over powered as u dont have to cast jack shit just hit yer insta and hack hack hack, u get Fz another super ability, in addition u get all the abilities of a bard again though u are far more powerfull then a bard cuz, correct me if i am wrong a bard only gets one shitty insta dd, doesnt have chain armour and hits like a fag, u also get sos, were is this balanced from a stealthers point of view? As for scouts they have longer range, greater damage bow wise a anytime stun with shield as well as a freakin any time 9 sec stun not to mention the fact that the fucking shield that is the size of a match box has a 100% block rate and to top it off the majority of people that play the freakin archer class in yer realm are a bunch of yellow mofo's that are only good at running like a fucking girla and incapable of running solo (there are a few exceptions to this rule though).
For your argument that these classes are balanced i think you need yer head examined cuz if they made the other stealther clsses as OP as these there would be a whole world of people screaming nerf the fuckers.
2xinsta DD's
wutae said:WTF ... are u saying ?
My main character is my minstrel , rr9 atm .
u all said some good and bad thing about mins ,
the problem is that u didnt say one basic thing .
Or u MAY have but i cba to red
MINSTREL STEALTH : wtf is thaT ? i have atm 31 + 19 stealth ,
but it only helps for stealthed speed , and for not been seen by
fgs .. how many peeps can give us teh same theme ,
OFC u CANT GIVE MoS to a minstrel
cause then he could INSTA dd u and uncover u without letting u PA .
SO minstrels WILL never get mos . k thnx .
Minstrel GRP utility , K THNX , u removed the best thing a minstrel had .
SOS . it exists atm to all 3 realms , but it's not THAT good as it was
in OF , they just took it from albs and gave it to hibs ,
cause Hibs MUST use their CC class ( which is bard ),
while albs have the option to not use that nerfed ability . cause
it belong to the minstrel ..
ATM the only reason i get some grps . is that i am rr9 .. look around ya ,
where are all these grp minstrels u are mentioning ?
i can see only arkyi , myself ( beelzeboul ) , and sometimes riderich .
rest minstrels in server , left the game in NF , cause of the introntuction
of MoS + Nerf of SoS , or they grping lan with some infils .
YES mistrels are the ultimate DUO class .