Off-topic Mafia #9 Game Thread
- Thread starter Iceforge
- Start date
old.Tohtori
FH is my second home
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2004
- Messages
- 45,210
Would save me some sanity as i'm a 100% sure tomorrow ain't gonna be an easy choice for me 
Iceforge
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2003
- Messages
- 1,861
- Thread starter
- #423
Vote Count
Day 2
Rubric - 1 - (Morphius)
Morphius - 4 - (Rubric, Levin, Golena, Kirennia)
Old.Tohtori - 1 - (Olgaline)
Not Voted: 1 (Old.Tohtori)
IT'S A LYNCH!!!
Morphius is quickly overpowered and get a noose around his neck. It snaps loudly as he is pulled up under the town-hall roof.
The mob moves to his house and almost tears it apart, looking for evidence, finding out he is: Morphius, the mafia goon.
A great day for everybody in town, except for
who has now lost his partner in crime!
Start night 2! The one with a night action, send it to me when you are ready!! Deadline is Monday at 20.00 CET due to weekend, but would be nice if it was before that! You know who you are! Do not post or vote in thread until I announce start of day 3!
Day 2
Rubric - 1 - (Morphius)
Morphius - 4 - (Rubric, Levin, Golena, Kirennia)
Old.Tohtori - 1 - (Olgaline)
Not Voted: 1 (Old.Tohtori)
IT'S A LYNCH!!!
Morphius is quickly overpowered and get a noose around his neck. It snaps loudly as he is pulled up under the town-hall roof.
The mob moves to his house and almost tears it apart, looking for evidence, finding out he is: Morphius, the mafia goon.
A great day for everybody in town, except for
the mafia roleblocker;
who's name was:
You really think I would write that here? D'OH!
Start night 2! The one with a night action, send it to me when you are ready!! Deadline is Monday at 20.00 CET due to weekend, but would be nice if it was before that! You know who you are! Do not post or vote in thread until I announce start of day 3!
Iceforge
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2003
- Messages
- 1,861
- Thread starter
- #424
The next morning, as the towns people gathered in the town hall again, satisfied and happy about yesterday's results, they found Olgaline, the townie, shot down cold-blooded outside.
The mafia had taken some revenge for yesterdays acts, it seemed.
But who was the last member of the mafia? They had to find out...
With 5 left alive, it takes 3 to lynch
Start of Day 3! Everybody can post and vote once again!
The mafia had taken some revenge for yesterdays acts, it seemed.
But who was the last member of the mafia? They had to find out...
With 5 left alive, it takes 3 to lynch
Start of Day 3! Everybody can post and vote once again!
old.Tohtori
FH is my second home
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2004
- Messages
- 45,210
Well...since i know who i am, i also know that now i'm bloody confused. Someone of the mafia family just offed their own.
And since it's a very deviant tactic, i'm betting, that since morp voted for rubric and rubric pulled the "trigger" on morp, that it would be a total 100% guiltproof status for Rubric so...
Vote: Rubric
This is what i'd do!
And since it's a very deviant tactic, i'm betting, that since morp voted for rubric and rubric pulled the "trigger" on morp, that it would be a total 100% guiltproof status for Rubric so...
Vote: Rubric
This is what i'd do!
kirennia
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 26, 2003
- Messages
- 3,857
People have been getting the last vote or two (Rubric last, golena 2nd to last in this game) on their mafia teammates in previous villages on purpose to shift blame. I'm also not sure if Rubric, if he was a mafia member, would vote off morph after both olgaline and tohtori said point blank that they weren't going to put the last vote on him...
The tactic of last voting has been used so much I'm starting to think of it as too obvious hence:
vote
ld.Tohtori
You usually cover all bases and defend heavily when people attack you which has been apparent in this game a lot too. I think your voting has been more sporadic though and with morphius, I think you've double bluffed thinking that people will be going for someone who voted for him as a covering tactic.
I do have to say, if it were a number of other people in your situation, I wouldn't have done the same but I know just how much you form tactics during games and I can see this as the kind of thing you'd do.
The tactic of last voting has been used so much I'm starting to think of it as too obvious hence:
vote
ld.TohtoriYou usually cover all bases and defend heavily when people attack you which has been apparent in this game a lot too. I think your voting has been more sporadic though and with morphius, I think you've double bluffed thinking that people will be going for someone who voted for him as a covering tactic.
I do have to say, if it were a number of other people in your situation, I wouldn't have done the same but I know just how much you form tactics during games and I can see this as the kind of thing you'd do.
old.Tohtori
FH is my second home
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2004
- Messages
- 45,210
Well that's exactly what i said!
It's exactly what i'd do, even without Morp concent.
To hell with the rest of mafia, the only thing is, i'm not doing it.
In no way shape or form would voting Olga be good for me. But ofcourse you can argue "that's a tactic", but really, it would be so much trouble that killing someone like...say...golena would've been a lot easier.
It's exactly what i'd do, even without Morp concent.
To hell with the rest of mafia, the only thing is, i'm not doing it.
In no way shape or form would voting Olga be good for me. But ofcourse you can argue "that's a tactic", but really, it would be so much trouble that killing someone like...say...golena would've been a lot easier.
Rubric
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2003
- Messages
- 2,145
A good result at last but now i am not so sure about Golena, i was convinced he was Mafia but now I can't believe he would have left his vote on Morphius unless it was a timing issue and he stuffed up removing his vote, therefore it must be Old.Tohtori. I can't believe i was so wrong about you at the start but as always you have played a good game,
Vote: Old.Tohtori
Vote: Old.Tohtori
Levin
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 2,734
Actually.. i just started reading the thread and then I couldn't stop. I just read through it all and my eyes are bleeding.
Anyway.. guys. With the whole thread fresh in mind I think it's safe to say our mafia is either Tohtori or Golena. I would have added Olgaline to that list except he's dead now so that makes it a little easier at least.
Out of Golena and Tohtori it's really difficult. Morphius did vote on Golena on day one, but if he actually did speak truth about not understanding the rules fully, he might have just made a mistake, which later turned out to be a nice cover - albeit by accident. Also, Golena's vote on Morphius (I think it was the 2nd vote?) may well have been smoke and mirrors or even a way to get rid of his mafia buddy as Rubric was calling Morphius on defending Golena too much. True mafia behaviour... you talk too much, the family kills you. The short of it is that them voting on eachother once each throughout the game does not mean they weren't mafia buddies. Also the killing of Olgaline goes well in line with the "kill the most innocent seeming person" mafia tactic that Golena personally presented earlier. Perhaps a bit too obvious though. I don't think Golena would mention the mafia tactic like that if he was actually using it, as we saw happened both on night 1 and night 2.
Tohtori then? Well.. on day one he defended Morphius so hard it wasn't even funny. I've just read through it and once I got through towards the posts at the end of day 1, I was *this* close to just skip the rest and post a vote for Tohtori to seal the deal. Every single post he did on day one makes him seem mafia together with Morphius. And that's what makes this so hard, because one day two Golena starts acting just as suspicious. And to boot, he and Morphius defend eachother, with little comments here and there to make it seem innocent enough. The Olgaline nightkill could be a double-foolery move so as to set up an "I wouldn't be so stupid as to.." argument, just like we saw. So.. reason I doubt Tohtori's guilt is just because Golena seems even more guilty. However.. claiming that "killing Golena would have been easier" doesn't make sense, really. Golena is the number 1 candidate next to Tohtori for being mafia. Killing your cover is a bad idea, and Tohtori would know this.
I'm really 50/50 on Tohtori and Golena but I am sure one of them is our last mafia scum here in town. Whichever one of you two is the townie - you've made it really hard for the rest of us! It's good that we can afford to miss once at this stage.
So... after this little monologue while everyone is asleep... I will follow suit and vote off Tohtori, mostly based on the first and third day's words and actions. Please let this be right!
Vote: Tohtori
Anyway.. guys. With the whole thread fresh in mind I think it's safe to say our mafia is either Tohtori or Golena. I would have added Olgaline to that list except he's dead now so that makes it a little easier at least.
Out of Golena and Tohtori it's really difficult. Morphius did vote on Golena on day one, but if he actually did speak truth about not understanding the rules fully, he might have just made a mistake, which later turned out to be a nice cover - albeit by accident. Also, Golena's vote on Morphius (I think it was the 2nd vote?) may well have been smoke and mirrors or even a way to get rid of his mafia buddy as Rubric was calling Morphius on defending Golena too much. True mafia behaviour... you talk too much, the family kills you. The short of it is that them voting on eachother once each throughout the game does not mean they weren't mafia buddies. Also the killing of Olgaline goes well in line with the "kill the most innocent seeming person" mafia tactic that Golena personally presented earlier. Perhaps a bit too obvious though. I don't think Golena would mention the mafia tactic like that if he was actually using it, as we saw happened both on night 1 and night 2.
Tohtori then? Well.. on day one he defended Morphius so hard it wasn't even funny. I've just read through it and once I got through towards the posts at the end of day 1, I was *this* close to just skip the rest and post a vote for Tohtori to seal the deal. Every single post he did on day one makes him seem mafia together with Morphius. And that's what makes this so hard, because one day two Golena starts acting just as suspicious. And to boot, he and Morphius defend eachother, with little comments here and there to make it seem innocent enough. The Olgaline nightkill could be a double-foolery move so as to set up an "I wouldn't be so stupid as to.." argument, just like we saw. So.. reason I doubt Tohtori's guilt is just because Golena seems even more guilty. However.. claiming that "killing Golena would have been easier" doesn't make sense, really. Golena is the number 1 candidate next to Tohtori for being mafia. Killing your cover is a bad idea, and Tohtori would know this.
I'm really 50/50 on Tohtori and Golena but I am sure one of them is our last mafia scum here in town. Whichever one of you two is the townie - you've made it really hard for the rest of us!
It's good that we can afford to miss once at this stage.So... after this little monologue while everyone is asleep... I will follow suit and vote off Tohtori, mostly based on the first and third day's words and actions. Please let this be right!
Vote: Tohtori
Iceforge
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2003
- Messages
- 1,861
- Thread starter
- #433
Vote Count
Day 3
Rubric - 1 - (Old.Tohtori)
Old.Tohtori - 3 - (Kirennia, Rubric, Levin)
Not Voted: 1 (Golena)
IT'S A LYNCH!!!
Old.Tohtori is quickly overpowered and get a noose around his neck. It snaps loudly as he is pulled up under the town-hall roof.
The mob moves to his house and almost tears it apart, looking for evidence, finding out he is: Old.Tohtori, Regular Townie.
It was a sad day for the town! They all went home, hoping tomorrow's gathering would be more rewarding!
Start night 3! Again, the one with the nightchoise know who you are! Deadline Monday at 20.00 CET, sooner prefered. Do not post or vote in thread until I announce start of Day 4!
Day 3
Rubric - 1 - (Old.Tohtori)
Old.Tohtori - 3 - (Kirennia, Rubric, Levin)
Not Voted: 1 (Golena)
IT'S A LYNCH!!!
Old.Tohtori is quickly overpowered and get a noose around his neck. It snaps loudly as he is pulled up under the town-hall roof.
The mob moves to his house and almost tears it apart, looking for evidence, finding out he is: Old.Tohtori, Regular Townie.
It was a sad day for the town! They all went home, hoping tomorrow's gathering would be more rewarding!
Start night 3! Again, the one with the nightchoise know who you are! Deadline Monday at 20.00 CET, sooner prefered. Do not post or vote in thread until I announce start of Day 4!
Iceforge
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2003
- Messages
- 1,861
- Thread starter
- #434
The next morning, as the towns people gathered in the town hall again, satisfied and happy about yesterday's results, they found Kirennia, the townie, shot down cold-blooded outside.
Today was the last chance to catch the guilty one.
With 3 left alive, it takes 2 to lynch
Start of Day 4! The last 3 left alive can post and vote once again!
Today was the last chance to catch the guilty one.
With 3 left alive, it takes 2 to lynch
Start of Day 4! The last 3 left alive can post and vote once again!
Levin
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 2,734
Golena couldn't nightkill Rubric because Rubric has had the Morphius/Golena combo going for much of the latter part of the game. He couldn't kill me because he needs someone to blame. So.. unless Rubric has been playing one hell of a game, there's the reasoning for my vote and I'm feeling pretty confident it's the right one.
Rubric
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2003
- Messages
- 2,145
Iceforge
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2003
- Messages
- 1,861
- Thread starter
- #438
Vote count
Day 4
Golena - 2 - (Levin, Rubric)
Not Voted: 1 (Golena)
IT'S A LYNCH!!!
Quickly, Levin and Rubric overpowered Golena and stripped the noose around his neck. They pulled the rope, stinging up Golena under the town hall roof, and just as Golena's body went lifeless, Levin felt a sharp pain in his back. Turning around, he was meet with a grinning Rubric and felt his legs give in under him and the pain from the knife in his back spread through his body, everything went cold and dark. The last thing he saw and heard was Rubric laughing and looking down at him.
Golena, regular townie, lynched day 4
Levin, regular townie, end-game killed
Rubric, mafia roleblocker, winning the game for him and his partner, Morphius.
Game over!
Day 4
Golena - 2 - (Levin, Rubric)
Not Voted: 1 (Golena)
IT'S A LYNCH!!!
Quickly, Levin and Rubric overpowered Golena and stripped the noose around his neck. They pulled the rope, stinging up Golena under the town hall roof, and just as Golena's body went lifeless, Levin felt a sharp pain in his back. Turning around, he was meet with a grinning Rubric and felt his legs give in under him and the pain from the knife in his back spread through his body, everything went cold and dark. The last thing he saw and heard was Rubric laughing and looking down at him.
Golena, regular townie, lynched day 4
Levin, regular townie, end-game killed
Rubric, mafia roleblocker, winning the game for him and his partner, Morphius.
Game over!
old.Tohtori
FH is my second home
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2004
- Messages
- 45,210
Aye, nice enough play, though my hanging was stupid by all accounts. Time, quick, not even considering what i said(which was right)
Iceforge
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2003
- Messages
- 1,861
- Thread starter
- #441
Just need to say this, before someone makes any assumptions:
No, Rubric was not given more time than anybody else would have gotten for being AFK. he was send a PM which gave him 48 hours to respond. But it only took like 3 hours after I had send it before people was saying he had already had enough time, which was why I got quite anoyed at it in the end, as people somehow expected that others should be glued to the computer 24/7 or something, ready and eager to respond.
No, Rubric was not given more time than anybody else would have gotten for being AFK. he was send a PM which gave him 48 hours to respond. But it only took like 3 hours after I had send it before people was saying he had already had enough time, which was why I got quite anoyed at it in the end, as people somehow expected that others should be glued to the computer 24/7 or something, ready and eager to respond.
Rubric
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2003
- Messages
- 2,145
Spot on about the hell of a game that is.
Sorry to Morphius who didn't even know what was coming to him, i saw the opportunity and took it.
Thanks for a great game as ever Ice,
old.Tohtori
FH is my second home
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2004
- Messages
- 45,210
Shame peopel didn't listen Rubie old boy
Called the plan as was exact.
Called the plan as was exact.
After I got killed I had a hunch, after Toht got killed, I knew.
and it's so damn frustrating to watch without being able to aid.
and poor Golena, on the toht lynch he didnt even have time to get online to give an opinion I checked his last active, same went for today he was on earlier, but I'm guessing he still doesnt even know it's over.
and it's so damn frustrating to watch without being able to aid.
and poor Golena, on the toht lynch he didnt even have time to get online to give an opinion I checked his last active, same went for today he was on earlier, but I'm guessing he still doesnt even know it's over.
old.Tohtori
FH is my second home
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2004
- Messages
- 45,210
The thing i most wonder about is, did Levin just get bored of the game?
He just voted REALLY fast and without too much thinking or even giving time to answer.
Like me defending Morp, which was complete bull.
He just voted REALLY fast and without too much thinking or even giving time to answer.
Like me defending Morp, which was complete bull.
I just think curiosity got the better of him ?
and well, It did look suspeciouse, tbh I had you down for a likely mafia,
but when I got night killed, I knew with 99,8% certanty it want you,
you'd have killed of Golena and Double teamed me with Levin and I'm sure you would ahve convinced Kirennia as well, so would have been an easy kill+lynch+kill "my guess"
And levins reaction to my post preatty much confirmed to me he was innocent,
so that left me "if I hadnt been wacked" with rubric or you tbh. from my perspective
and well, It did look suspeciouse, tbh I had you down for a likely mafia,
but when I got night killed, I knew with 99,8% certanty it want you,
you'd have killed of Golena and Double teamed me with Levin and I'm sure you would ahve convinced Kirennia as well, so would have been an easy kill+lynch+kill "my guess"
And levins reaction to my post preatty much confirmed to me he was innocent,
so that left me "if I hadnt been wacked" with rubric or you tbh. from my perspective
Levin
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 2,734
I wasn't bored of the game, but at that stage all it would have come to would have been arguments going round and round. I got kind of burnt on that when Tohtori was mafia that time and I didn't vote him and he won. This time i didn't want anyone to twist my head around, so i preferred to go with gut/chance and just vote one. I realized there was a little risk Rubric was mafia, or course, but you can't take away from him that he played damn well. His strong attacks on Morphius had me fooled. He played the townie role just like I play when I'm townie (which is each and EVERY TIME so far!)
As for Tohtori and Golena. I don't know why, but your aggressiveness really made me think you were mafia. You made it really hard for me, mainly I guess, because we seem to think so differently in our townie roles. I prefer the straight forward approach and you guys use a lot more methods and tactics and double dares etc, which had me fooled more than once. I really thought at least one of you was mafia this game and I can't believe how fooled you had me.
As for Tohtori and Golena. I don't know why, but your aggressiveness really made me think you were mafia. You made it really hard for me, mainly I guess, because we seem to think so differently in our townie roles. I prefer the straight forward approach and you guys use a lot more methods and tactics and double dares etc, which had me fooled more than once. I really thought at least one of you was mafia this game and I can't believe how fooled you had me.
Iceforge
Can't get enough of FH
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2003
- Messages
- 1,861
- Thread starter
- #450
Now give dem game #10 role
We need our mafia fix.
btw IceF did you ever get my pm ?
not that i was expecting any reply, just curiouse, as the thought occurred to me it might have been lost in the masses.
What was the PM?
Quite frequently got ot delete messages in my in and out box here on FH.
might be a day or two before I get game #10 started....