Off-topic Mafia #4 game thread

[Levin]

Ah wait.. I think I missed something in Tohtori's post. Did you protect Cerb then?

 

[Levin]

Hmm (sorry about the many small posts instead of one big.. i keep thinking of things).

I forgot one scenario about English. If he is mafia he could of course be trying to point at townies, as Kirennia says. Just like he tried with Lethul too after the first night. In my opinion it would be stupid of a townie author to throw around blame.. but not as stupid for a mafia author. But then again, maybe that's too obvious.

 

[old.Tohtori]

He or some other mafia scum is an author and to me it looked like they tried to fool us. Might be a bit nobrainer but hey! Ocam's razor, among a collection of multiple posibilities, usually the most easy is the correct one

So, if we go by that logic, which is more likely?

A: I protected someone from a kill?
B: Mafia made up a fiendish plan, didn't kill anyone over the night, and then English(if he was mafia) even enforced that plan by making the story sound like that?

Yes Levin it was cerb, my post was done a bit late so incoherent a bit.

Ofcourse if Cerb was mafia, and the mafia just didn't kill anyone(to re-enforce egnlish plan), it miht just be a fluke. That's bloody likely!

But Vasc, mind telling why you didn't bold your vote? Is it a trick or a messup?

 

[Levin]

I was actually having the thought that you (Tohtori) could be mafia, have your gang not kill anyone this night, and then claim you saved someone.

But since it's Cerb, I find it highly likely that you could have figured the mafia would target him next since he's been so inactive - and thus it's actually quite believable that you successfully protected him tonight.

 

[old.Tohtori]

I was actually having the thought that you (Tohtori) could be mafia, have your gang not kill anyone this night, and then claim you saved someone.

But since it's Cerb, I find it highly likely that you could have figured the mafia would target him next since he's been so inactive - and thus it's actually quite believable that you successfully protected him tonight.

Well it was a coin-toss really, to protect myself or one of the less active ones.

Cerb was the only inactive one i could think of, as everyone else is either a "town suspect", as in, mafia will let us hang eachother, and i still think Lethul is evil, even if Rubric wasn't. So, tonight it worked like any other night. Couldn't mention protecting cerb before, 'cause that would've just put the mafia in a rather dangerous "random" mode, as in, kill one of the active ones.

Heck, something wrong with him!

 

[Vasconcelos]

Oh and Vasc, if you want to vote for me I think you have to put it in bold, otherwise it won't count.

Ah well, nothing personal here bud

Is just that i have this feeling. Think i missed the part where english claimed to be the author, but my suspicion about the author being mafia and making up the story around you to make you look less suspicious stands. And now u say it, if english is the author that only reasures me in my thought that he is a mafia too.

If it didnt count:

VOTE: LEVIN

 

[Levin]

So left now is...

Calo
Cerb
English
Kirennia
Lethul
Levin
Olgaline
Tohtori
Vasconcelos

If Tohtori speaks truth about being a doctor, we have him and Cerb as innocents. I know I'm a townie, so in my eyes that leaves six people.

Calo
English
Kirennia
Lethul
Olgaline
Vasconcelos

Two or three of these are mafia.

English and Vasconcelos were awfully quick to jump on the author's (English himself) message after the night had passed. Very odd to be honest. Vasc voted on me with unbold letters (which I pointed out to him in a post as soon as I saw it) but I think that was just a mistake. It probably means nothing. Still these two are probably highest on my list.

Calo and Lethul are staying moderately active.. quite average really. Nothing about them sticks out, other than English's mention of Lethul in his night 1 story.

Kirennia and Olgaline are two relatively active, analyzing people. Kirennia is gunning for English. Olgaline has... probably not got a single vote against him so far in the game? Interesting.

It's really hard to determine anything out of this. I wish we had a cop who could shed some light here, but... ah well. Does anyone else have any insights?

 

[Levin]

Think i missed the part where english claimed to be the author, but my suspicion about the author being mafia and making up the story around you to make you look less suspicious stands. And now u say it, if english is the author that only reasures me in my thought that he is a mafia too.

So let me get this straight. You think English and I are mafia because he mentions me in an author story which has absolutely no impact on things?

Okay, that sounds... very random, just like I remember you acting on the first day.

So English if I may ask you- why DID you mention me in your story tonight?

 

[- English -]

believe me or not, iceforge wrote the storyline tonight lol....

 

[- English -]

the question i want to know is who is the COP, its about time he did some work

 

[Levin]

believe me or not, iceforge wrote the storyline tonight lol....

Ookay! Is there any way for us to control that? It would kind of seem strange that the mod would single out someone like that, even if it's just an innocent passage about sleeping in.

 

[old.Tohtori]

I've always thought of the "interludes" as fluff, and not let them affect by decisions.

Though i am a bit wondering why English didn't write it, if he is the author.

Not trying to fingerpointpaint here, just asking.

 

[- English -]

Ookay! Is there any way for us to control that? It would kind of seem strange that the mod would single out someone like that, even if it's just an innocent passage about sleeping in.

I could show pms but its against the spirit of the game imo. I dont think the author has much power anyway and when I asked Iceforge whats the point in an author at the start of the game, he said it was just for roleplaying really. It doesn't have any real power.

 

[- English -]

I've always thought of the "interludes" as fluff, and not let them affect by decisions.

Though i am a bit wondering why English didn't write it, if he is the author.

Not trying to fingerpointpaint here, just asking.

Ill answer this fairly. It was about 6;30 and i noticed I had a pm from iceforge for the dawn scene. As i was on my way out to view a house i just asked him to do it as i wouldnt be back till late.

hope its not breaking the rules me saying this :]

 

[Levin]

I could show pms but its against the spirit of the game imo. I dont think the author has much power anyway and when I asked Iceforge whats the point in an author at the start of the game, he said it was just for roleplaying really. It doesn't have any real power.

Thank you for saying it yourself. I rest my case on this one. I'll tell you one effect it had though... it gave me the shits when I thought I had been murdered, until I opened the spoiler button!

 

[- English -]

Thank you for saying it yourself. I rest my case on this one. I'll tell you one effect it had though... it gave me the shits when I thought I had been murdered, until I opened the spoiler button!

lol, i'd have been scared if the mafia hit their own member

 

[old.Tohtori]

Ill answer this fairly. It was about 6;30 and i noticed I had a pm from iceforge for the dawn scene. As i was on my way out to view a house i just asked him to do it as i wouldnt be back till late.

hope its not breaking the rules me saying this :]

Don't think so, even if it's a bit of OOC-gaming. But this all has been really.

Would be interesting to play this game with a STRICT roleplay rule sometime.

Anyhoo, fair enough.

Unless you're lying, in which case i shake my finger at you like so..*fingershaking*

 

[- English -]

Don't think so, even if it's a bit of OOC-gaming. But this all has been really.

Would be interesting to play this game with a STRICT roleplay rule sometime.

Anyhoo, fair enough.

Unless you're lying, in which case i shake my finger at you like so..*fingershaking*

Iceforge may read and respond to prove this. Will just have to wait and see.

 

[Levin]

lol, i'd have been scared if the mafia hit their own member

Really? Because then you yourself could have been hit? I would have been happy, not scared, if the mafia had hit one of their own members.

 

[- English -]

What im worried is that tehre are no signs of a townie cop :/

 

[Levin]

There probably isn't one then.. they would have spoken up by now.

 

[old.Tohtori]

There probably isn't one then.. they would have spoken up by now.

That's true. Or provide some serious nudging towards some people if not come out of the closet.

Shame really, would help alot to know atleast something.

 

[Calo]

There must be other town roles then just a doc and an author..

Don't think there are 5-6 vanilla townies..

 

[Levin]

Did we ever find out what the superpowered useless townie-person could do? Cause apparently we might have one among us.

 

[Vasconcelos]

So, if we go by that logic, which is more likely?

A: I protected someone from a kill?
B: Mafia made up a fiendish plan, didn't kill anyone over the night, and then English(if he was mafia) even enforced that plan by making the story sound like that?

Yes Levin it was cerb, my post was done a bit late so incoherent a bit.

Ofcourse if Cerb was mafia, and the mafia just didn't kill anyone(to re-enforce egnlish plan), it miht just be a fluke. That's bloody likely!

But Vasc, mind telling why you didn't bold your vote? Is it a trick or a messup?

Heh, dont be so jumpy, i forgot to put and didnt realize till Levin pointed that to me, couldnt edit (and must not) so i reposted.

And about the logic. It may be both of the options. They couldnt kill the protected victim and also made up the story. Or they just tried to kill you but you protected yourself, would be nice to know who the doc was protecting. Might be useful to interfere de mafia plan...

 

[Vasconcelos]

Ill answer this fairly. It was about 6;30 and i noticed I had a pm from iceforge for the dawn scene. As i was on my way out to view a house i just asked him to do it as i wouldnt be back till late.

hope its not breaking the rules me saying this :]

Then, i apologize and assume that my previous logic isnt valid anymore, thus

UNVOTE: LEVIN

for now

Sowy for the post secuence, but had to catch up with morning posts and im replying as i read

 

[old.Tohtori]

And about the logic. It may be both of the options. They couldnt kill the protected victim and also made up the story. Or they just tried to kill you but you protected yourself, would be nice to know who the doc was protecting. Might be useful to interfere de mafia plan...

that's quite a loose theory. That everything happened that is. Especially if you go by Occam's razor logic.

Anyhoo, regarding who was protected(past tense), is up there(cerb). Regarding who will be protected, is gonna be kept quiet. Well, would be silly otherwise.

 

[Vasconcelos]

that's quite a loose theory. That everything happened that is. Especially if you go by Occam's razor logic.

Anyhoo, regarding who was protected(past tense), is up there(cerb). Regarding who will be protected, is gonna be kept quiet. Well, would be silly otherwise.

Read my last post

 

[old.Tohtori]

Read my last post

Multithreading for the loose,forgot i posted this and when i did, you had that.

Blahrg.

Anyway! I'm guessing we should vote for someone. And seems this town is hanging english or levin? Again, asking.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Heh, one vote for english and the rest of the town is either A: drunk off their assets, trying to numb the pain if they happen to get hung or B: Hungover off their assets 'cause they thought they need numbing for last night.