Hold on. So we gll agree silencing doesn't not eliminate anyone from making a night action? We have no proof it doesn't. By agreeing who should be silenced in advance we prove nothing. If you volunteer to be silenced then stay quiet the next day what does that prove?
That would asume that it's conspiricy between two parties.
thus why if said target for silencing doesnt get to pick the silencer all that would proove is if the silenced party stayed silencet or not.
in this case it would not proove my guilt or innocence, but only that of the silencer, if I do not get to choose who then what do I stand to gain?