Werewolf Experiment Game Evolved - Game thread

[Ch3tan]

Read up, I have been honest. Unlike lots of people here.

I do not like flawed arguments, and there are lots of them being made by those who would force a no-vote.

 

[Will]

I've said it already. Pure logic states that you should just vote for whoever you chose last night. Or else you are agreeing to be burnt to a crisp.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Votes stand at:

Ch3tan(4): Will, RandomBastard, itcheh, chetan
Novote(4): Kirennia, aph3x, uara, mabs
Will(1): Calaen

6 to choose, 2 unvoted

 

[Ch3tan]

phazey and tab have the swing votes.

 

[Calaen]

It looks like I am gonna get fried anyway so I might as well vote wrong.

unvote will

vote novote

 

[Ch3tan]

So you would condemn Will and I, but save Kir and others? Interesting.

 

[kirennia]

Thats fine no offence taken, well maybe a little as your happy to see my die but neh

My no vote stands as it is, not happy to kill someone off just to see what tommorow brings.

Wasn't that I was happy to see you die, just that with that line of thinking, I thought you might be more likely to be put upto the chopping block. Subtle difference

So you would condemn Will and I, but save Kir and others? Interesting.

I have taken note that one person might still be down as no lynch as reading back, Tohtori started the game and said he'd make a judgement call on one person, whether their late vote counts or not (unless anyone actually voted like that in the first place)... therefore it's logical to assume that someone in the list of no-voters may well be a no voter.

As said however, I'm not one of those people and I agree, we don't even know that the person we vote for will in fact die. What you will however see tomorrow if this goes for a no vote, is that if done publically, you'll see I was telling the truth and we'll also potentially see who the no voter who voted for no vote was (if their choice didn't change... and if that made any sense).

The way I'm seeing this at the moment is that those who voted for a particular person shouldn't necessarily be rewarded for driving the bandwagon. I think that by uncovering what this game is about early on with us all in the same boat is the best way to see exactly what Tohtori has planned for us all.

If the person voted for isnt going to die then it wont matter if it's a no vote or a vote on them... nothing lost.

If the person voted for IS going to die, we're down a person before even knowing what the game entails.

Alternatively, there could be a hidden bad guy and then there's roughly an 8% chance that you get the right person from the word go... which pretty much doesn't happen in mafia/werewolf games and especially not in Tohtoris games.


I'll tell you what, join my vote and if whatever happens to those wrong doesn't happen to me also, vote for me and get it over with the following day. Just to make doubly sure that I wasn't lying, in the event of this being a concealed thing where we're all PMed instead of publically in the same boat, don't write anything, I'll tell you what Tohtori said (not quoting, just what happened to me that night), then you can check on the feasibility of my answer.

All bases covered to prove innocence? Check...

 

[Ch3tan]

Well no, because as Will has said, it would be suicide for me to join your vote. And give you very little risk of me being around tomorrow to call you on your deal.

 

[kirennia]

Well no, because as Will has said, it would be suicide for me to join your vote. And give you very little risk of me being around tomorrow to call you on your deal.

It wasn't a post aimed at you, it's aimed at everyone (although it was posted because of you ). As someone who started this 'bandwagon', I guess it's more upto me then the others who joined it to show my motives, which are just. I severely doubt Tohtoris going to kill off everyone who got it wrong as that'd lead to a very short/boring game... hence why I'm not too worried about voting against what his game outline suggested at this early stage.

 

[RandomBastard]

Well I whispered ch3tans name into this little microphone, and so my vote for him stands in order to save my own skin, but what I can't understand is did all you novotes really not vote for anyone? Seems rather too altruistic to be true.

 

[Aph3x]

Ok Ch3tster I see your point, have re read the rules and the people we vote for are cast out, now looking at tied in with the fact we are all strapped to beds next to a crispy guy would suggest the people we vote for are saved, would it not ?

Unvote No Vote

Any thoughts on that ?

 

[kirennia]

Ok Ch3tster I see your point, have re read the rules and the people we vote for are cast out, now looking at tied in with the fact we are all strapped to beds next to a crispy guy would suggest the people we vote for are saved, would it not ?

Unvote No Vote

Any thoughts on that ?

The person who gets voted off does not necessarily die.

That's a very good point...I didn't notice this originally

unvote: no vote

In fact, maybe it'd be a good idea that before the final vote is cast on anyone, we first decide who we ALL should vote for for the following day to save everyone... if indeed that turns out to be the case. Of course if it turns out they die, then that second nominee will end up being killed as a result so 50/50 for them.

So any takers? Might be an idea to have choice 1 and choice 2 just in case choice 1 dies at the end of this bit... I don't mind doing it

 

[Calaen]

Well I voted for Will privately and am willing to vote no vote to see what happens if the person that is voted does not die then there is no harm in voting no vote surely?

 

[kirennia]

Well I voted for Will privately and am willing to vote no vote to see what happens if the person that is voted does not die then there is no harm in voting no vote surely?

I'm on the fence at the moment. Part of me wants to know what happens if someone gets voted for now; I'd initially assumed it was more then likely going to be that they'd be killed but noticing that comment, it's skewed my view on the whole thing. Voting for a no vote wont uncover that part of the game so will keep us in the dark until day 2, by which time, with us not knowing who is going to be killed as a result of not voting for the correct person at night, might lose us a lot of people.

As I say, I'm on the fence and I'm not sure which way to go now.

 

[taB]

Been away for a few days. I know I need to vote. Will get myself confused reading through this tomorrow and make a satisfyingly uninformed decision.

 

[Ch3tan]

Well I voted for Will privately and am willing to vote no vote to see what happens if the person that is voted does not die then there is no harm in voting no vote surely?

There is harm. We do not know what will happen, but we know something will happen to those that guessed the wrong way. Now if you are all really doing what is best for the group, then we will all vote for the person who most people guessed for last night. That way more of us survive/ do not have a bad thing happen, than would otherwise be the case.

So far 4 people have voted for me, myself included. Is there anyone with more guesses against their name? If there is then fair doo's, vote for them, but otherwise it makes no sense to vote a no-vote or a person with less guesses against their name -unless of course you are trying to kill us off (or whatever the punishment is)?

 

[Aph3x]

Ok I will fly that flag. My vote was for Will as stated earlier, I will put my vote back on Will so its clearer when counting votes.

Vote Will

 

[taB]

I'm happy not helping anyone for the moment and that includes the novote crew

vote : RandomBastard

 

[Uara]

Ok i've read through the comments and what people have said does make a lot of sense, Its unclear exactly what happens when the evening comes along and what happens to the people who get it wrong etc so I think we need to kno! so I'll change to who i whispered to our evil controller.
Unvote:No-one
Vote Will

 

[old.Tohtori]

"You people are giving me a headache..."

Votes stand at:

Ch3tan(4): Will, RandomBastard, itcheh, ch3tan
Novote(2): mabs, calaen
Will(2): aph3x, uara.
RandomBastard(1) taB

6 to choose, 2 unvoted

 

[Ch3tan]

Just to clarify guys, if everyone votes for who they guessed last night, we can see who the majority voted for. Then as a group we can decide if we are going to go against the grain, or try and save the majority.

 

[Ch3tan]

Ch3tan
Calaen
Uara
RandomBastard
Mabs
Will
Kirennia
Aph3x
taB
phazey
itcheh

So we are waiting on phazey, kir is active.

mod can you give phazey a punt?

I am going to assume phazey was the one who did not whisper his vote at the start, and therefore he has been auto voted novote.

 

[old.Tohtori]

(Phazey has been punted)

 

[Aph3x]

Yep thats the plan Ch3t, Looks like you will be the one to be voted first matey.

 

[kirennia]

Just to clarify guys, if everyone votes for who they guessed last night, we can see who the majority voted for. Then as a group we can decide if we are going to go against the grain, or try and save the majority.

Okay.

vote : Aph3x

I still don't think he's going to kill off the majority of us... there's going to be a twist, maybe roles will be given out tonight or something but I just can't see Tohtori killing off 6+ of us in one day.

 

[Mabs]

unvote novote
vote calaen

 

[Ch3tan]

lol, no shock there for those of us that follow these games mabs

 

[Aph3x]

So we have all now voted yeah ?

Count looks like 4 Ch3tan, 2 Will, 1 Caelen, 1 Random Bastard and 1 no vote.

With only Calaen (why do i struggle with this fricken name) left to vote.

 

[Mabs]

lol, no shock there for those of us that follow these games mabs

old habits die hard

 

[Calaen]

lol Mabs, I expected more tbh

unvote Will

Vote Calaen