Would this be cool or what. or not

[[PS]Fool]

Well, i have had many charachters on all realms in my few months playing, but i think i am gonna stay in good old hib. i have had an idea for sometime now, and maby it would suck (if it would please tell me why ). basicly i would like to make a guild of alts, or mains, that are all heros/champs specd in sheild with a few druids/ wardens. the idea is to create a sorta standard organized infantary for hib in RvR, that would go around in groups of 8, all with guard on each other, and hopefully others in RvR would follow and we would have a chance in RvR. i dunno maby this has been done b4, but it could rock, but then it could suck . if intersted post here, and once we got 8 i'll make the guild.

 

[Perplexed]

not

 

[[PS]Fool]

ah, why tho, i would kinda like to know

 

[old.Tzeentch]

Because there is no new players in the game (highly likely speculation), everyone you see, is probably an alt of another high level character.

So, you will have the same problems everyone else has.

Everyone wants to do their own thing, me me me me me.

 

[[PS]Fool]

Kinda why i said guild of alts....

 

[Perplexed]

A group of tanks in RvR stands no chance I'm afraid, not even with a few druids and wardens. RvR is all stuns, mezzes and nukes. U would basically be AoE mezzed and killed in seconds by any cleric/sorc/whatever who knows what he's doing ;(

What I'd really love to see tho, is organised tank-duels, say a group of 8 from each realm squaring off. No mezzing, healing, nuking or whatever, just 8v8v8 tank wars, would rock

 

[-Lillo-]

why would anyone want 2 different guilds? I mean, most people are happy with their guild and have their alts join the same guild.

and why would they join a limited guild where not all classes and only 1 support class (druid, 2 if you count warden) is allowed?

If those 8 tanks join an existing guild and play RvR there will be just as much tanks as there would be with such a tank only guild.
so whats the point??

I'm not saying it's a bad idea, I'm just saying that you will have a hard time finding people who are interested.
(and I also dont think you would stick to your tank, druid and warden only motto for a long time. You will soon see you need other classes...)