Werezomwolfbie Game thread #10
- Thread starter Mabs
- Start date
itcheh
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 740
Hold your horses ... by Syd's reckoning pipes could be interpreted as anything:
If the Hypnotist role was real (and it does explain a few things) ... then we still have a murderer around.
Nate, please tell us who the new 'innocent' is.
- Plumber (Mabs)
- Pied Piper (Sydrik)
- Cousin of Billy Piper
- A fan of Piper aircraft
If the Hypnotist role was real (and it does explain a few things) ... then we still have a murderer around.
Nate, please tell us who the new 'innocent' is.
Sydrik
Resident Freddy
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2004
- Messages
- 1,093
Well we have a better chance if Nate lets us know who is the other innocent. He can speak for himself as a seer, toht and I were under Cals influence as villagers, so unless Nate seered me last night he can give us one more innocent.
At the moment its between Olga, Itcheh, Gmloki and Uara.
Itcheh you do seem completely intent on disproving everything Nate says.
I think Nate owns up on who else he knows is innocent and we listen to the last 3 or 4 then make a choice.
At the moment its between Olga, Itcheh, Gmloki and Uara.
Itcheh you do seem completely intent on disproving everything Nate says.
I think Nate owns up on who else he knows is innocent and we listen to the last 3 or 4 then make a choice.
itcheh
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 740
I'm not trying to disprove anything - I'm keeping an open mind until the evidence tells me otherwise. Now that I have confirmation of the 'pipes' I am happy to accept that Nate is telling the truth.
However, I'll repeat that there needs to be a review of Toht's posts. Clearly the murderer feared Toht and what he was saying MORE than the possibility of a seer finding him out. That is very interesting IMHO.
However, I'll repeat that there needs to be a review of Toht's posts. Clearly the murderer feared Toht and what he was saying MORE than the possibility of a seer finding him out. That is very interesting IMHO.
itcheh
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 740
Dead / Missing
- Mabs
- Ch3tan (murder night #2)
- Calaen (public hanging day #3)
- Tohtori (murder night #3)
- nate (gypsy / seer)
- itcheh
- sydrik
- uara
- gmloki
- olgaline
Sydrik
Resident Freddy
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2004
- Messages
- 1,093
Ch3t pointed the finger at two main people, Itcheh for being a douche and Gmloki for defensive voting, and is now dead.
IF we have a blocker I'd suggest myself or Nate tonight as it seems to be the most logical death choice for the bad guy/s.
I can sort of see the reasons for Olga's vote on Nate earlier but he changed when I confirmed his story. In my eyes that leaves Uara, Gmloki and Itcheh.
IF we have a blocker I'd suggest myself or Nate tonight as it seems to be the most logical death choice for the bad guy/s.
I can sort of see the reasons for Olga's vote on Nate earlier but he changed when I confirmed his story. In my eyes that leaves Uara, Gmloki and Itcheh.
itcheh
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 740
Would it be fair to assume that we don't have a 'blocker' but a 'protector' in our midst (hence no murders on night one)?
If, however, we DO have a blocker ... and they are still alive ... it might be a good idea now for them to step forward and tell us who they blocked on night 1.
If, however, we DO have a blocker ... and they are still alive ... it might be a good idea now for them to step forward and tell us who they blocked on night 1.
itcheh
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 740
A murder was blocked on night 1, so the murderer is in a bit of a tight spot because he now knows there's was a seer who could find him out AND a protector who could keep the seer alive.
Therefore the protector is more dangerous to the murderer than the seer ... and I predict that's why Toht died last night. I also think that Toht had some insight as to what was going on and needed to be silenced.
The murderer and the hypnotist are not necessarily working together, so it might be reasonable to conclude that we've destroyed one axis of evil in the village. So removing the Cal related postings I noticed a few things:
So, in my opinion, it's down to Gmloki and Olga ... I welcome thoughts from the rest of the village.
Therefore the protector is more dangerous to the murderer than the seer ... and I predict that's why Toht died last night. I also think that Toht had some insight as to what was going on and needed to be silenced.
The murderer and the hypnotist are not necessarily working together, so it might be reasonable to conclude that we've destroyed one axis of evil in the village. So removing the Cal related postings I noticed a few things:
- Toht (while under the influence of Cal) implied heavily that Gmloki and Olga are guilty (also stated that he believed Sydrik and I were innocent)
- Gmloki has kept a VERY low profile, only posting 4 messages ... 2 of which were votes out of the blue with very little explanation
- Olga has been contributing but the commentary has been vague ... creating enough visibility to hide in plain sight, without really contributing to the conversation
So, in my opinion, it's down to Gmloki and Olga ... I welcome thoughts from the rest of the village.
uhm....
Any and all of your reasons for voting for me could be just as well be argued against you Itcheh.
Also, I've put my neck out a couple of times since the start, so vague ? Really!??
I went head on saying I wouldnt be bulliled into a vote when people were lining up to lynch "who was it?" ah right, YOU!
I could have placed the final vote on you, I but didnt, hmmm.....
I went head on against Nate when it seemed that he wanted us to go and kill a plumber...
Yes I can see how that would be vague,
Also why would you rule out Uara ? what has he contributed or did you conviniently forget him for some reason?
To me it's between Gmloki, Ithceh and Uara.
Any and all of your reasons for voting for me could be just as well be argued against you Itcheh.
Also, I've put my neck out a couple of times since the start, so vague ? Really!??
I went head on saying I wouldnt be bulliled into a vote when people were lining up to lynch "who was it?" ah right, YOU!
I could have placed the final vote on you, I but didnt, hmmm.....
I went head on against Nate when it seemed that he wanted us to go and kill a plumber...
Yes I can see how that would be vague,
Also why would you rule out Uara ? what has he contributed or did you conviniently forget him for some reason?
To me it's between Gmloki, Ithceh and Uara.
Sydrik
Resident Freddy
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2004
- Messages
- 1,093
Vote: Itcheh
Suspected by Ch3t - now dead.
Has tried to waste time since the beginning by acting a douche
If he is guilty then Uara is his partner.
If I'm wrong then we should probably look at Olga and Gmloki tomorrow and if Im right we kill Uara.
Suspected by Ch3t - now dead.
Has tried to waste time since the beginning by acting a douche
If he is guilty then Uara is his partner.
If I'm wrong then we should probably look at Olga and Gmloki tomorrow and if Im right we kill Uara.
itcheh
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 740
Oh, and for the record, the only reason I didn't mention Uara in my analysis was because I didn't see anything suspicious.
That's not in any way an endorsement of his innocence - I just wanted to see what others thought of my review of the evidence.
Nice to see Syd diving in with the votes again without reviewing the evidence.
Ch3t only disliked me because I found his fruit and veg nonsense a threat.
I actually haven't wasted any time at all ... unless you mean initially choosing NOT to vote BECAUSE THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE.
That's not in any way an endorsement of his innocence - I just wanted to see what others thought of my review of the evidence.
Nice to see Syd diving in with the votes again without reviewing the evidence.
Ch3t only disliked me because I found his fruit and veg nonsense a threat.
I actually haven't wasted any time at all ... unless you mean initially choosing NOT to vote BECAUSE THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE.
gmloki
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2003
- Messages
- 634
Well I could go into detail, A LOT OF Detail but what's the point. The knives, or should that be pitchforks and stakes are out with Itcheh acting as our Kangaroo court in damning my good name and Olga to boot. I believe that Olga is in on the act but the absence of evidence often leads to the absence of proof
itcheh
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2003
- Messages
- 740
Nice to see you slither out from the shadows Gmloki ...
Well, my post was designed to highlight some of my observations and provoke some debate ... and yet despite being mostly absent for the past 4 days, you can't be bothered to give any commentary?
Well, my post was designed to highlight some of my observations and provoke some debate ... and yet despite being mostly absent for the past 4 days, you can't be bothered to give any commentary?
Uara
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2004
- Messages
- 2,254
Right so the whole Nate situation is cleared up and so we can safely say Syd is indeed one of the good guys (unless he can mask his real nature to gypsy magic).
So-Nate and Syd are definitely good guys (out of who is left alive). I would theorise that there would only be 1 murderer out there-2 murderers and a hypnotist pan piper in a village of 9 of us is sure slightly too high for good working conditions. (however it is slightly possible the bad guy has a partner).
That means that the killer is out of Me,Olga,Itcheh and gmloki. If there is only 1 murderer then getting a wrong decision today is not the end of the world- 4v1 (if block/protected during night) or 3v1 if Murderer gets a kill in. I would say that Nate be protected if possible. It would leave us open to be murdered but it gives the village the greater chance of survival as the more chances we get to scry who the murderer is the better.
With regard to Tohts post Itcheh-are we to assume that he knew they were guilty because there is no evidence that toht was anything special. Maybe his hypnotised act was to implicate a couple of people. We won't know as he's dead now but I think we would have to take anything toht said very carefully as we don't know how much has been fabricated.
Looking at the rest of us: I can scream i'm innocent till im blue in the face but if I was any of you I wouldn't trust that comment until it has been backed up by either my death or scrying. So yeah I am innocent (villager) but still I'm not offended by being considered to be a murderer.
Itcheh-now gut instinct says he's not bad, he's been quite vocal when it's drawn a large amount of attention down on him which I'm sure a murderer would not want to do. He also although questioned the Nate scry wasn't overly aggressive towards him and instead wanted to rely on evidence which is always a plus in my books.
Gmloki-I honestly don't know. 5 posts. 2 votes. Itcheh as kangaroo court...not really, it's no show trial here, everyone else here aren't falling over each other to string you up so I don't think you need to get so defensive about that accusation. Everyone comes under the spotlight now and then, you just have to deal with it.
Olga-Has been contributing and has gone up against the Nate decision as well but a bit more aggressively (before it was cleared up that Cal was a bad guy). Could well have been hoping for a quick lynch against Nate with everyone else joining in so that he could have got rid of the seer. Of course once that was cleared up had to de-vote.
So-Nate and Syd are definitely good guys (out of who is left alive). I would theorise that there would only be 1 murderer out there-2 murderers and a hypnotist pan piper in a village of 9 of us is sure slightly too high for good working conditions. (however it is slightly possible the bad guy has a partner).
That means that the killer is out of Me,Olga,Itcheh and gmloki. If there is only 1 murderer then getting a wrong decision today is not the end of the world- 4v1 (if block/protected during night) or 3v1 if Murderer gets a kill in. I would say that Nate be protected if possible. It would leave us open to be murdered but it gives the village the greater chance of survival as the more chances we get to scry who the murderer is the better.
With regard to Tohts post Itcheh-are we to assume that he knew they were guilty because there is no evidence that toht was anything special. Maybe his hypnotised act was to implicate a couple of people. We won't know as he's dead now but I think we would have to take anything toht said very carefully as we don't know how much has been fabricated.
Looking at the rest of us: I can scream i'm innocent till im blue in the face but if I was any of you I wouldn't trust that comment until it has been backed up by either my death or scrying. So yeah I am innocent (villager) but still I'm not offended by being considered to be a murderer.
Itcheh-now gut instinct says he's not bad, he's been quite vocal when it's drawn a large amount of attention down on him which I'm sure a murderer would not want to do. He also although questioned the Nate scry wasn't overly aggressive towards him and instead wanted to rely on evidence which is always a plus in my books.
Gmloki-I honestly don't know. 5 posts. 2 votes. Itcheh as kangaroo court...not really, it's no show trial here, everyone else here aren't falling over each other to string you up so I don't think you need to get so defensive about that accusation. Everyone comes under the spotlight now and then, you just have to deal with it.
Olga-Has been contributing and has gone up against the Nate decision as well but a bit more aggressively (before it was cleared up that Cal was a bad guy). Could well have been hoping for a quick lynch against Nate with everyone else joining in so that he could have got rid of the seer. Of course once that was cleared up had to de-vote.
Sydrik
Resident Freddy
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2004
- Messages
- 1,093
I'd back that claim up or you might find yourself suspended
gmloki
Part of the furniture
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2003
- Messages
- 634
Unvote Calean
Well step out of the shadows I will indeed. Being in the dark let's you think about things, consider things. Who's the killer amongst us, me ??? No. Itcheh ??? Possibly but I think the man speaks to much sense to be such a calculated cold blooded killer. Same with Uara. My conclusion is that Olga has to be our prime suspect. He has done a very great job of trying to steer opinion and split the group. Divide and you will conquer. He has been saying enough just to dampen suspicion but not enough to tighten the noose around his neck. I am sure that the splinters on his arse must be painful from all the time sat on the fence. If you offend nobody then how can you become a suspect. A very cold and calculating way to whittle the group down. The sooner we see through this masquerade, the quicker we become safe.
Vote Olga
Well step out of the shadows I will indeed. Being in the dark let's you think about things, consider things. Who's the killer amongst us, me ??? No. Itcheh ??? Possibly but I think the man speaks to much sense to be such a calculated cold blooded killer. Same with Uara. My conclusion is that Olga has to be our prime suspect. He has done a very great job of trying to steer opinion and split the group. Divide and you will conquer. He has been saying enough just to dampen suspicion but not enough to tighten the noose around his neck. I am sure that the splinters on his arse must be painful from all the time sat on the fence. If you offend nobody then how can you become a suspect. A very cold and calculating way to whittle the group down. The sooner we see through this masquerade, the quicker we become safe.
Vote Olga