Werewolf #9

[Ch3tan]

As for my vote? It is vital the serial killer is taken out, they have the ability to win this for the wolves assuming we have a large pack. Tonight could be the last night if this is the case.

I have two suspects tab and damini. (sorry)

vote tab

 

[taB]

You sod

I might have missed it but did Itcheh give out any info from night one?

 

[Ch3tan]

day 2, so he would have had one crystal ball session.

I'm not convinced Gohan is a wolf - it would be too obvious to kill ECA just because he voted for him to be lynched.

ECA was suspicious of Gunner ... which is a little bit more believable to me

Vote: Gunner

Still not sure what tAB was doing in my house growling last night though

I wouldn't worry Damini ... although you are usually an easy target for a good lynching, I think there are more worthy suspects at this time.

You sod

I might have missed it but did Itcheh give out any info from night one?

And that is ALL he said after random died. He only named one person, so if you are working on the assumption that he got a positive scrying, then gunner is the wolf. However he wasn't really calling for his blood, he was largely absent from the discussion.

 

[Ch3tan]

Fucksticks. I am suspicous of dams and tab, but I realised that what I am reading from their posts could also mean one of them is the doctor. If I get tab burned and he's been protecting me then I am screwed.

unvote tab

I need to read this again.

 

[Damini]

Much as I'd love to say I'm the doctor, and get myself an asbestos coating, I'm not Sorry.

I'm kind of hoping that the fact Itcheh said that he doesn't think I'm the wolf was his way of saying I'm innocent and that he scried me, without having to reveal he was a seer. But maybe it just means he didn't suspect me enough to spy on me.

 

[Ch3tan]

Well he only had time for one scrying, so he either saw that you or gohan were innocent or that gunner was a wolf. That is all you can conclude from his single post on the topic.

 

[Damini]

Well, I'm going to go for Mystic G. Two reasons - one, he's been baying for my blood, and since I know I'm innocent that makes him suspicious to me. Secondly, because Ch3tan is still alive. Ch3tan never survives a night, and Meg is usually the one shouting loudest for him to die, so if I was Meg, and I was a wolf, the last person I'd attack would be Ch3tan. If that makes sense

vote: Mystic G

 

[Ch3tan]

I don't know, meg defended jup. And I think baying for your blood is something to do with those tv rights...

 

[Damini]

Damini - villager (if you believe me)
Ch3tan - seer
Mabs - innocent (according to Ch3tan)

MYstIC G
gunner440
Jimmy
taB
Calaen
Billargh
inactionman
Fweddy

One doctor (hopefully), two wolves (assumedly) and one serial killer... possibly a vigilante, possible a nurse... Eight left, three evil, five good, odds not in our favour if we just pick someone out at random, as you're more likely to pick a villager than a killer.

Hrm... may change my vote again.

 

[Calaen]

Well I am just a plain old villager.

 

[MYstIC G]

I could have told you that Mabs isn't a wolf, fs.

 

[MYstIC G]

PS: Jup knew how to do special handshakes.

PPS: Damini = wolf!

 

[inactionman]

I have no clue who the wolves are, my normal technique of finding wolves involves detective work to find the rest once the first one is found.

Although I think the chances of a random person being a bad guy are a bit better than damini says, as I think the wolves are one of the larger packs, just 2 in this game wouldn't make sense from a balance point of view.

 

[Damini]

But then if it was a larger pack, then surely they would include a role blocker, and then Ch3tan wouldn't be able to seer.

 

[inactionman]

No idea, but the difference from the last game is there's one more person total, and a serial killer. So maybe Will did that instead.

 

[Ch3tan]

But then if it was a larger pack, then surely they would include a role blocker, and then Ch3tan wouldn't be able to seer.

I think will has confused the fuck out of all of us with the roles and unstated roles. We are all tense as hell because we do not really know what the make up of the village is.

I think the fact that I have been able to scry rules out a roleblocker, or maybe they have simply been blocking someone else?


We do not have two packs, unless they have both been really unlucky and targeted the same person each night, and the game is too big for one small pack.

 

[taB]

I think Damini would be a lot more skittish and uncertain if she was a villager. She seems to have an agenda, what it is though I am unsure. However I think a decision needs to be made even if I change it later (It's going to be a long day at work methinks).

vote: Damini

For some reason I'm also very suspicious of Ch3t but tbh I can't find a gap in his logic yet so will have to stick it to the back of my mind and put it down to genetic memory

I'd be tempted to agree that we're in single pack territory unless they've either doubled up on a kill or been blocked each time - possible yet unlikely.

Oh, and whoever the doc is (if there is one) keep yer head low and keep up the good work

 

[Damini]

Gah. I'm NOT a wolf.

 

[taB]

Gah. I'm NOT a wolf.

I've found your musings this time round a lot more sane

For some reason that rings alarm bells!

 

[Damini]

Heh, I'm one of those damned if you do and damned if you don't types then If you check back to a couple villages back, my logic actually saved Milkshake from a burny fate AND outed the wolf, so I do have reserves of logic. It's a bit like those women who lift whole cars to save babies - the ability is there, but it's only to be used on special occasions.

 

[Damini]

MYstIC G - Damini
Ch3tan -
Mabs - gunner
gunner440
Jimmy
Damini - Mystic G
taB - Damini
Calaen
Billargh
inactionman
Fweddy - Ch3tan

Votes so far.

 

[Fweddy]

I'm so confused. Please can one of the werewolves do something suspicious for me?

And Ch3tan, all you said is that Jupitus is not a wolf. I suspect a wolf could have guessed that, not just a seer, so I don't really consider it evidence.

 

[Calaen]

I suppose he could, but unless mabs tell us hes the serial killer then the evidence Ch3t has given us so far has to be taken as true. Trying to get our only known way of correctly identifying the wolves lynched, because you cant kill him at night due to a doctor protecting him is a give away as far as I am concerned.

vote fweddy

 

[taB]

And Ch3tan, all you said is that Jupitus is not a wolf. I suspect a wolf could have guessed that, not just a seer, so I don't really consider it evidence.

That's my niggle too Fweddy, but he couldn't know about any other roles if that is the case. Discounting the wolves, I'm sure about 50% of the people left will have some sort of role: doctors, seers, killers, etc..

It's hard to tell with Ch3t he could have taken it as a massive gamble and hood-winked us all, or he could (unusually) be on the level.

Bottom line for me is the odds fall in favour of Ch3t being who he says he is, be better if he found out who is guilty though, rather than who isn't

 

[Fweddy]

Trying to get our only known way of correctly identifying the wolves

Sorry, but how do you know Ch3t is correctly identifying anything, or that it's to our advantage? All he's said is that Jup was not a werewolf and that Mabs is not one either.
As it seems we only have one pack of wolves to contend with, every werewolf here must know who is and isn't a werewolf.

That's my niggle too Fweddy, but he couldn't know about any other roles if that is the case. Discounting the wolves, I'm sure about 50% of the people left will have some sort of role: doctors, seers, killers, etc..

That's the thing though. Doctors, seers etc aren't wolves, so saying someone isn't a werewolf and them turning out to be a doctor instead of a villager isn't a huge giveaway. It's a little white lie that could easily protect a wily wolf for most of the game, and I believe Ch3tan is that wily.

I don't know for certain or anything, but I don't have any other suspicions at the moment and I don't like how everyone seems to be accepting everything Ch3t says as gospel now. That kind of blind trust scares me.

 

[taB]

That's the thing though. Doctors, seers etc aren't wolves, so saying someone isn't a werewolf and them turning out to be a doctor instead of a villager isn't a huge giveaway. It's a little white lie that could easily protect a wily wolf for most of the game, and I believe Ch3tan is that wily. I don't know for certain or anything, but I don't have any other suspicions at the moment and I don't like how everyone seems to be accepting everything Ch3t says as gospel now. That kind of blind trust scares me.

Yes, but my point is that announcing that someone is a villager when there's a 50% (arbitrary number plucked) chance of them being something else is a big risk. I don't discount your theory, I just find it the less likely scenario of the two available.

 

[Fweddy]

Mabs is NOT a wolf.

At no point does Ch3t say anyone is a villager though.

 

[Damini]

I'm not a hundred percent convinced by any stretch. The fact that we're at this stage and no closer to finding a wolf makes me think we've got a bright bunch to hunt down, and so I'm not discounting anything. However, if Ch3tan isn't a wolf and we burn him, and we lose our seer, then we're really screwed.

 

[taB]

At no point does Ch3t say anyone is a villager though.

Yes, you're right; And with Jup as well, for some reason that's how I had it in my head.

Hmm, can get it right 100% by saying it that way.

Arsebiscuits.

 

[Ch3tan]

I can only give the info that my scrying provides, and I have only been shown that the two I have scryed so far are NOT wolves.

I could have told you that Mabs isn't a wolf, fs.

PS: Jup knew how to do special handshakes.

PPS: Damini = wolf!

Explain yourself meg please.

And I do not think Damini is a wolf, whoever my she is on my suspected insane serial killer list, along with Jimmy and Billargh. Fweddy is just annoying.