Werewolf #5

[Frizz]

Rhetoric aside, we have to make sure we get one tonight. So here's my summary:

Damini - Voted Mal. Seems too delicate to be a wolf. Though it may be a front.
Milkshake - Voted Ch3tan. Feels picked on. Bandwagon hopper.
Ch3tan - Voted Mal. Supposedly a top detective. Suspects Milkshake.
taB - Voted Mal. Has a problem with Frizz, but has greater suspicions for Milkshake.
Frizz - Voted Mal. Suspects taB. Doesn't like to read back.

Atleast one of the four who voted Mal is a wolf.

Hmm, I'm going for an interview now, but when I get back, I'll decide.

 

[Milkshake]

Oh, get off. I voted Ch3tan, everyone voted against...and now people have suspicions for me? And where did Ch3tan suddenly become a 'top detective', because Damini said so?

I'm looking at either a tab/Frizz wolfy or a Damini/Ch3tan wolfy group. t/F seem very against each other (could be a front) but I'm willing to assume that they both suspect each other and thus are both probably innocent.

Let's vote Ch3tan, and see how things go from there.

 

[Milkshake]

Guys, shame on you. This is the SLOWEST day at work by miles....and NOONE is posting.

It makes baby jebus cry

 

[Damini]

I'm here! I don't think I want to change my vote though. I probably will, as I'm dithering about it a lot, but right now I think I will stick with following you around with kindling.

Nothing personal, you understand

*Splashes you with lighter fluid when she thinks you aren't looking*

If I was to change my vote, it would be to Ch3tan. Or TaB. Doesn't narrow the field down greatly. The only person I don't suspect is Frizz.

Ergo Frizz is the most likely to be a wolf.

 

[Milkshake]

So change your vote to Ch3tan, and follow my logic. I'm no dog, I'm just adding logic to a generally fuzzy puzzle.

If Ch3tan is a villager, i think you'll be clean and I'll go for tab/Frizz.

 

[taB]

So change your vote to Ch3tan, and follow my logic. I'm no dog, I'm just adding logic to a generally fuzzy puzzle.

If Ch3tan is a villager, i think you'll be clean and I'll go for tab/Frizz.

Far too suspicious: "I'll be your friend Damini, even if Ch3tan is a villager and I'm wrong I'll gang up with you to burn the others too"

Thanks for the warning. I'm calling bullshit.

vote : Milkshake

 

[Milkshake]

Fair enough

I'm saying to Damini to vote Ch3tan, if Ch3tan is a Villager I believe the two of you are (tab/Frizz), and if she doesn't vote Ch3tan then I believe it's him and her are the wolves.

That's how I'm pushing it. Voting me is silly.

 

[taB]

Fair enough

I'm saying to Damini to vote Ch3tan, if Ch3tan is a Villager I believe the two of you are (tab/Frizz), and if she doesn't vote Ch3tan then I believe it's him and her are the wolves.

That's how I'm pushing it. Voting me is silly.

But that's a ridiculous gamble to take and makes no sense - there are five of us left. If we lynch a villager tonight the wolves will win. Even if the doc gets a save in tonight, it would be 2 v 2 and the furry bastards win.

Did you think noone would spot that?

 

[Milkshake]

I see it that if we lynch a wolf, then I know who the other wolf is.

If we lynch a villager, I know who the other villager.

And we just hope whoever the doctor is will understand this too.

 

[Milkshake]

P.S You should vote ch3tan.

 

[taB]

I see it that if we lynch a wolf, then I know who the other wolf is.

If we lynch a villager, I know who the other villager.

And we just hope whoever the doctor is will understand this too.

And I'm saying if we lynch a villager we lose....

It won't matter for crap whether that gives us the information we need, it'll be too late.

 

[Milkshake]

How do you propose we vote tab, in a way that does not fall into the trap you describe?

I'm all for listening to a solution that will let us win.

 

[taB]

How do you propose we vote tab, in a way that does not fall into the trap you describe?

I'm all for listening to a solution that will let us win.

Who is the us you refer to? Villagers or wolves? My proposal is that we lynch a wolf or we're all stuffed.

First you want Damini to vote with you in a flawed plan, now you want suggestions from me, all in a short space of time. With each post you've made I'm becoming more convinced that my above vote is right.

 

[Frizz]

I think Malecheon is innocent.

Which just makes me think he's guilty :/

The only person I don't suspect is Frizz.

Ergo Frizz is the most likely to be a wolf.

Look where that logic got you, Dams. It just ain't as black and white as that!

Now that I think about it, I think she's baffling with bulldust. But I'm also worried about Milkshake taking suggestions. Hmmm...

*Suspect*

 

[Damini]

Heh. The truth is in the other villages, all the people who I've least suspected have been the wolves, so the less I suspect someone, the more suspicious of them I am.

And it's causing me brain ache.

You can suspect me all you like, but I'm not a wolf.

 

[Ch3tan]

Right. That was not a good night.

I admit that I do not care that random is dead, I would have been trying to get him lynched had he survived. That's because I dislike him.

If I were a wolf I would be stupid to argue with him and then eat him. Then again I could be double bluffing. Ho hum. Milkshake, I had doubts about you and Mal, you forced me to fight for my life and implicate Mal even though I did not really believe he was a wolf.

I am now very unsure as to who your furry buddy is milkshake, but I know that you are furry.

Frizz is still the only other villager I trust, meaning that he is probably a wolf, and he and taB could be playing a clever game.

meh, at the end of the day, I believe in an eye for an eye.

vote Milkshake

 

[Damini]

One more vote to go...

 

[Frizz]

Bleh, it doesn't matter who I go for. Milkshake has been condemned with a majority vote.

Oh well.

Vote: Milkshake

 

[Damini]

Ok, we have a problem.

We have two wolves left.

Milkshake has voted for Ch3tan.

Everyone else has voted for Milkshake.

So, if Milkshake IS a wolf, it means the other wolf is voting for him too.

Which doesn't make a great deal of sense.

Anyone want to volunteer an opinion on this before we start up the fire?

 

[Frizz]

Maybe both wolfs are voting Milkshake?

 

[taB]

Ok, we have a problem.

We have two wolves left.

Milkshake has voted for Ch3tan.

Everyone else has voted for Milkshake.

So, if Milkshake IS a wolf, it means the other wolf is voting for him too.

Which doesn't make a great deal of sense.

Anyone want to volunteer an opinion on this before we start up the fire?

Damn, beaten to it. I was thinking the same thing. Yet as Frizz is still number two suspect in my mind, what other choice does he have but to go with the crowd. I also find it very suspicious that he goes with the majority vote, no offence Damini but you are very swayable (is that a word?). With a bit of effort he could possibly turn one or more of us from the Milkshake vote (prolly not me though) but has gone for the bandwagon so as to appear to have thoughts in line with the villagers.

I believe that Frizz is the 2nd wolf and is going along with the rest of us in the hope he can kill us later.

 

[taB]

Maybe both wolfs are voting Milkshake?

Possible but I don't believe that is the case or I wouldn't have voted for Milkshake.

 

[Frizz]

I had a choice of four people to choose from. I stated my vote didn't matter. And it can still mean two wolfs voted Milkshake.

It's unlikely to be Damini, as she brought it up. You claim you were beaten to saying it taB, but how do we know that? We don't. It could easily be a bluff. And I think it is.

Unvote: Milkshake
Vote: taB

 

[taB]

I had a choice of four people to choose from. I stated my vote didn't matter. And it can still mean two wolfs voted Milkshake.

It's unlikely to be Damini, as she brought it up. You claim you were beaten to saying it taB, but how do we know that? We don't. It could easily be a bluff. And I think it is.

Unvote: Milkshake
Vote: taB

Because I started writing the post and when I previewed it Damini's post was there (and yes that's 15 minutes - I'm checking the forum when I'm not absorbed in game). Your post appeared during this time which is why I answered it separately.

I have been suspicious of you for a while as you are well aware. Your vote (prior to the change to me this time) makes you appear to be Milkshake's number two in this.

 

[Damini]

They way I see it, I have a two out of three chance of picking the wolf (assuming that Milkshake hasn't been saddled with a wolf partner who'd just let him burn and quietly walk away, whistling innocently - and when you bear in mind, as taB pointed out, I'm very easy to persuade to change my vote, doesn't seem likely).

And I still am finding it impossible.

Hrmph.

unvote: Milkshake

vote: Ch3tan

 

[Frizz]

How so? Even if I was, I'd have no way of saving him. No matter what I did. Not that I'm particularly bothered, he could be a wolf. But so could you and someone other than Milkshake.

Remember, we don't know Milkshake is a wolf. It's all speculation.

edit:// Oh, Dams just tied the vote...

 

[Damini]

Yeah, I do that.

 

[taB]

assuming that Milkshake hasn't been saddled with a wolf partner who'd just let him burn and quietly walk away, whistling innocently

I find it hard to believe that a wolf wouldn't ditch his / her partner to fulfill the end goal of eating everyone. These aren't compassionate human beings we are dealing with but calculating monsters .

Even if I was, I'd have no way of saving him

Oh well.

Vote: Milkshake

That pretty much proves my point, you have no option but to vote for him, else to look suspicious. The fact that you've changed tack and switched your sights to me as a last minute attempt to deflect from this doesn't sway me. At least you made the effort to appear like you were voting with the villagers for Milkshake. Switching to vote for me because I've called you out and caused you discomfort is massively transparent.

 

[Frizz]

That pretty much proves my point, you have no option but to vote for him, else to look suspicious. The fact that you've changed tack and switched your sights to me as a last minute attempt to deflect from this doesn't sway me. At least you made the effort to appear like you were voting with the villagers for Milkshake. Switching to vote for me because I've called you out and caused you discomfort is massively transparent.

You insist I was voting with the villagers, perhaps I was inadvertently voting with the wolves?

I had options with my voting, four of them. I chose the bandwagon. For once.

 

[Ch3tan]

I'm off to plough some fields in a few hours, and then I will not be back until our day of rest. Can we please sort this out before soon?

Here is my opinion for what it is worth. Based on this round of voting, Damini has condemned milkshake, and then offered up doubts, which have been suffiecient to switch votes and save milkshake for now. If the wolves thought victory was possible through self sacrifice, then I think they would turn on each other, it makes no sense to expose themselves simply to lose anyway.

However I don't like Damini's constant vote swinging. I realise this will leave me open to a burning if no one else votes, but.

vote Damini