Off-topic Mafia #2 Game Thread

[Amanita]

That last vote was kind of a no brainer since all us mafia just had to gang up on someone

 

[Rubric]

No, We couldn't kill someone the first night becaus amanita forgot her shotgun.

So i was totally suprised that someone was killed in that night! and even a townie! a cop even!

Rubric, you won our game!

And pfew, i was hoping Marc would jump in soon because we just needed 1 more vote. I was getting very suspicous for the rest of you.

You couldn't lose though, i didn't realise there was 3 of you i thought it would be only 2.

 

[Rubric]

Need to find some way to do our voting not based on randomness in the first round. I think if the game started in the night stage and gave the mafia a chance to talk and lynch someone on the first night we could then get the discussion going.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Need to find some way to do our voting not based on randomness in the first round. I think if the game started in the night stage and gave the mafia a chance to talk and lynch someone on the first night we could then get the discussion going.

Well, according to rules, that's how it should start.

 

[Iceforge]

Well, according to rules, that's how it should start.

Yeah, I know, but I always start mine on day and all games I've ever seen start with day.
I also only seen small games through.
A normal game would have between 20 and 30 players and then it is more fair with a kill on the first night. with just 7-8 it kinda screw things up

 

[Iceforge]

You couldn't lose though, i didn't realise there was 3 of you i thought it would be only 2.

Not correct, you was the quickest killer.
So lynch day 2 on Cerb or Lethul and you targetting the one with the gun night 2 would be 2 townies, 2 mafia left on day 3, if then the othe rof Cerb and Lethul was killed, leaving you alone and you hit shotgun holder again, it would be 1-1, you being quick-killer = Town win

Else I wouldn't have let day 2 play at all

Oh, that is a mod houserule I made up, originally for Kirennia as Serial Killer, to balance things up a tiny bit.

 

[Levin]

Now i'm all nervous about the next game! There are a lot of rules and this game was a lot more complicated than the first, so I hope I don't screw anything up during the night phase.

 

[Iceforge]

Now i'm all nervous about the next game! There are a lot of rules and this game was a lot more complicated than the first, so I hope I don't screw anything up during the night phase.

Hehe, I wont make the next more complicated than this one

And if you think this is complicated, you should see my Monty Python and the holy grail setup I am about to play on another forum when it becomes my turn to mod

 

[Rubric]

Not correct, you was the quickest killer.
So lynch day 2 on Cerb or Lethul and you targetting the one with the gun night 2 would be 2 townies, 2 mafia left on day 3, if then the othe rof Cerb and Lethul was killed, leaving you alone and you hit shotgun holder again, it would be 1-1, you being quick-killer = Town win

Else I wouldn't have let day 2 play at all

Oh, that is a mod houserule I made up, originally for Kirennia as Serial Killer, to balance things up a tiny bit.

ah i see if all three mafia had lumped on another townie other than me i cuold have levelled things at night.

 

[old.Tohtori]

Yeah, I know, but I always start mine on day and all games I've ever seen start with day.
I also only seen small games through.
A normal game would have between 20 and 30 players and then it is more fair with a kill on the first night. with just 7-8 it kinda screw things up

Yeah i know, just seems "unrealistic"(i know!) with a lynching without a murder.

Don't they lynch someone on day 1 anyway?

So basically it's the same, someone dies on round one.

 

[Iceforge]

Yeah i know, just seems "unrealistic"(i know!) with a lynching without a murder.

Don't they lynch someone on day 1 anyway?

So basically it's the same, someone dies on round one.

Well, the assumption with a day start is that the moderator is killed on night zero

 

[old.Tohtori]

Well, the assumption with a day start is that the moderator is killed on night zero

Aaa. Ok, then i can wrap my brain around it.

 

[Vasconcelos]

Funny, i went all happy to play Columbo on Rubric's ass by nite and got ganked by Rubric himself after founding he was a townie