IBM HD Problems plz help

d1m3b4g

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Jul 25, 2004
Messages
14
I've got a 60 gig deskstar model that is going seriously wrong. Its one of the older ones the 60gxp that ibm put out before hitachi took over.

What happens is, with the drive plugged in, no matter if its on its own channel or sharing, the machine (p4 2.8 intel board) hangs on detecting IDE drives etc and then takes an age to boot.

The problem was picked up when I was trying to capture raw DV from a firewire device and it was comming out all jumpy and the sound was messed up. So i looked to see if the drive was forced into PIO mode just as a long shot. It was.

Everything I tried from that point on to get the drive into UDMA wouldnt work, so I wondered why. I read up from a MS knowledge base article that windows will force the drive into a lower transfer mode if it picks up a certain amount of CRC or data errors across the interface.

So basically IBM fitness test says the drive is totally fine, the SMART status of it says its also fine. But its not, its completely useless. No wonder my raid setup was getting messed up with it.

So basically where do I go from here?
I need the drive to work for my video editing machine, to store massive avis that I rip from it. But I'm assuming without a proper return RMA code thing IBM/hitachi wont listen as I have no way of "proving" the drive is f**ked other than getting one of their engineers from whatever asian country they live in to come over to my house and watch.

:(

Suggestions?

Dime
 

smurkin

Can't get enough of FH
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
561
I dont have any advice..more anecdotal....I got through 4x 60 gxps and 2x 120 gxps...they were awful drives...click off death stuff. Particularly bad for running RAID0. There is a software patch for the drive's behaviour that causes the click of death behaviour (IBMs site). These days I'm into western digital caviars (2x120Gb) and a raptor for my os...seem to be good drives.
 

smurkin

Can't get enough of FH
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
561
seems to have gone cold... :m00: so here goes..

How come it messed up your RAID...do you have two of these drives ?

Is this drive still borked when not on the RAID controller ? (you know, your DV capture should work without having to resort to RAID)....is the drive going clunk or clickety ?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom