Coolermaster Praetorian Mini-review

MrBlack

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
148
This is just a mini-review of this case. Some hardware sites have a serious tendency to waffle for 6 pages when it comes to product reviews. I'll try to stick to the useful information.

This is an expensive case for the features. It is pleasingly light, the entire chasis being hewn from the purest simmering (well brushed, anyway) aluminium; but what you get for the £95 you'll spend on it doesn't seem like a lot.

Access is pretty easy. Both side panels are secured with three thumb screws, some taking a screwdriver to loosen up, but that's no major problem. The Motherboard tray slides out of the back of the case after removing another 4 thumb screws. It sticks a bit and takes some working to get completely out; but after that it's a breeze to install the initial parts.

The rear blanking plates are also secured with thumbscrews, surprisingly enough. Standard ATX PSUs will fit in a cage at the top after affixing an adaptor plate to the back of the PSU. This cage got in the way of my ATX connector and generally obstructed me a little once the tray was re-inserted.

The drive bays take a back-to-basics approach. Simply two cut sheets of aluminium that you screw your 5.25" drives into and with helpful little ledges to rest your 3.5" drives on prior to screwing them in, as well. There's some useful dead space either side of the 3.5" rack for shoving loops of ribbon cable out of the way of the primary airflow routes, too.

The case's capacity belies its size somewhat. You can comfortably fit 4 hard drives in the rack, which extends right to the bottom of the case, giving each drive lots of space either side to allow for good airflow. There's room for 4 5.25" drives, too, although the motherboard tray obstructs the bottom two slots so that only shorter drives will fit. There's also a pair of external 3.5" bays. I've got two cd drives, 3 cd drives and a floppy drive in the front of this case without it feeling cramped at all. The case is quite deep for its height, which seems to make all the difference.

The front panel connector block provides a firewire, 2 USB and an audio block. behind a neat swinging door so as not to spoil the flush frontage. Power and HDD LEDs are both blue, which they just had to be, really. I'd feel conned if I'd spent nearly a ton and got boring plebby red and green ones.

Cooling is well catered for. The interal hard drive bays have 2 front mounted 60mm intake fans (molex connectors) blowing across them. There's a 60mm rear fan by the I/O panel (3-pin motherboard connector, usefully) and another 60mm molex fan at the top.

The general build quality is the best I've seen in a case. The side panels slide in easily, screw holes align perfectly and the front face looks clean and stylish, should you care about these things. The look is spoiled a little if, like me, you stuff crappy begie-fronted CD and floppy drives into it. One irritation is that the front blanking plate retaining screws took a lot of work to remove; some feeling like they were cross-threaded. Again, this is only a minor fault. The unit is also light. (Yay aluminium again)

So this a good, solid, spacious and light case. While its flaws are only slight, I think £95-£105 is a bit much to fork out for it, since no PSU is supplied. These, I suppose are the drawbacks of aluminium cases. I can't give any comparisons to other models of this type as haven't seen any of the others close up.

I got mine from Scan (http://web6.scan.co.uk/Products/Info.asp?WPID=85626) which, from my hunting, was a tenner cheaper than everywhere else I looked.

It is now also available in black, for those of a more nihilistic bent.

MrB.
 

SilverHood

FH is my second home
Joined
Dec 23, 2003
Messages
2,300
I got one of these babies, except my LED is green.

They truly rock, and are great for overclockers.
Only other problem I found, was when installing my PSU, it was a bit too small for the bay provided. Otherwise, I have no complaints


:clap:
 

wyrd_fish

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 27, 2003
Messages
537
glad you like it

maybe the review i read was written by a moron
 

Clown

Part of the furniture
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
4,292
Don't 60mm fans make for noisy computer? Oh why oh why am I so obsessed with quietness all of a sudden :(
 

MrBlack

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
148
They're not exactly whisper quiet, no, but they're not noisy. If I had any kind of measuring equipment, I'd give you a dbA rating, but I don't so I'll class them as "Average".

Hmm.. Just realised I've written 60mm across the board. They're all 80s.. doh.

/me edits and no-one will be any the wiser.

Edit: Oh yeah, I can't edit it. Damn.
 

jaba

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 25, 2003
Messages
780
Nice review MrBlack! thanks very much indeed..maybe we should have a review forum where people can write things about stuff they own?
 

MrBlack

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
148
Thanks jaba.

A small warning adendum to that review:

The front grill is quite weak. Were you to, say, brace your foot against it to aid in pushing it back under your desk for example, (Not speaking from personal experience here and I'll smack anyone who says I am) then you might sort of dent it... a bit..

*ahem*
 

Clown

Part of the furniture
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
4,292
I think I'd like a black case, but not one like those Thermaltake ones. They just look tacky. What's a good site to browse for cases, with pictures and stuff?

I'm on the look out for a simple black case, with slide out mobo thing, and maybe space for some quiet fans.
 

DaGaffer

Down With That Sorta Thing
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
18,498
Clown said:
I think I'd like a black case, but not one like those Thermaltake ones. They just look tacky. What's a good site to browse for cases, with pictures and stuff?

I'm on the look out for a simple black case, with slide out mobo thing, and maybe space for some quiet fans.

I've got the black version of this (well its called ATC something or other, but its the same case basically), and the only problem I've had with black is that if you want it to look good (and lets face it, you wouldn't get a black case if you didn't care about appearance) then finding matching black DVD and diskette drives etc is a real pain in the arse. If I was going to get a black case again, I'd make sure it was one with doors/"stealth" drive bays, so I could hide all the white/beige crap away more effectively.

Oh, and its not quiet in standard form. I've got a Vaio desktop as well and you could put that in the living room no problem, its really quiet. No chance with the Coolermaster.
 

Llixeraxu

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Feb 3, 2004
Messages
131
sorry to rez such an old thread,

BUt it inspired me to buy one.

Review is spot on.. as is the point about the average sounding fans.

Looks great. BUilt great.

Had a few cases in my time and this is by far the best ive had.

The buttons on the front feel real nice when you push them on or off.. and no pesky re-set button that you need a pen to push it in with.

One point.

You can buy front bezels to cover the optical drives. Made by cooler master.

8.5/10!

why not 10? noise. price. gets dirty real easy. Touched it with my not so greasy paw.. and i can still see it now.. and polish dosnt work.

STupid black brushed finish lol. Looks sexeh tho
 

Clown

Part of the furniture
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
4,292
The lights at the front can be a bit bright. I have to put a towel over it when I'm watching a movie or going to sleep. Saying that, I could just turn them off... But I'm not going to do that.

I'd fully recommend the Sonata. I have an Athlon 2500+ @ 2400MHz, so it should be pretty warm, but it's at ~38 degrees and ~30 degrees for the case... All depending on the room temperature of course.

Don't expect it to totally shut out the sound tho. If I turned my fans up, then it sounds like any other case, and the whine of the 9800 Pro is still heard. There isn't any pull-out motherboard tray either, but I love the way the hard drives are put in. Sideways and with the tray thing.
 

wyrd_fish

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 27, 2003
Messages
537
i liked the idea of sideways HDDs

as for sound and lights, that won't bother me

and a MoBo tray would be nice, but i'm not going to change it around in there too often
 

Clown

Part of the furniture
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
4,292
What are you thinking of putting in there?
I'm nosey :p
 

wyrd_fish

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 27, 2003
Messages
537
just a 9600XT, 1800duron and a temp controlled PSU

the 9600 and duron are also temp contoled


oh, and maybe 1 case fan
 

Clown

Part of the furniture
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
4,292
It comes with a nice and quiet PSU in it already and a case fan that's pretty noisy if it's not connected to the low voltage power plug.
 

wyrd_fish

Fledgling Freddie
Joined
Dec 27, 2003
Messages
537
i made my my case fan from an old PSU :D

method:
take 1 PSU and remove an 80mm fan and a female molex
combine with the use of a soldering iron ad electrical tape

tweesers are required for dismantling molexs
 

Clown

Part of the furniture
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
4,292
Just use the one it comes with because it's a pain to take it out :p
 

Herbal

Loyal Freddie
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
472
Clown said:
The 80mm wouldn't fit in a Sonata :)
did in mine ;p
also theres a slot/connection holes for a further fan in the front of the sonata its a bitch to get to tho :(
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom