With the keep merry-go-round we have since the gold bags, its been possible to test the players theory that contribution is fixed when you enter the zone.
After around 30 keeps yesterday. Thats 15 zones. Most people in a warband got the same contribution for the second keep as they did in he first keep.
For example. These are the positions I got for the first few zones
Zone ---- Keep 1 ---- Keep 2
DW ------ 45 -------- 43
TM ------- 32 ------- 34
Praag ----- 20 ------- 17
DW ------- 2 ------- 2
Praag ----- 62 ------ 68
TM ------- 9 ------- 8
Praag ------ 13 ------ 14
DW ------- 25 ------- 20
TM ------- 12 ------- 11
This was with me just auto attacking and then entering the keep and attacking the lord.
The contribution score of 2 I had, I didnt even auto attack or attack the lord. I rolled 950 then as well. inc well deserved gold bag .
At one point, a player joined the warband in the last few seconds of the lord fight and just managed to get into the area of influence. He did nothing and came 3rd. As the warband obviously did enough to class him as having done somehting, he counted as having contributed. We told him to do nothing special the next keep, and sure enough, he came 3rd before the roll.
The only times that contirbution differed by any degree was when I zoned in between keeps. For example, I had 60+ contribution. On the way to the second keep, I took the flight master to a different tier and then back again. I then had 25 contribution.
The only other occasions I had a change was where I CTD a some point.
This was watched and remarked on by both warbands running about (both fighting in the same place, and members being swapped between the two as players crashed out and the bands were recreated)
What does this proove?
Contribution is missnamed, it is a figure given to the player as they enter the zone. It has nothing to do with any contribution the player actually makes to the fight.
Get rid of it. Its abusable, players with good contributuion scores were staying in the zone waiting for the keeps to be retaken so they could rely on the same contribution again.
Its shoddy programming and makes the keep takes feel even more lackluster than normal.
After around 30 keeps yesterday. Thats 15 zones. Most people in a warband got the same contribution for the second keep as they did in he first keep.
For example. These are the positions I got for the first few zones
Zone ---- Keep 1 ---- Keep 2
DW ------ 45 -------- 43
TM ------- 32 ------- 34
Praag ----- 20 ------- 17
DW ------- 2 ------- 2
Praag ----- 62 ------ 68
TM ------- 9 ------- 8
Praag ------ 13 ------ 14
DW ------- 25 ------- 20
TM ------- 12 ------- 11
This was with me just auto attacking and then entering the keep and attacking the lord.
The contribution score of 2 I had, I didnt even auto attack or attack the lord. I rolled 950 then as well. inc well deserved gold bag .
At one point, a player joined the warband in the last few seconds of the lord fight and just managed to get into the area of influence. He did nothing and came 3rd. As the warband obviously did enough to class him as having done somehting, he counted as having contributed. We told him to do nothing special the next keep, and sure enough, he came 3rd before the roll.
The only times that contirbution differed by any degree was when I zoned in between keeps. For example, I had 60+ contribution. On the way to the second keep, I took the flight master to a different tier and then back again. I then had 25 contribution.
The only other occasions I had a change was where I CTD a some point.
This was watched and remarked on by both warbands running about (both fighting in the same place, and members being swapped between the two as players crashed out and the bands were recreated)
What does this proove?
Contribution is missnamed, it is a figure given to the player as they enter the zone. It has nothing to do with any contribution the player actually makes to the fight.
Get rid of it. Its abusable, players with good contributuion scores were staying in the zone waiting for the keeps to be retaken so they could rely on the same contribution again.
Its shoddy programming and makes the keep takes feel even more lackluster than normal.