Snifnarb said:Look at this link
http://www.visionofsages.net/toa/artifacts/madtales.html
It appears that healers/hybrids who wear armor (cleric, druid, shammy, healer) will get the TANK version of Maddening Scalars with the tank stats such as melee speed, they cannot recieve a version of the Maddening Scalars with appropriate stats.