tic or theurg?

[Golly]

for general usefullness and utility in a group (damage also included as util) which is the best char and what spec?

looking at either 41 ice 35 earth
45 wind 25 ice 16 earth
50 enhance 50 flex 23 shield
50 enhance 48 rej 35 crush?

something along them lines for rvr fg warfare, what and why is the most suitable char, all RAs included etc

 

[Corran]

for general usefullness and utility in a group (damage also included as util) which is the best char and what spec?

looking at either 41 ice 35 earth
45 wind 25 ice 16 earth
50 enhance 50 flex 23 shield
50 enhance 48 rej 35 crush?

something along them lines for rvr fg warfare, what and why is the most suitable char, all RAs included etc

Played both.

Tic is RR6 and is reliant on RA's alot of the time
Theurg i RR8+ and is always great, RA's just improve it that bit more.

If you just wanted utility then heretic got more Heals (haha power eating), rezzs, uninteruptable nuke and tough to kill. Lots of things interupt your uninteruptable. And no charge/det hurts your ability in melee tank. Mediocre damage (but can be quite constant), mediocre interupt ability, lots of RA utility.

Theurg is great interupt, good nuker but easier to kill if you leave self in a bad position. Personally when it comes to groups i would and do always pick my theurg. But then since I rolled him I always enjoyed him alot more then any other toon i played so im biased

 

[raid]

have played theurgist some, never tic tho so cant compare them from player pov.

however from enemy (mid) pov, interrupt wise tic normally gives our groups much more trouble than theurgist. on the other hand theurgist sure has much more damage potential, especially with caba debuffing spirit.

 

[Illudian]

Do caba's cba to debuff spirit ?

 

[Manisch Depressiv]

Against caster heavy groups both Theurg and Tic is good. Against tank heavy groups I'd say the Tic is better, he is very hard to kill and can snare better.

I played a 41 Ice Theurg a few nights against caster groups and I liked it very much but I'd say overall a Tic has better group utility. Harder to kill, PR, DI, BOAD, RR5, AoE snare, Banelord.

I play 50 Flex, 50 Enh, 23 Shield, rest Rejv and I like it very much. Levi damage is just amazing and the insta snare is teh pwn. Also got insta dot for interrupt and MoC1 for AoE snare spam.

Yet, I'd rather replace a Merc with a Tic instead a Theurg.

 

[Maoni]

Do caba's cba to debuff spirit ?

ahh nvm misread...well when i played the caba with spirit spec i debuffed both body and spirit depending on situation etc..

I havent tried the summon pets rr5 thing on theurg but tic rr5 is really nice for tanks/support in grp...pity the RA doesnt help the casters tho.