Thane template, need feedback

[Dumle]

Ok so heres what Im thinking about, Is + Shield worth it now or am I better off switching it for +Qui?

I am a frostalf thane so I have made it "caster" oriented, some think its a waste but I think its fun to make it a bit different

Will be playing him a bit in grp but mostly solo/duo I guess so what will benefit me the most, Qui or Shield? (Im specced 42/42/48 btw.)

The numbers in (..) are with or without Qui/Shield, if I switch them that is.

Config Report

Stats

Str: 92 Int: 0 Hits: 240
Con: 86 Pie: 95 Power: 0
Dex: 92 Cha: 0
Qui: 0 (50) Emp: 0

Resists

Body: 27 Energy: 22 Crush: 21
Cold: 27 Matter: 17 Thrust: 23 (3)
Heat: 25 Spirit: 23 (5) Slash: 25 (2)

Skills
9 Shield (0 Shield)
11 Hammer

Focus

Cap Increases
17 Dex
72 Hits
8 AF
18 Pie
16 Str
11 Con

Other Bonuses
9 Style Damage Bonus
4 Spell Range Bonus
4 Spell Damage Bonus
4 Melee Damage Bonus
10 Casting Speed Bonus
5 Fatigue
13 Power Percentage Bonus

Piece Listing

Chest
Name: Guard of Valor (Thane)
Level: 51 Quality: 94
AF: Bonus:
Effect 1: 40 Hits
Effect 2: 18 Strength
Effect 3: 5 Strength Cap Increase
Effect 4: 15 Dexterity
Effect 5: 5 Dexterity Cap Increase
Effect 6: 4 Melee Damage Bonus
Effect 7: 4 Spell Damage Bonus
Effect 8: 4 Style Damage Bonus
Effect 9: 4 Spell Range Bonus
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 32.00

Arms
Imbue Points: 37.5 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 22 Dexterity - 99 precious Vapor Essence
Gem 2: 22 Strength - 99 precious Fiery Essence
Gem 3: 4 Axe - 99 flawed Earthen War Rune
Gem 4: 60 Hits - 99 precious Blood Essence
Utility: 64.33

Head
Imbue Points: 37.5 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 19 Piety - 99 faceted Watery Essence
Gem 2: 3 Axe - 99 rough Earthen War Rune
Gem 3: 5 Shield - 99 imperfect Fiery Battle Jewel
Gem 4: 7 Slash Resist - 99 imperfect Watery Shielding
Utility: 66.67

Legs
Imbue Points: 37.5 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 16 Strength - 99 polished Fiery Essence
Gem 2: 13 Constitution - 99 imperfect Earthen Essence
Gem 3: 11 Spirit Resist - 99 faceted Vapor Shielding
Gem 4: 4 Shield - 99 flawed Fiery Battle Jewel
Utility: 61.33

Hands
Imbue Points: 37.5 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 22 Constitution - 99 precious Earthen Essence
Gem 2: 19 Piety - 99 faceted Watery Essence
Gem 3: 4 Axe - 99 flawed Earthen War Rune
Gem 4: 9 Energy Resist - 99 polished Light Shielding
Utility: 65.33

Feet
Name: Soot smudged boots
Level: 51 Quality: 94
AF: Bonus:
Effect 1: 21 Strength
Effect 2: 21 Constitution
Effect 3: 40 Hits
Effect 4: 6 Strength Cap Increase
Effect 5: 6 Constitution Cap Increase
Effect 6: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 38.00

Right Hand
Name: Malice Axe
Level: 51 Quality: 94
DPS: Bonus:
Effect 1: 15 Strength
Effect 2: 15 Constitution
Effect 3: 5 Strength Cap Increase
Effect 4: 5 Constitution Cap Increase
Effect 5: 40 Hits Cap Increase
Effect 6: 5 Style Damage Bonus
Effect 7: 5 Fatigue
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 20.00

Left Hand
Name: Cyclops Eye Shield
Level: 51 Quality: 94
DPS: Bonus:
Effect 1: 40 Hits
Effect 2: 5 Heat Resist
Effect 3: 5 Cold Resist
Effect 4: 5 Matter Resist
Effect 5: 5 Body Resist
Effect 6: 5 Energy Resist
Effect 7: 8 AF Cap Increase
Effect 8: 32 Hits Cap Increase
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 60.00

Two Handed
Imbue Points: 0.0 of 10 (94 Qual) Overcharge: None
Gem 1: Empty -
Gem 2: Empty -
Gem 3: Empty -
Gem 4: Empty -
Utility: 0.00

Ranged
Imbue Points: 0.0 of 10 (94 Qual) Overcharge: None
Gem 1: Empty -
Gem 2: Empty -
Gem 3: Empty -
Gem 4: Empty -
Utility: 0.00

Neck
Name: Beaded resisting stones
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 10 Crush Resist
Effect 2: 10 Thrust Resist
Effect 3: 10 Body Resist
Effect 4: 10 Cold Resist
Effect 5: Empty
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 80.00

Cloak
Name: Cloak of Runic rapidity
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 15 Constitution
Effect 2: 18 Dexterity
Effect 3: 18 Piety
Effect 4: 6 Piety Cap Increase
Effect 5: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 34.00

Jewel
Name: Harpy feather charm
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 6 Heat Resist
Effect 2: 6 Cold Resist
Effect 3: 6 Matter Resist
Effect 4: 6 Body Resist
Effect 5: Empty
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 48.00

Belt
Name: Belt of Moirai
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 7 Spirit Resist
Effect 2: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 3: 8 Dexterity Cap Increase
Effect 4: 8 Piety Cap Increase
Effect 5: 8 Power Percentage Bonus
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 14.00

Right Ring
Name: Ring of the torrent
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 11 Crush Resist
Effect 2: 10 Slash Resist
Effect 3: 10 Thrust Resist
Effect 4: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 5: Empty
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 62.00

Left Ring
Name: Immolated ring
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 15 Dexterity
Effect 2: 15 Piety
Effect 3: 8 Heat Resist
Effect 4: 8 Energy Resist
Effect 5: 4 Dexterity Cap Increase
Effect 6: 4 Piety Cap Increase
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 52.00

Right Wrist
Name: Bracer of the deep
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 24 Piety
Effect 2: 22 Dexterity
Effect 3: 60 Hits
Effect 4: 5 Power Percentage Bonus
Effect 5: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 45.67

Left Wrist
Name: Ebon hide Bracer
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 6 Slash Resist
Effect 2: 6 Cold Resist
Effect 3: 6 Matter Resist
Effect 4: 6 Body Resist
Effect 5: 6 Heat Resist
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 60.00

 

[Dumle]

Modified it a little bit...

Config Report

Stats

Str: 91 Int: 0 Hits: 236
Con: 86 Pie: 95 Power: 0
Dex: 92 Cha: 0
Qui: 53 Emp: 0

Resists

Body: 22 Energy: 26 Crush: 21
Cold: 22 Matter: 12 Thrust: 23 (3)
Heat: 26 Spirit: 21 (5) Slash: 27 (2)

Skills
11 Hammer
8 Shield
3 Sword
3 Axe

Focus

Cap Increases
17 Dex
40 Hits
18 Pie
16 Str
11 Con

Other Bonuses
9 Style Damage Bonus
4 Spell Range Bonus
4 Spell Damage Bonus
4 Melee Damage Bonus
2 Melee Speed Bonus
10 Casting Speed Bonus
5 Fatigue
13 Power Percentage Bonus

Piece Listing

Chest
Name: Guard of Valor (Thane)
Level: 51 Quality: 94
AF: Bonus:
Effect 1: 40 Hits
Effect 2: 18 Strength
Effect 3: 5 Strength Cap Increase
Effect 4: 15 Dexterity
Effect 5: 5 Dexterity Cap Increase
Effect 6: 4 Melee Damage Bonus
Effect 7: 4 Spell Damage Bonus
Effect 8: 4 Style Damage Bonus
Effect 9: 4 Spell Range Bonus
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 32.00

Arms
Imbue Points: 37.5 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 13 Strength - 99 imperfect Fiery Essence
Gem 2: 19 Piety - 99 faceted Watery Essence
Gem 3: 11 Energy Resist - 99 faceted Light Shielding
Gem 4: 52 Hits - 99 faceted Blood Essence
Utility: 56.33

Head
Imbue Points: 37.0 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 22 Dexterity - 99 precious Vapor Essence
Gem 2: 4 Hammer - 99 flawed Fiery War Rune
Gem 3: 3 Shield - 99 rough Fiery Battle Jewel
Gem 4: 25 Quickness - 99 flawless Airy Essence
Utility: 66.33

Legs
Imbue Points: 37.5 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 13 Constitution - 99 imperfect Earthen Essence
Gem 2: 7 Energy Resist - 99 imperfect Light Shielding
Gem 3: 9 Spirit Resist - 99 polished Vapor Shielding
Gem 4: 28 Quickness - 99 perfect Airy Essence
Utility: 59.33

Hands
Imbue Points: 37.5 of 32 (100 Qual) Overcharge: 38%
Gem 1: 22 Constitution - 99 precious Earthen Essence
Gem 2: 19 Piety - 99 faceted Watery Essence
Gem 3: 9 Slash Resist - 99 polished Watery Shielding
Gem 4: 4 Hammer - 99 flawed Fiery War Rune
Utility: 65.33

Feet
Name: Soot smudged boots
Level: 51 Quality: 94
AF: Bonus:
Effect 1: 21 Strength
Effect 2: 21 Constitution
Effect 3: 40 Hits
Effect 4: 6 Strength Cap Increase
Effect 5: 6 Constitution Cap Increase
Effect 6: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 38.00

Right Hand
Name: Malice Axe
Level: 51 Quality: 94
DPS: Bonus:
Effect 1: 15 Strength
Effect 2: 15 Constitution
Effect 3: 5 Strength Cap Increase
Effect 4: 5 Constitution Cap Increase
Effect 5: 40 Hits Cap Increase
Effect 6: 5 Style Damage Bonus
Effect 7: 5 Fatigue
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 20.00

Left Hand
Name: Magma infused heater shield
Level: 51 Quality: 94
DPS: Bonus:
Effect 1: 5 Shield
Effect 2: 24 Strength
Effect 3: 6 Heat Resist
Effect 4: 3 All Melee Skill Bonus
Effect 5: 2 Melee Speed Bonus
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 68.00

Two Handed
Name: Magmabattler (Con)
Level: 51 Quality: 94
DPS: Bonus:
Effect 1: 15 Strength
Effect 2: 15 Constitution
Effect 3: 10 AF Cap Increase
Effect 4: 6 Crush Resist
Effect 5: 6 Slash Resist
Effect 6: 6 Thrust Resist
Effect 7: 3 Melee Speed Bonus
Effect 8: 4 Melee Damage Bonus
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 56.00

Ranged
Imbue Points: 0.0 of 10 (94 Qual) Overcharge: None
Gem 1: Empty -
Gem 2: Empty -
Gem 3: Empty -
Gem 4: Empty -
Utility: 0.00

Neck
Name: Beaded resisting stones
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 10 Crush Resist
Effect 2: 10 Thrust Resist
Effect 3: 10 Body Resist
Effect 4: 10 Cold Resist
Effect 5: Empty
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 80.00

Cloak
Name: Cloak of Runic rapidity
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 15 Constitution
Effect 2: 18 Dexterity
Effect 3: 18 Piety
Effect 4: 6 Piety Cap Increase
Effect 5: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 34.00

Jewel
Name: Harpy feather charm
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 6 Heat Resist
Effect 2: 6 Cold Resist
Effect 3: 6 Matter Resist
Effect 4: 6 Body Resist
Effect 5: 44 Hits
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 59.00

Belt
Name: Belt of Moirai
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 7 Spirit Resist
Effect 2: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 3: 8 Dexterity Cap Increase
Effect 4: 8 Piety Cap Increase
Effect 5: 8 Power Percentage Bonus
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 14.00

Right Ring
Name: Ring of the torrent
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 11 Crush Resist
Effect 2: 10 Slash Resist
Effect 3: 10 Thrust Resist
Effect 4: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 5: Empty
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 62.00

Left Ring
Name: Immolated ring
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 15 Dexterity
Effect 2: 15 Piety
Effect 3: 8 Heat Resist
Effect 4: 8 Energy Resist
Effect 5: 4 Dexterity Cap Increase
Effect 6: 4 Piety Cap Increase
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 52.00

Right Wrist
Name: Bracer of the deep
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 24 Piety
Effect 2: 22 Dexterity
Effect 3: 60 Hits
Effect 4: 5 Power Percentage Bonus
Effect 5: 2 Casting Speed Bonus
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 45.67

Left Wrist
Name: Ebon hide Bracer
Level: 51 Quality:
Bonus:
Effect 1: 6 Slash Resist
Effect 2: 6 Cold Resist
Effect 3: 6 Matter Resist
Effect 4: 6 Body Resist
Effect 5: 6 Heat Resist
Effect 6: Empty
Effect 7: Empty
Effect 8: Empty
Effect 9: Empty
Effect 10: Empty
Utility: 60.00

 

[Cozak]

Looks pretty good to me nice balance between melee toa bonuses and caster bonuses, think i will use it for my thane if i ever get around to toa'ing him

 

[Azathrim]

Nice template, but are you sure GoV gives both magic and melee bonuses for Thanes?
(it would make sense, but you know, ... Mythic).

 

[Cami]

Nice template, but are you sure GoV gives both magic and melee bonuses for Thanes?
(it would make sense, but you know, ... Mythic).

Yep, gives the same stats as the shaman version.