Renew Rift?

As it says on the tin

  • Yarp

    Votes: 22 53.7%
  • Narp

    Votes: 12 29.3%
  • Mebbe

    Votes: 7 17.1%

  • Total voters
    41

Ctuchik

FH is my second home
Joined
Dec 23, 2003
Messages
10,466
Depends on if they nerf warriors or not.

If they do, yes.

If they don't, no.
 

Toggers

One of Freddy's beloved
Joined
Jan 23, 2004
Messages
502
hating this mana drain bollox but other than that its a great game
 

Madmaxx

FH is my second home
Joined
Feb 14, 2009
Messages
2,934
yeah everytime I get bored I just change roles, will keep me interested for a while just for that; only 35 so far but still enjoying it.
 

eksdee

FH is my second home
Joined
Feb 17, 2006
Messages
4,469
Yep, definitely. I think the game has massive potential. Warrior damage and mana drains need looking at, plus more incentives to open world PvP. That aside, the game is just what I have been waiting for for a long, long time.
 

Punishment

Resident Freddy
Joined
Jan 23, 2005
Messages
8,604
Yep, definitely. I think the game has massive potential. Warrior damage and mana drains need looking at, plus more incentives to open world PvP. That aside, the game is just what I have been waiting for for a long, long time.

(Rubs Hands) So who is pling me ?:p
 

eksdee

FH is my second home
Joined
Feb 17, 2006
Messages
4,469
Sadly powerleveling doesn't work (we're tried multiple methods).
 

pito

Loyal Freddie
Joined
Sep 3, 2008
Messages
120
I have to agree it is a good game, still needs some balancing and some bug fixing (tired of rifting through the world floor) but it has great promise ( at least until GW2)
 

pito

Loyal Freddie
Joined
Sep 3, 2008
Messages
120
GW was even a true mmo tho was it ? most of it is instanced

GW yes i agree it was just istanced but from what i have seen and played of GW2 is totally different i mean time will tell whether or not it will be as good as it paints to be but i have high hopes.
 

Syri

FH is my second home
Joined
Jan 4, 2004
Messages
1,019
GW was even a true mmo tho was it ? most of it is instanced

Guild Wars is mostly instanced, apart from the towns. GW2 however is going to use the more traditional open world system, used by most MMOs. I'd expect it will still feature some instancing, but most of the adventuring will be done in the same world as other players, not your own private little world.
 

BloodOmen

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
18,132
Love the mage QQ :) 20 yard range on champion charge, 30 yard range on mage spells HERP DERP.

That said Champions are fine, you're basicly crying about their damage this early in the game before everyone gets pvp souls sorted + decent amounts of valor, quite silly really. Thats like saying "Oh a Shadowblade PA'd me for 4000 damage because I have no resists :() :p especially given how hard MAGES can nuke with that 30 yard range vs melee's 15-20 yard charge ranges.

As for mana drains as said previously dominator mana drain is by far more op than void knights mana drain because it scales.
 

BloodOmen

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
18,132
Love the mage QQ :) 20 yard range on champion charge, 30 yard range on mage spells HERP DERP.

That said Champions are fine, you're basicly crying about their damage this early in the game before everyone gets pvp souls sorted + decent amounts of valor, quite silly really. Thats like saying "Oh a Shadowblade PA'd me for 4000 damage because I have no resists :() :p especially given how hard MAGES can nuke with that 30 yard range vs melee's 15-20 yard charge ranges.

As for mana drains as said previously dominator mana drain is by far more op than void knights mana drain because it scales.

Forgot to add: weapon stones are quite imba for champs also when combined with proper timing and titan strike :p 15% bonus crit damage from weapon stones trolololol + destroyer's bearing = ouchies.
 

Ctuchik

FH is my second home
Joined
Dec 23, 2003
Messages
10,466
Love the mage QQ :) 20 yard range on champion charge, 30 yard range on mage spells HERP DERP.

That said Champions are fine, you're basicly crying about their damage this early in the game before everyone gets pvp souls sorted + decent amounts of valor, quite silly really. Thats like saying "Oh a Shadowblade PA'd me for 4000 damage because I have no resists :() :p especially given how hard MAGES can nuke with that 30 yard range vs melee's 15-20 yard charge ranges.

But you seem to forget that all our really hard nukes have 2 seconds or more cast time (4.2 for the really kickass one even after talented to be faster), meaning that those extra 10 yards means fuck all as a champion will guaranteed have the in combat bull rush talent, and an assortment of talents that breaks him free of CC's.

And from a melee vs caster point of view, valor on a mage isn't going do be nearly as useful as valor on a melee that can negate damage both with valor and resists, a mage has ONLY valor that really helps, as armour value is the only thing that handles physical damage negation. And mages have no armour, even with the archon armour buff its pitifully low. And even though some melee abilities have magic damage procs, the majority of the damage a melee do is physical damage.

Yes i'm well aware that mages are glass cannons, but they seem to have forgot the cannon part. Even pyro is weak comparative to melee damage wise unless you spec for the one trick pony (insta squirrel +50% damage cinder burst combo), that really only works in 1v1 situations and is even more squishy then normal because one has to give up so many points better spent in survivability talents to get it.


The only mage soul that stands a real chance against a properly specced and played melee is a 51 point specced warlock.

Melee IS going to get nerfed, there is no question about it. I just hope they do it before the end of the free month so ppl have an incentive to stay rather then go back to fucking WoW most likely never to come back.
 

BloodOmen

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
18,132
But you seem to forget that all our really hard nukes have 2 seconds or more cast time (4.2 for the really kickass one even after talented to be faster), meaning that those extra 10 yards means fuck all as a champion will guaranteed have the in combat bull rush talent, and an assortment of talents that breaks him free of CC's.

And from a melee vs caster point of view, valor on a mage isn't going do be nearly as useful as valor on a melee that can negate damage both with valor and resists, a mage has ONLY valor that really helps, as armour value is the only thing that handles physical damage negation. And mages have no armour, even with the archon armour buff its pitifully low. And even though some melee abilities have magic damage procs, the majority of the damage a melee do is physical damage.

Yes i'm well aware that mages are glass cannons, but they seem to have forgot the cannon part. Even pyro is weak comparative to melee damage wise unless you spec for the one trick pony (insta squirrel +50% damage cinder burst combo), that really only works in 1v1 situations and is even more squishy then normal because one has to give up so many points better spent in survivability talents to get it.


The only mage soul that stands a real chance against a properly specced and played melee is a 51 point specced warlock.

Melee IS going to get nerfed, there is no question about it. I just hope they do it before the end of the free month so ppl have an incentive to stay rather then go back to fucking WoW most likely never to come back.

You can chain CC tho no? if champs are specced as high as Destroyer's Bearing (which the hard hitting ones will be thats 51 points down the drain) they'll only have 1 charge and 1 pvp trinket, they should be easily locked down or knocked back (myesss elementalist remember? pew pew knockback) the only warrior soul that knockback is useless for is Paragon because they get a buff that makes them immune to it.

And all that said if they nerf champs they need to nerf mages because as said in another thread I have been hit for 2900 by a mage (which is harder than any champ i've seen hit) not sure whats so hard to grasp about it all really... warrior + 2handed weapon + cloth ofcourse they're going to hit hard, they're always going to hit hard vs you and no amount of nerfing is going to fix that. And if on the offchance they did nerf them to the point where they couldn't even touch a clothie damage wise congratulations your constant whining and moaning has ruined a class.
 

ECA

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Dec 23, 2003
Messages
9,452
Same failing as DCU, endgame is a planned out geargrind rather than anything fun/challenging.
 

BloodOmen

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
18,132
Same failing as DCU, endgame is a planned out geargrind rather than anything fun/challenging.

its not as bad as DCU was, you'll always have to work for gear ECU :p the thing with this is do you want to grind Favor or grind experts from Plaques :)
 

ECA

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Dec 23, 2003
Messages
9,452
It's not quite as shallow as DCU but basically very similar, it will take you a similar amount of time to grind the PVE Gear ( hardmodes vs T1 experts ) and PVP set will take quite a bit longer, but it doesn't make it much different.


DCU had a less lag dependant combat system also.
 

Ctuchik

FH is my second home
Joined
Dec 23, 2003
Messages
10,466
You can chain CC tho no? if champs are specced as high as Destroyer's Bearing (which the hard hitting ones will be thats 51 points down the drain) they'll only have 1 charge and 1 pvp trinket, they should be easily locked down or knocked back (myesss elementalist remember? pew pew knockback) the only warrior soul that knockback is useless for is Paragon because they get a buff that makes them immune to it.

And all that said if they nerf champs they need to nerf mages because as said in another thread I have been hit for 2900 by a mage (which is harder than any champ i've seen hit) not sure whats so hard to grasp about it all really... warrior + 2handed weapon + cloth ofcourse they're going to hit hard, they're always going to hit hard vs you and no amount of nerfing is going to fix that. And if on the offchance they did nerf them to the point where they couldn't even touch a clothie damage wise congratulations your constant whining and moaning has ruined a class.

The difference between melee critting for 2900+ damage and a mage critting for 2900 is still that the mage needs a cast time and can be interrupted, a melee only need 1 or 2 global cooldowns worth of instants. And at least heavy spec champions can get on demand crits, a mage can't get that no matter what. So a mage critting for 2900+ damage is lucky, a champion can crit by just timing his abilities right. I mean, YOU posted a screenshot of a 2.4k titan strike crit claiming melee > casters...

Yes melee's can theoretically be chain CC'd, but almost all CC's have either a annoyingly long cooldown, requires a cast time, has a really short duration (8 - 12 seconds) is ground targetted or even channeled. But all but one root breaks on damage, a select few has a chance to break, so sometimes actually works, but those are in stormcaller, one of the worst survivability trees out there for mages and requires some heavy dedication to the tree.

Look, i know you play a warrior so probably have a hard time seeing the imbalance, but dedicate a few weeks to play a mage and i'm pretty sure you will see what i mean. Personally i'm leveling a warrior and to be honest i don't fear anything in terms of pvp now.
 

BloodOmen

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
18,132
The difference between melee critting for 2900+ damage and a mage critting for 2900 is still that the mage needs a cast time and can be interrupted, a melee only need 1 or 2 global cooldowns worth of instants. And at least heavy spec champions can get on demand crits, a mage can't get that no matter what. So a mage critting for 2900+ damage is lucky, a champion can crit by just timing his abilities right. I mean, YOU posted a screenshot of a 2.4k titan strike crit claiming melee > casters...

Yes melee's can theoretically be chain CC'd, but almost all CC's have either a annoyingly long cooldown, requires a cast time, has a really short duration (8 - 12 seconds) is ground targetted or even channeled. But all but one root breaks on damage, a select few has a chance to break, so sometimes actually works, but those are in stormcaller, one of the worst survivability trees out there for mages and requires some heavy dedication to the tree.

Look, i know you play a warrior so probably have a hard time seeing the imbalance, but dedicate a few weeks to play a mage and i'm pretty sure you will see what i mean. Personally i'm leveling a warrior and to be honest i don't fear anything in terms of pvp now.

Yes, and the difference is a melee can only do it once every 30 seconds and thats assuming they even have perfect timing (reduces the cooldown of proper timing to 30 seconds) mages can spam it through and through regardless of cast time, the problem with mages is they simply don't like the fact they've rolled a class they just can't button mash to win on which is obviously what they thought when they rolled them.

Mages are basicly crying nerf from solo/bad team play experiences, the game wasnt made for solo its made for team play, i've met plenty of mages I can charge into and titan strike and what happens when they have a team behind them? I get cc'd to high hell, stunned, knocked back, and the mages is healed up.

Champions are basicly a 1 trick pony at the moment, if they can't drop you after a titan strike they quite simply can't take you down with a proper healer backing you and the crit reduction from the PVP soul up because their normal melee hits are feeble in comparison with mage nukes (and don't give me the cast time arguement because it really doesnt wash given how much damage mages can do without the use of cooldowns)

Just face it a mages ideal world in this game is being able to faceroll the keys and kill any class without having any sort of mental challenge, as it has been in 99% of mmo's since DAOC.


p.s I love it how mages cry about champs yet ignore sabo's and paragons :) makes me chuckle abit in side, sabo's with their 1 second GCD charges vs 1.5 second GCD dispels + 5000 detonates and paragon for their 51 pointer while wielding 2 good weapons, makes them cc immune while active.
 

BloodOmen

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
18,132
Decided to cancel my subs because the warfronts get boring way to fast, will renew in a heart beat if they add a dedicated rvr zone.
 

Madmaxx

FH is my second home
Joined
Feb 14, 2009
Messages
2,934
yeah, its funny how I'm taking my time and only lvl40. But people who are 50 are doing all the same 1-10,10-20 dungeons just in "expert" difficulty. And the same warfronts at level 50. I dont know if I'll hit 50 now it's pointless doing the same dungeon over and over, eve if it is harder.
 

BloodOmen

I am a FH squatter
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
18,132
yeah, its funny how I'm taking my time and only lvl40. But people who are 50 are doing all the same 1-10,10-20 dungeons just in "expert" difficulty. And the same warfronts at level 50. I dont know if I'll hit 50 now it's pointless doing the same dungeon over and over, eve if it is harder.

nah the dungeons arent so bad, they arent the same at 50 :p they have new bosses in them on expert, I actually liked the way they did it.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom