a theory r.e. the dinosaurs

Ezteq

Queen of OT
Joined
Jan 4, 2004
Messages
13,457
A topic I am very interested in, I shant say that I am an expert on the subject but it is something I know a fair bit about and enjoy a great deal.

I have been to a few dinosaur museums and lectures about them, seen jurassic park and its offspring several hundred times and read a whole pile of books about them and it is generally accepted now that some dinosaurs evolved in to birds, there is evidence that a great deal of Chinese dinosaurs actually had feathers and the bone structure of some dinosaurs is very similar to that of birds.

The question that popped in to my head as I lay trying to get to sleep the other night was would dinosaurs have sung like birds? (This was not a totally random thought, we had spent the day fossil hunting in Lyme Regis and I had also been to a dino museum, additionally there was a blackbird belting out the avian equivilant of "I will survive" right outside my window).

It is pretty much impossible to determine certain facts about the creatures, their colour for example, but I was wondering if any of you knew of any examples of fossils being found that indicated the kind of sound made by dinosaurs (there was a theory a few years ago that T Rex actually made a bubbling belching sound more than the gut twisting roar we'd imagine).

I just thought this was an interesting thought and next time I go to one of the lectures I'll try to snag the right bod and ask them what they think, it is kind of sweet to imagine dinosaurs singing like giant birds though it may only have been possible with the smaller species because with birds the larger they are the less finesse they have when calling...ostriches arn't particularly likely to win anything at the MTV awards tbh (though imo they would look better in a leotard than madonna).
 

Iceforge

Can't get enough of FH
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
1,861
A topic I am very interested in, I shant say that I am an expert on the subject but it is something I know a fair bit about and enjoy a great deal.

I have been to a few dinosaur museums and lectures about them, seen jurassic park and its offspring several hundred times and read a whole pile of books about them and it is generally accepted now that some dinosaurs evolved in to birds, there is evidence that a great deal of Chinese dinosaurs actually had feathers and the bone structure of some dinosaurs is very similar to that of birds.

The question that popped in to my head as I lay trying to get to sleep the other night was would dinosaurs have sung like birds? (This was not a totally random thought, we had spent the day fossil hunting in Lyme Regis and I had also been to a dino museum, additionally there was a blackbird belting out the avian equivilant of "I will survive" right outside my window).

It is pretty much impossible to determine certain facts about the creatures, their colour for example, but I was wondering if any of you knew of any examples of fossils being found that indicated the kind of sound made by dinosaurs (there was a theory a few years ago that T Rex actually made a bubbling belching sound more than the gut twisting roar we'd imagine).

I just thought this was an interesting thought and next time I go to one of the lectures I'll try to snag the right bod and ask them what they think, it is kind of sweet to imagine dinosaurs singing like giant birds though it may only have been possible with the smaller species because with birds the larger they are the less finesse they have when calling...ostriches arn't particularly likely to win anything at the MTV awards tbh (though imo they would look better in a leotard than madonna).

I dont know if they sung like birds, but I do know that scientists are able to see what kind of sounds was produced by dinosaurs, as they can find evidence for what kind of noises they was able to create with the throats and such.

And I am quite sure, but not 100%, that they did NOT sing like birds, because then scientists would have gone public with that long ago as to further prove the thesis about dinosaurs evolving into birds.
 

Lucius

Banned
Joined
Apr 1, 2008
Messages
679
Did you watch Prehistoric Park? I know not enitrely Dinosaurs but an amazing watch.

On topic, I'm not so sure, I always thought the sounds in the modern movies and documentaries are pretty accurate but that's probably a bit of a bad assumption.
 

Ezteq

Queen of OT
Joined
Jan 4, 2004
Messages
13,457
thats the thing, we think that there is a lot known about dinosaurs and other prehistoric beasties but really what we actually know as fact is miniscule, and some things that we declared fact have been totally disproven.

Lucius you can pretty much guarentee that if its prehistoric i'll watch it lol

i dont know why but this question both excites and amuses me a great deal and i would love to find an answer.
 

tris-

Failed Geordie and Parmothief
Joined
Jan 2, 2004
Messages
15,260
a mumified dino was found not long ago.
google it and see whats going down with that. i dont know if the insides were preserved or what.
 

Ezteq

Queen of OT
Joined
Jan 4, 2004
Messages
13,457
yeah a hadrosaur i think it was just the outer skin etc that was preserved but it'd be cool to see if vocal chords survided and if you can tell what sound a creature makes just from its vocal chords
 

tris-

Failed Geordie and Parmothief
Joined
Jan 2, 2004
Messages
15,260
found this

ScienceDaily (Jun. 5, 2007) — What did dinosaurs hear? Probably a lot of low frequency sounds, like the heavy footsteps of another dinosaur, if University of Maryland professor Robert Dooling and his colleagues are right. What they likely couldn’t hear were the high pitched sounds that birds make.
What Did Dinosaurs Hear?

so they couldnt hear the types of sounds birds make so its possible they didnt make those sounds, because they wouldnt be able to communicate.
 

Ezteq

Queen of OT
Joined
Jan 4, 2004
Messages
13,457
rofl well tbh they were about the same size...

nice find there young tris, well done.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom